ArbNation Join free

Buying a tree from a nursery: what the ISA brochure and the stock standard cover

The International Society of Arboriculture sums up tree quality as form, injuries and roots, FIR for short. The American nursery stock standard, Z60.2, gives buyers and sellers one set of terms for measuring and sizing plants.

This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) brochure Buying High-Quality Trees, hosted by University of Wisconsin Extension in Kenosha County, sets out what separates a high-quality tree from a low-quality one at the point of sale. AmericanHort, the sponsor of the American Standard for Nursery Stock, describes the standard buyers and sellers use for plant size and root balls.

High-quality and low-quality trees

The brochure says a high-quality tree has strong form, with well-spaced, firmly attached branches, a trunk free of wounds or damage, and a quality root system. A low-quality tree has weak form: several stems start at the same point and branches grow into each other. Its trunk has wounds from handling or incorrect pruning, and its roots are limited, crushed or circling in an undersized root ball or container. Problems alone or together can cut a tree's prospects. A low-quality tree may develop costly problems and need more maintenance, while a high-quality tree may become a long-lasting asset to the property.

Form

The brochure warns that the branches on a young shade tree may not be there at maturity. Many lower branches get shaded out or pruned away for clearance, and many nurseries prune young trees to spur crown growth, which can lead to corrective pruning later. Good form starts with branches evenly spaced along the trunk and firmly attached. Very upright branches with narrow attachment angles may cause trouble as they grow into the trunk. Branches that press against the trunk or each other signal problems, since the contact areas may compress, crack or die back. Several branches at one point on the trunk make weak attachments, compression and cracks far more likely.

For a multi-trunk tree, the trunks should be well separated at the ground line, because trunks expand in girth and squeeze together.

Injuries

The brochure says never to buy a tree without thoroughly checking the trunk. Wrap can protect a trunk in transit and should be removed after planting. Under it, the trunk can show wounds, incorrect pruning cuts and insect injuries. Cuts that remove or injure the swollen collar at the base of a branch may lead to canker, decay and cracking. A stub prevents the tree from recovering from the cut. A flush cut can kill trunk tissue above and below it, and cracks or long dead streaks may follow in high summer or low winter temperatures.

Roots by type of stock

The brochure sorts nursery trees by how they are grown, harvested and sold, and each has its own root problems.

Nursery stock types and root signs in the ISA brochure
Stock typeWhat it isRoot signs the brochure names
Bare rootNo soil around the roots; usually small treesRoots crushed, torn, dried out or discolored. Root ends should be cleanly cut.
Balled and burlappedRoots of field-grown trees held in soil with burlap and wire or ropeTrunk flare visible at the top of the ball. Top of the ball flat, since rounding may mean major woody root loss. Ball diameter at least 10 to 12 times the trunk diameter measured six inches (15 cm) above the flare.
ContainerRoots and soil in a containerRoots twisting or circling in the container, which may girdle and kill other roots or the whole tree if they wrap the lower trunk. Trunk flare visible.

The brochure adds that fine circling roots may be cut away at planting, and larger ones straightened if still flexible. A buried trunk flare on a container tree should be gently exposed before planting. The roots of different stock types have their own page in bare root, balled and burlapped, container and air-pot trees, and circling roots in container trees covers that fault.

The nursery stock standard

AmericanHort's standard page says the purpose of the American Standard for Nursery Stock is to give buyers and sellers a common terminology for transactions. The standard sets common techniques for measuring plants, stating plant size, relating height to caliper or height to width, and judging whether a root ball or container is large enough for a plant of a given size. The standard is meant for professional horticulturists and landscape architects who understand common horticultural terms.

The association has been involved in the standard since 1921, and the first edition, Horticultural Standards, appeared in 1923. The first edition under American Standards Association procedures followed on June 22, 1949. The 2005 to 2013 revision produced ANSI Z60.1, approved in April 2014. A revision between January 2024 and April 2025 produced ANSI Z60.2, officially approved on April 12, 2025. The final canvass ballots showed unanimous approval.

AmericanHort's operating procedures for the standard, revised November 18, 2022 and still headed Z60.1, keep commercial terms out of the standard: guarantees, warranties and other conditions between buyer and seller are not included. Written requests for an interpretation go to AmericanHort's designated standards representative. Oral requests get no interpretation.

Plant names used in nurseries are in nursery stock names.

Who to call

Sources