ArbNation Join free

Planting too deep: buried root flare, as extension services describe it

A tree set too deep has no visible flare where the trunk meets the soil. Maryland, Nebraska, Iowa State and Illinois extension describe the signs, the causes and the look-alikes.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Four extension services describe planting depth. It is not training and does not teach the work. The related guide on planting depth and root flare covers the measurements.

What the flare looks like

Nebraska Extension calls a tree planted at the correct depth easy to spot. The sides of the trunk flare out where trunk becomes root, and the flare sits at the soil surface. The tops of the first roots may show at the soil line. A trunk that goes straight into the soil like a telephone pole, with little or no flare, is too deep. Iowa State Extension puts it the same way: if the trunk flare cannot be seen at the base, the tree is planted too deeply.

The University of Maryland Extension adds that a flare which cannot be seen should raise suspicion of deep planting or of another problem such as girdling roots. Illinois Extension describes the flare as the part of the trunk that starts to taper out as trunk tissue turns into root tissue.

How trees end up too deep

  • Per Nebraska Extension, young whips planted mechanically in fields go deep so that they stand upright, and trees often start too deep in the field.
  • Pot-grown trees are sometimes set too deep in the soil of the container.
  • Many trees are planted in a hole no wider than the root ball, with no soil taken off the top of the ball. The actual depth of the flare inside a balled and burlapped root ball is not known, Nebraska notes, so the depth may still be wrong.
  • Illinois Extension calls digging a hole that is too deep the most common planting mistake. The depth of the original container or root ball is misleading, it adds, because the flare is commonly buried in the pot or down in the root ball.
  • Maryland Extension notes that mulch piled on top adds to the problem. It is not uncommon to see trees planted three or more inches too deep with mulch over them.

Signs on the tree

Signs of deep planting in the extension pages
SourceSigns and effects described
University of Maryland ExtensionA depth of only one inch too deep can cause trouble. Bark deteriorates at the soil line and can eventually kill the plant, usually over a few seasons. Some new growth appears each spring and dies back in summer stress. Advanced signs are cankers and deep bark cracking. Bark that peels near cracks is a problem sign, since some shallow cracking is normal. Trees look as if they struggle to grow. A tree may last until fall and not survive winter because of low food reserves.
Nebraska ExtensionRoot growth is reduced and tree health is compromised for the rest of the tree's life. Planting depth was not recognized as a major tree health problem until recent years, Nebraska notes.
Iowa State ExtensionProblems often do not show up until several years after planting. Limb dieback is the effect named.
Illinois ExtensionTrees planted too deep struggle to establish and often have a lifetime of issues. Most potted or balled and burlapped trees have up to three years of transplant shock.

Maryland Extension notes that residents seldom link a tree's decline to how it was planted, because death takes a few seasons.

Look-alikes and fixes in the extension pages

Maryland Extension names girdling roots as another problem to suspect when the root flare is not visible. Nebraska Extension notes that girdling roots that could have been removed before planting are not found when excess soil stays on the root ball.

Maryland holds that a newly planted tree set too deep can be lifted and replanted, and that root collar excavation can sometimes help. It describes an air spade used by arborists to remove soil and mulch down to the flare with little root disturbance, and recommends the procedure for valuable or specimen trees. For Iowa State, replanting may be possible for a newly planted tree, meaning one in the ground a year or maybe two, or one not yet fully established in the surrounding soil. Past that, trees are often too large to replant at a higher level, and the only way to prevent limb dieback is correct depth at planting. Iowa State also notes that loose soil at the bottom of the hole can settle, letting the flare sink after planting. See root collar excavation.

Sources