Construction damage to trees: what long-term studies report on decline after building work
A 1976 Delaware study followed 886 trees beside building work and found 35 percent survived. A 2022 Philadelphia campus study counted 1,427 removals over 11 years, 48.5 percent tied to construction.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Delaware, 1972 to 1975
Peter K. O'Rourke's 1976 master's thesis at the University of Delaware observed 886 deciduous trees beside construction activity. The activity included excavation, fill application, paving and wound damage. The study followed nine tree species at 13 sites in northern New Castle County, Delaware, from 1972 to 1975, and measured construction impact as tree survival.
Across all trees, 35 percent survived. Sweetgum and red maple were more tolerant of construction. Black oak, beech and yellow poplar were particularly vulnerable. Thinning, excavation and fill damage were the primary causes of decline, and lowered water tables were suspected to harm tree health.
The thesis concludes that the nature of construction processes at the time was not predisposed to tree maintenance and protection. It sees little practical value in remedial suggestions made tree by tree. Residual groups of trees thrive despite adjacent construction, and the author suggests such groups may be the most effective means of protecting trees from land development.
Philadelphia campus, 2003 to 2014
Lara Roman of the USDA Forest Service and co-authors studied a highly urbanized college campus in Philadelphia, published in Forests in 2022. They linked two tree inventories 11 years apart, from 2003 and 2014, with institutional records and an account from the University Landscape Architect.
The core campus held 3,694 live trees in both years. A total of 1,427 trees were removed in the period, which is 38.5 percent of the 2003 live trees. The annual mortality rate was 4.3 percent. The 1,427 new plantings exactly equaled the trees lost.
Of the removals, 29.9 percent came from capital projects and another 18.6 percent from other construction, together 48.5 percent. Tree health decline and risk management accounted for 48.7 percent. Other human land use decisions caused 2.0 percent, and 0.9 percent had unknown causes. The authors attribute the high annual rate to construction pressure and proactive management that removes unhealthy trees promptly.
Construction caused the removal of 53.6 percent of lawn trees but 25.4 percent of street trees. Capital projects in the study are renovation or construction work costing US$100,000 or more.
The paper cites other cities. Building permits were associated with tree mortality in Toronto. Building and road construction were related to declining tree density in Mississauga. Major development projects caused tree removal and canopy loss in Melbourne, and building demolition after an earthquake drove canopy loss in Christchurch.
A review of 56 mortality studies
Hilbert and colleagues reviewed urban tree mortality in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in 2019. They summarised rates from 56 studies of trees along streets, in yards and in landscaped parks. Annual mortality ranged from 0.6 to 68.5 percent in planting cohort studies and from 0 to 30 percent in repeated inventories of uneven-aged trees.
The review lists construction and redevelopment activity as a human factor in 6 articles. Roman's paper reads this as 15 percent of the quantitative mortality studies and suggests construction may play a larger role than that, particularly in urban cores.
Two of the reviewed studies compared trees with and without construction, both on Milwaukee street trees. Hauer and colleagues in 1994 compared the survival of 432 street trees damaged by construction with 413 not damaged, over 10 years, and the review records construction damage as a negative factor. Koeser and colleagues in 2013 tracked 793 street trees aged 0 to 10 years, of which 402 were beside construction and 391 were not. The same study followed 895 trees aged 11 to 25 years, of which 219 were beside construction and 686 were not. The review lists being adjacent to construction as a negative factor.
Miller and Miller in 1991 compared redeveloped and non-redeveloped parts of Milwaukee. The review records the redeveloped area as a negative factor.
Site conditions behind these figures are covered in the guide to construction damage and grade change and the guide to soil compaction.
Sources
- Peter K. O'Rourke, The effect of manifest construction activities on survival of deciduous trees in New Castle County, Delaware, University of Delaware master's thesis, 1976, abstract, read October 19, 2026
- Roman, Fristensky, Lundgren, Cerwinka and Lubar, Construction and Proactive Management Led to Tree Removals on an Urban College Campus, Forests 13(6):871, June 1, 2022 (CC BY), read October 19, 2026
- Hilbert, Roman, Koeser, Vogt and van Doorn, Urban Tree Mortality: A Literature Review, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 45(5):167-200, September 2019 (USDA Forest Service PDF), read October 19, 2026