ArbNation Join free

Climbing and felling ash dieback trees: what Forestry Commission Operations Notes 46 and 46a say

Forestry Commission Operations Note 46 says ash colonised by Armillaria can pose risks to forest workers within two years of basal necrosis forming. Note 46a says only trained and experienced tree surgeons or forestry workers should work on obviously affected ash.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.

The two notes

The Forestry Commission publishes two operations notes on ash dieback, the disease caused by Hymenoscyphus fraxineus. Operations Note 46, dated 20 September 2018, covers ash in woodlands. Operations Note 46a, version 1.0 issued 7 August 2019, covers individual ash trees and small groups. Note 46a defines a small group as an area of trees less than 20 metres wide and less than 0.5 hectares.

The GOV.UK page for Note 46a was first published on 9 August 2019 and last updated on 4 August 2026, when an accessible version of the example tree inspection checklist was added. Scottish Forestry carries its own guidance on individual ash trees in Scotland, last updated 15 May 2026. Its summary describes advice for householders and practitioners responsible for individual and small groups of ash, such as those in hedgerows, verges, church yards, gardens and parks. The summary adds that it can also be used for ash in woodland that poses a risk to public safety.

Worker risk in Operations Note 46

Note 46 expects public safety to be one of the biggest management issues for woodland ash owners. Infected trees are likely to carry considerable dead wood in the crown. Trees infected at the base by the fungus and by secondary pathogens may rapidly lose structural integrity and anchorage because of butt and root rot.

The note gives an example. Ash colonised by Armillaria begin to pose risks to forest workers and visitors within two years of basal necrosis forming. After five years, about half of the affected trees are likely to have enough decay to be assumed hazardous.

The note says special care may be needed during felling because infected trees may react unpredictably, a particular concern where felling is manual. It states that the primary consideration is whether the job can be done by other means. Its best control measure is mechanical harvesting equipment with the operator in a protective cab, with care not to damage woodland soils. Where that is not possible, it says it is more important than ever that a chainsaw operator is both competent and properly equipped. It notes that the Forest Industry Safety Accord (FISA) has produced ash-specific guidance for forest managers.

Worker risk in Operations Note 46a

Note 46a cautions that poor canopy condition may not come from ash dieback. Drought stress, waterlogging, root damage and other pests and diseases can also stress ash. Where dieback is the cause, the note says the structural integrity and inherent strength of the tree may be severely affected by the disease and by secondary pests or pathogens. These may create high risk felling conditions for any operators working on or adjacent to the tree.

The note then states that only trained and experienced tree surgeons or forestry workers should undertake work on ash showing obvious or advanced signs of dieback. Its section on managing individual trees names deadwood removal, crown reduction or pollarding, and felling as the work that could be needed. Before listing them, it refers to assessing the health and safety risks of working off the ground in potentially weakened ash. It says pruning and felling should be done by suitably qualified and experienced tree surgeons.

Note 46a advises a precautionary view of the health and safety implications for contractors managing or felling infected ash, because the risks are not yet well understood. The strength of the timber in an affected tree is hard to assess. Failure of a tree or part of it has a more immediate impact in high risk locations beside highways, network infrastructure and public spaces. Because suitably trained contractors with appropriate machinery are limited, the note puts the highest risk locations first.

Licences and the dangerous tree exception

Section 9(4)(a) of the Forestry Act 1967 says a felling licence is not required for felling to prevent danger or to prevent or abate a nuisance. Note 46a gives the Commission's interpretation of that exception for ash. It says the exception is for exceptional circumstances with an obvious danger, and an approved felling licence is the normal route where one is needed.

The note lists four criteria that must all be met for the exception to apply to an ash tree:

  • The tree already shows dieback symptoms.
  • It is within falling distance, meaning its total height, of a highway, service network, built infrastructure or a space with frequent public use.
  • The greater part of the crown is dead.
  • Crown reduction work needed to remove the deadwood would, in the opinion of a qualified professional, cause significant harm to the tree's vitality or visual amenity.

A tree with basal lesions, with or without secondary infection such as honey fungus, also falls within the exception. The note adds that the presence of ash dieback does not in itself give authority to fell without a felling licence.

Where else the notes point

Note 46a refers to the UK Forest Industry Safety Accord guidance for managers on felling ash dieback affected trees, the National Tree Safety Group booklet Common sense risk management of trees, and an example tree inspection checklist in its appendix 1. Related reading: the guide to felling dead and dying ash, the guide to ash dieback and the guide to ash dieback as a regulated disease.

Sources