Cutting the wrong tree after a boundary-app or fence mistake: what surveyors and courts say
HM Land Registry says a boundary is an invisible line that only a court or tribunal can fix if disputed. Wisconsin surveyors say phone apps can be off by several dozen feet.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. It sets out what a land registry, a surveyors' body and a state surveying office publish about where a boundary lies and about phone mapping apps. None of them speaks to felling a tree.
A legal boundary and a physical boundary
HM Land Registry practice guide 40, supplement 3, applies to England and Wales. The word boundary has no special meaning in law, it explains, and can be used in two senses. A legal boundary is an imaginary line dividing one person's property from another's. It has no thickness or width, is rarely identified with precision on the ground or in conveyances, and is not shown on Ordnance Survey mapping.
A physical boundary is a feature that can be seen, such as a fence, wall or hedge. The legal boundary may run within the structure, along one side of it, or take in part of an adjoining road or stream. A hedge left untended can take root where it touches the ground and become very wide, which makes the original line hard to see.
The exact position of a disputed boundary can be determined only by the court or by the Land Registration division of the Property Chamber, First-tier Tribunal.
General boundaries on title plans
Under section 60(1) of the Land Registration Act 2002, the great majority of registered titles show only general boundaries. HM Land Registry completes a first registration without detailed enquiries about the precise location of the legal boundary. No standard tolerance, measurement or ratio links the general boundary on a title plan to the legal boundary. Case law sets no limit on the quantity of land that can fall within the general boundaries rule.
An owner who wants something more precise has two routes: a boundary agreement or a determined boundary application. The first always needs the agreement of the adjoining owners, and the second almost always does too.
Fence and wall beliefs
The guide takes up the idea that the way a fence is built shows who owns it, for example that posts and arris rails sit on the owner's side. It finds no legal foundation for such beliefs. Deed covenants to maintain a wall or fence do not on their own confer ownership. Ownership or maintenance of a boundary feature appears on the title only when the deeds lodged for registration refer to it.
Where ownership or responsibility cannot be determined, the guide says the feature is usually best regarded as a party boundary. Any alteration or replacement should only be done with the agreement of the adjoining owners. Deed plans may carry a T mark. An entry referring to one is normally a statement about who owns a boundary structure or must maintain it. T marks not referred to in the text of a deed have no special force in law.
Hedges, ditches and what a court weighs
For a plan that is unclear, the court can look at other evidence, in particular the physical features on the ground at the time. The question for the court is what the reasonable layperson would think they were buying. The parties' own intentions, beliefs and assumptions are irrelevant. The guide cites Cameron v Boggiano [2012] EWCA Civ 157 and Drake v Fripp [2011] EWCA Civ 1279.
It also lists presumptions that other evidence may rebut. Where a hedge or bank sits beside an artificial ditch, the boundary is presumed to run along the edge of the ditch furthest from the hedge or bank. That presumption does not apply to a natural ditch, or where both sides were in common ownership when the feature was made.
What RICS publishes
The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) publishes Boundaries: procedures for boundary identification, demarcation and dispute resolution, 4th edition, dated October 21, 2022. It was first published in February 2021 as a guidance note and reissued in October 2022 as a professional standard. The regulatory requirements stayed the same, RICS notes.
The RICS summary describes boundary disputes as costly, traumatic and time-consuming, ending at times in expensive legal cases. The new edition puts more emphasis on mediation. The standard itself is a PDF download.
Phone apps and boundary lines
The State Cartographer's Office at the University of Wisconsin-Madison states that phone GPS lacks the accuracy and precision that land surveying needs. It reports a 2022 case in which a Wisconsin landowner used a phone app to find what he took to be his boundary. The app put it 80 feet from the previously surveyed line. He took the earlier survey to be wrong and removed the iron markers at the corners, which the office describes as a violation of state law.
The Wisconsin Society of Land Surveyors and the Wisconsin County Surveyors Association issued a statement on May 15, 2023 about recreational apps used for hunting, fishing, biking and hiking. Such apps give an approximate position relative to boundary lines. Assuming the apps can locate property lines accurately can lead to misunderstandings, disputes between adjoining landowners and possible litigation.
The statement gives these reasons for naming a licensed Professional Land Surveyor as the person who locates property lines.
- Education: surveyors are trained in legal principles and boundary control, and apply deed data.
- Licensing: Wisconsin licenses surveyors to locate and mark property corners, and the resulting survey maps become public records.
- Equipment: survey-grade GPS measures to the nearest eighth of an inch, while a typical phone app can be off by several dozen feet.
- Process: surveyors research the client's deed, the adjoining owner's deeds and earlier survey records.
The statement describes the apps' parcel lines as drawn from available and often ambiguous digital mapping sources.
Sources
- HM Land Registry, Plans: boundaries, practice guide 40 supplement 3, Open Government Licence v3.0, read October 19, 2026
- RICS, Boundaries: procedures for boundary identification, demarcation and dispute resolution, 4th edition, October 21, 2022, read October 19, 2026
- State Cartographer's Office, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Can I survey my property with my smartphone? June 13, 2023, read October 19, 2026
- Wisconsin Society of Land Surveyors and Wisconsin County Surveyors Association, Cell phone apps white paper, V.8, May 15, 2023, read October 19, 2026