Digging or trenching near a tree: Arlington County, ISA journal papers and BS 5837 guidance
Arlington County sets trench setbacks of 10 feet for trees up to 6 inches across and 20 feet for larger ones. Two journal papers report what trenching did to real trees, and Leeds City Council summarises BS 5837.
This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. Arlington County, Virginia, applies its figures to utility work in public space. The two papers are research reports, not rules, and Leeds City Council writes for planning applications.
Arlington County, Virginia
Arlington County's page on utility damage prevention near trees sets minimum distances for work near public trees. DBH is trunk diameter at breast height.
| Work | Tree 6 inches DBH or less | Tree over 6 inches DBH |
|---|---|---|
| Trenches, bore pits, hand holes and manholes | At least 10 feet from the trunk | At least 20 feet from the trunk |
| Bores | At least 4 1/2 feet deep when within 10 feet of the trunk | At least 4 1/2 feet deep when within 15 feet of the trunk |
| Test pits | Outside the structural root zone | Outside the structural root zone |
Trees 42 inches DBH or greater, or otherwise significant, may need more than 20 feet. Plans show every tree within 20 feet of bored lines and 25 feet of trenched lines, with each tree's structural and critical root zones and trunk diameter, plus protection details such as fencing or root matting. On permitted work in public space the installer is responsible for tree stewardship. If a tree is severely damaged or dies from unpermitted construction, the installer may owe replacement or other damages under the Trees and Shrubs Ordinance. Exceptions must be approved by the urban forester.
Trenching in a five-year study
Fredric Miller and Dan Neely reported in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in July 1993 on telephone-line trenches dug in spring 1987 on the University of Illinois campus. They followed hackberry, sweetgum, sugar maple and honeylocust through 1991. Trenches ran 0.5 to 3.3 m from the trunks, 0.6 to 0.9 m deep. Only 7 of 98 trees, trenched and untrenched together, died, and six of the seven had been trenched.
The closer the trench, the greater the loss of growth. Hackberry trenched within 0.5 m (1.5 ft) of the trunk grew 45% less over five seasons than untrenched trees. The other three species, trenched farther away, lost less than 15%, and honeylocust trenched 3.3 m (11 ft) from the trunk lost 7%. Trenching distances of 0.5 to 3.3 m did not predispose the trees to evident disease or insect infestation.
The paper also lists distances proposed by others for one side of a tree. The British Standards Institution and Watson suggest 0.5 ft of trench distance for each 1 inch of trunk diameter. Harris and ASCA give 1 ft per inch. For augering, another author gives 1 ft per inch. The authors write that the data support the British Standards Institution and Watson minimum. Most roots lie in the top 1.0 m (3 feet) of soil and may spread at least 2 to 3 times the tree's height in open ground. A water main study cited in the paper found tree mortality of 25 to 44 percent about 12 years later, and 100 percent in some cases.
Utility lines under trees in Maryland
Earl Yingling and colleagues of the US Forest Service wrote in 1979 from experience supervising utility work in Maryland rights-of-way. The Maryland Forest Service requires tunneling as soon as roots of a certain size turn up in a utility trench. The trigger size dropped from 2 inches to 1 inch. Tunnels usually leave at least the top 2 feet of soil undisturbed. Maryland experience suggests open trenches should not extend under the crowns of trees under 6 inches DBH. The authors say the line between smaller and large old trees should be set locally. Yingling put it at 23 inches in central Maryland, and a Delaware study found survival falling from 10 inches.
The paper gives case histories. In Pikesville a 66,000-volt line went under street trees with most trenches and tunnels left open about 2 weeks, and only 2 of 34 silver maples died in the next 8 years. In Frederick, a conduit went under 21 London plane trees by trenching and hand-tunnelling, and none died.
BS 5837 as Leeds summarises it
Leeds City Council's guidance note describes BS 5837, the British Standard on trees in relation to design, demolition and construction, which came into effect on 30 April 2012. The standard applies whether or not planning permission is required. Root protection areas are plotted as a circle centred on the stem, or a polygon of equal area where rooting is asymmetrical. The default position is no structures within the root protection area of retained trees. Engineering solutions are considered only in exceptional circumstances.
The Council's list of impacts to assess includes drainage and services, and level changes. Its table of planning information asks for the alignment of utility apparatus, including drainage, where outside the root protection area or installed by a trenchless method. The default tree protection barrier is a 2 m tall galvanised tube and welded mesh barrier with uprights driven at least 0.6 m into the ground.
Call before you dig
The Common Ground Alliance's 811 page treats planting trees and shrubs as digging. It asks for contact with 811 a few business days before starting so buried utilities are marked. The guide to call-before-you-dig services lists the services by country.
Who to call
- 811 (United States): marks buried utility lines before any dig, planting trees included
- Arlington County Urban Forestry: approves exceptions to the setbacks for work near public trees in Arlington
- Leeds City Council Landscape Team: wrote the BS 5837 guidance note for planning applications in Leeds
Sources
- Arlington County, Virginia, Utility Damage Prevention: Near Trees, read October 15, 2026
- Miller and Neely, The Effect of Trenching on Growth and Plant Health of Selected Species of Shade Trees, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 19(4), July 1993, read October 15, 2026
- Yingling, Keeley, Little and Burtis, Reducing Damage to Shade and Woodland Trees From Construction Activities, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 5(5), May 1979, read October 15, 2026
- Leeds City Council, Existing Trees and Development: tree-related information in the planning system (Landscape Guidance No.1), read October 15, 2026
- Common Ground Alliance, 811 Before You Dig, read October 15, 2026