When a neighbour cuts or damages your tree: New York, Florida, Texas and Quebec
New York allows treble the stumpage value or US$250 per tree for cutting a tree on another's land without consent. Florida extension papers cite a court that awarded loss of shade, and Texas and Quebec sources warn of damages.
This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. It restates a New York statute, two University of Florida (UF/IFAS) Extension publications, the Texas State Law Library and Éducaloi in Quebec.
New York: Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law section 861
Section 861 applies to a person who, without the owner's consent, cuts, removes, injures or destroys any underwood, tree or timber on another's land. Common land of a city, village, town or county is included, and so is damage to the land in the course of the work. An action may be maintained for treble the stumpage value of the tree or timber, or US$250 per tree, or both. It also reaches any permanent and substantial damage to the land or improvements.
The reparations are meant to restore the land to its condition immediately before the violation, by physical restoration, a monetary payment, or both.
A defendant has a narrower exposure after proving, by clear and convincing evidence, one of three things. These are cause to believe the land was theirs, an easement or right of way permitting the act, or a legal right to harvest the land. The defendant is then liable for the stumpage value or US$250 per tree, or both. Reasonable costs of the action and any permanent and substantial damage to the land are added.
Stumpage value is the current fair market value of a tree as it stands before sale, cutting or removal. The statute lists ways to set it: an arm's-length sale price, solicited bids, the Department of Environmental Conservation stumpage price report, comparison with like sales on state or private lands, or other appropriate means.
Florida: the UF/IFAS handbook
The UF/IFAS handbook on trees and landowner responsibility covers a landowner who removes a boundary-line tree without the adjoining owner's consent. Liability may run to the reduction in the land's value and to the loss of the ornamental value and creature comforts the tree provided. The handbook cites Elowsky v. Gulf Power Co. (Fla. 1st DCA 1965). A tree on the boundary line shaded and cooled the bedroom of a police officer who slept during the day. The jury awarded US$500, and the court upheld it. The court's reasoning was that shade trees may matter to an owner without adding to the sale value of the land.
The handbook also reports Balzer v. Ryan (Fla. 1st DCA 2018). A neighbour cut encroaching roots. The cutting undermined the tree's structural integrity and raised the risk that it might one day fall. The court held that the tree owner had no cause of action, as the neighbour was exercising a privilege to cut the roots. The handbook notes there is no Florida case on that question otherwise, and that it is not clear whether spraying encroaching vegetation with herbicide such as glyphosate, or grinding stumps, would create a cause of action.
The Escambia County Extension summary of the same handbook says that without a neighbour's consent, a landowner who cuts down a shared tree can be legally liable for damages.
Texas: trimming to the line
The Texas State Law Library guide says a neighbouring landowner has the right to trim branches to the property line, but could be sued for injuring the tree or other property in the process.
Quebec: no self-help
Éducaloi says that a neighbour who cuts branches or roots personally can be sued, and the court might order payment to compensate for damaging or killing the tree.
Valuing a lost tree
The New York statute ties damages to stumpage value. The Florida handbook cites liability for ornamental value and creature comforts. For ways to price a tree, see the guide to tree valuation methods. For the wider rules on a neighbour's tree, see the neighbour tree law overview and the guide to insurance and property damage claims.
Who to call
- Your county extension office: questions about tree health and responsibility after storms; UF/IFAS Escambia County is an example
- Your insurer: what property-damage claims after tree damage involve
- Tree valuation methods: how a tree is priced when its value is disputed
- Texas State Law Library: the state's neighbor-law guide for Texas
Sources
- New York State, Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law section 861, New York State Senate, read October 16, 2026
- New York State, Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law section 861, NewYork.Public.Law text, read October 16, 2026
- UF/IFAS Extension, FE962, Handbook of Florida Fence and Property Law: Trees and Landowner Responsibility, read October 16, 2026
- UF/IFAS Extension Escambia County, Property Law and Tree Damage, by Carrie Stevenson (February 10, 2015, updated October 14, 2020), read October 16, 2026
- Texas State Law Library, Neighbor Law guide, Trees page, read October 16, 2026
- Éducaloi, Trees and Fences, read October 16, 2026