Biochar in tree planting soils: what three published trials report
A Toronto greenhouse trial, a Stockholm roadside planting and a four-year roadside experiment each tested biochar in tree soil. Growth rose in two of them. The Stockholm trial also found cracked bark and lower leaf phosphorus.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Three trials published between 2023 and 2025 put biochar into soil for urban trees. They differ in setting, species, biochar rate and length. Only one ran in a greenhouse. The other two followed trees planted along roads.
The three trials
| Trial | Setting | Length |
|---|---|---|
| Sifton, Smith and Thomas, PLoS One, 2023 | Greenhouse pots, silver maple | 3 months |
| Fransson and Andreasson, Linnaeus University, 2023 | Stockholm roadside, sweet cherry | 6 years |
| Seo and others, EGU General Assembly, 2025 | Roadside field experiment, 30 trees per treatment | 4 years |
Silver maple in a greenhouse, University of Toronto
Sifton, Smith and Thomas of the University of Toronto grew one-year-old silver maple saplings in a calcareous loam topsoil stripped from a construction site in Whitby, Ontario. The soil had a pH of 7.1. The trial ran three months from May to August 2018, with 13 pots in each of nine treatments.
The treatments paired two wood biochars, a granulated conifer biochar and a loose sugar maple sawdust biochar, with two biofertilizers: an inactivated yeast and the bacterium Bacillus velezensis. Both biochars were made by slow pyrolysis at about 700 degrees C. The rate was 40 g of biochar per 2500 ml of soil, which the authors put at about 20 t/ha by weight per area.
Dry mass beat the control by a statistically significant margin where biochar was combined with a biofertilizer, and with the inactivated yeast alone. The largest gain was 91 percent over the control, for sugar maple biochar with the inactivated yeast. Every biochar treatment, alone or combined, produced taller saplings than the control. Diameter at the base showed no significant difference among treatments. Leaf copper fell with sugar maple biochar alone, with the yeast alone and with the yeast plus bacterium.
The authors call this the first test of these biochars with these bacteria, and they recommend field trials in more seriously degraded urban soils.
Sweet cherry along a Stockholm street, Linnaeus University and SLU
Fransson and Andreasson followed Prunus avium 'Plena' trees on Herrhagsvagen in Enskede, Stockholm. The City of Stockholm planted them in 2 by 2 by 1 m pits in strips of three substrates. One was a standard urban planting soil and one the same soil mixed with 50 percent pulverized biochar by volume. The third was gravel with a 50 percent biochar soil mixture at the surface. The biochar came from deciduous wood pyrolyzed at 550 degrees C, with a pH of 8.
Table I of the paper lists the biochar trees as planted in November and December 2010, a year after the other two groups. Ten trees stood in the control soil, ten in biochar and six in gravel. All received watering and fertilizer for the first two seasons, and none afterwards.
Stem circumference after four years was 36.2 cm in the control, 35.5 cm in gravel and 49.0 cm with biochar. The paper calls the biochar trees 35 percent larger in circumference. The abstract puts the same 35 percent at six years, so the two parts of the paper print different ages for one figure.
Crowns were about 20 percent wider with biochar, 5.2 m against 4.3 m. Tree height did not differ, at 6.1 m with biochar and 6.4 m in the control. Shoots were longer with biochar in 2012 and 2013 and equal from 2014. Visual vitality and leaf fluorescence showed no difference.
Leaf nitrogen was higher with biochar, 2.19 against 1.87 mg per g, and leaf phosphorus was lower, 0.33 against 0.47 mg per g. The authors read the nitrogen result as a sign that nitrogen limited growth. The biochar trees dropped their leaves later and had cracks in the bark of the stem, which the authors say might point to problems preparing for winter.
The authors add that six years is short against a tree's lifespan, and that gravel-planted trees grew as large as those in the control soil, which raises the question of whether the planting soil was a good medium.
Roadside trees in a four-year field experiment, Kyung Hee University
The third source is a conference abstract from Kyung Hee University, presented at the EGU General Assembly in 2025 and licensed CC BY 4.0. The team planted 30 six-year-old trees of representative roadside species in each of a control and a biochar treatment. Wood chip biochar at 4 percent of soil mass went into two subsoil layers, at 15 to 25 cm and 30 to 45 cm.
The abstract reports that biochar halved the tree defect rate in the first growing season and halved final tree mortality after four years. The authors suggest the lower first-season defect rate could come from biochar keeping soil water in an adequate range, particularly in the dry season of March to May, and they report a larger plant-available water range with biochar. The site had a monsoon climate, and days when soil water content passed field capacity were 5.6 times more frequent in the control. Coarse and fine root dry biomass were marginally higher with biochar. The authors say further nutrient analysis is still to come.
Where the trials differ
The greenhouse trial measured saplings for three months. The Stockholm trees were measured at four and six years, and the roadside experiment at four years. The first two used about 20 t/ha and 50 percent by volume respectively, and the third used 4 percent by soil mass. Rates, species and soils are not comparable across the three. Biochar as a waste product, and the standards for it, are on biochar in urban tree soils and biochar standards and rules.
Sources
- Sifton MA, Smith SM, Thomas SC, Biochar-biofertilizer combinations enhance growth and nutrient uptake in silver maple grown in an urban soil, PLoS One 18(7):e0288291, July 18, 2023, read October 19, 2026
- Seo I, Jeong M, Park YL, Yoo G, Biochar application can decrease urban trees' defect rate and mortality after transplanting by optimizing soil water condition, EGU General Assembly 2025, EGU25-19162, CC BY 4.0, read October 19, 2026
- Fransson A-M, Andreasson F, Biochar improves the growth of urban sweet cherry, Sustainable Built Environment and Urban Transition conference, Linnaeus University, October 12-13, 2023, CC BY 4.0, read October 19, 2026