ArbNation Join free

Continuous planting trenches and planting strips: what city manuals specify

Seattle sets 1,200 cubic feet of soil per street tree, Toronto 30 m3 in a continuous soil trench, and New York City prints trench volumes by length. Vancouver, Washington gives strip widths only.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. Four city documents describe continuous planting trenches or planting strips for street trees. Each is summarised from the document itself.

The four cities side by side

Widths and soil volumes in four city documents
CityWidth or stripSoil volume
New York City, 2008Ideal pit 4 by 10 ft or 5 by 10 ftNo cubic minimum stated; 800 to 1400 cu ft in a 100 ft trench
Seattle, 2017Planting strip 5 ft 6 in clear, 6 ft to the curb face1,200 cf per tree
Toronto, 2022Public boulevard at least 5.00 m30 m3 minimum per tree
Vancouver, Washington, 2011Strips of 4 ft and of 6 to 8 ftNo figure given

New York City Parks Tree Planting Standards

The New York City Department of Parks and Recreation issued its Tree Planting Standards in April 2008. They ask for tree pits as large as possible, with 4 by 10 feet or 5 by 10 feet as the ideal sizes. Sidewalk width can limit pit size.

Parks encourages continuous tree pits, and designs with continuous pits may get more flexible spacing. Pits must be continuous wherever trees are grouped. A continuous pit means two or more trees in a single sidewalk trench at least 30 feet long. The standards list shared soil volume and less soil compaction among the benefits of grouping.

A sample configuration sheet gives surface area and soil volume for pits 4, 5, 6 and 7 feet wide, all worked at a pit depth of 2 feet. A 100 foot trench holds 800 cubic feet at 4 feet wide, 1000 at 5 feet, 1200 at 6 feet and 1400 at 7 feet. The sheet describes these long pits as underground trenches usually treated with structural soil below ground and sidewalk pavement above, except around the tree.

The standards do not permit sidewalk-level tree grates and name granite paving as the alternative. Brick or concrete tree wells are not to be installed.

Seattle Right-of-Way Improvements Manual, section 3.7

Seattle's section 3.7 on street trees, last updated June 9, 2017, calls for 5 feet 6 inches clear between the back of the sidewalk and the inside edge of the curb, which is 6 feet to the curb face. It puts the tree centreline 3 feet 6 inches from the curb face and 2 feet from the sidewalk edge.

Tree pits are the alternative in business districts. A pit has a minimum of 24 square feet of open area, usually 4 by 6 feet or 5 by 5 feet. Smaller pits go to site-specific review.

For soil, the section calls for 1,200 cubic feet per tree to meet industry standards for street trees in urban areas. Where planting strips cannot supply it, the manual points to structural soils and soil cells to increase volume and connect root zones under paving. Structural soil needs four times the volume of soil cells to match the usable amount. A minimum of 5 feet of lateral clearance from underground utilities is required.

Toronto standard drawing T-850.183-1

Toronto's Engineering and Construction Services drawing T-850.183-1, revision 0 of April 2022, shows a continuous soil trench with soil cells and a tree grate. Its notes set soil volume at 30 m3 minimum per tree and tree openings at a minimum of 1500 mm by 1500 mm.

The plan view shows a minimum public boulevard width of 5.00 m, trees at 8.00 m on centre as the typical spacing, and a minimum pedestrian clearway of 2.10 m between the property line and the tree fence.

Vancouver, Washington Street Tree Manual

The City of Vancouver, Washington published its Street Tree Manual in 2011. It defines a planting strip as the area from the back of the curb to the front of the sidewalk, or the area in a raised median, used for grass or approved landscaping plants. The manual prints no soil volume.

It ties replacement tree size to strip width. A 4 foot planting strip takes a replacement tree of 1.5 inch caliper or larger, and a 6 to 8 foot strip takes 2 inches or larger. Where no planter strip exists, trees are set 3 feet behind the curb or sidewalk. The manual says wide planting strips are important if large street trees are to reach maturity without damaging sidewalks, curbs and streets.

Related guides

Soil volumes from other cities are in soil volume in city design standards. Pit and trench layouts are in tree pit designs for streets.

Sources