Emerald ash borer treatment options: how extension compares them
Extension bulletins sort emerald ash borer treatments into soil applications, trunk injections, lower trunk sprays and cover sprays, and compare removal against them. This page reports how Wisconsin, North Central IPM Center and Texas A&M publications rate each.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The comparisons below come from four extension publications written for owners and for licensed applicators, and one Chicago city page is cited on its ash plan. The extension publications name active ingredients and describe results from university trials. The 2009 bulletin says pesticide labels and registrations change constantly and vary from state to state. For the canopy figure that separates treatment from removal, see the canopy-loss thresholds.
The four treatment categories
The 2009 bulletin from the North Central IPM Center (Herms and colleagues) groups effective insecticides into four categories. Texas A&M AgriLife Extension, in its October 2024 guide, uses the same four. Insecticides are the only feasible way to save host trees, in the Texas guide's words.
| Method | What the bulletins record |
|---|---|
| Soil drench or injection | Imidacloprid or dinotefuran taken up by roots. Needs no special equipment for a drench. Results vary between trials and are less consistent on trees over 15 inches in diameter. |
| Trunk injection | Emamectin benzoate, imidacloprid, azadirachtin and acephate implants are named. Wounds the trunk. Moves through the tree faster than a soil application. |
| Lower trunk spray | Dinotefuran sprayed on the lower 5 to 6 feet of trunk. Does not wound the tree. One year of protection. |
| Cover spray | Pyrethroids and carbaryl on trunk, branches and foliage. Reach adults and newly hatched larvae only. Short-lived. |
| Removal | Compared by cost against treatment. Wisconsin: ash trees are known to become brittle and hazardous relatively quickly. |
Soil applications
Both bulletins describe a drench poured at the base of the trunk, or an injection 2 to 4 inches deep within 18 inches of the trunk. Both report that uptake is better at the base than in a grid or ring pattern. The 2009 bulletin adds that imidacloprid binds to organic matter such as mulch, which can reduce uptake. Texas A&M describes injection as placing the product in the root zone without removing mulch.
Results are mixed. The 2009 bulletin reports excellent control in some imidacloprid trials and poor control in others, with differences in protocol and pest pressure behind the spread. Texas A&M calls soil results variable. The University of Wisconsin professional guide reports excellent protection for ash under 6 inches in diameter in the first year, and says larger trees may need two consecutive years.
The sources differ on season. The Wisconsin guide reports that recent research found spring applications more effective than fall, and Texas A&M agrees. The 2009 bulletin reports spring and fall imidacloprid applications equally effective.
Trunk injection
The 2009 bulletin says injections suit sites where soil treatment is impractical, such as wet, compacted or restricted soil. It also says injections wound the trunk and may cause long-term damage if repeated yearly. The Wisconsin guide notes that injections and implants can injure trees, especially smaller ones, and may give entry to disease-causing pathogens such as the fungus behind Nectria canker.
Emamectin benzoate draws the strongest results in the 2009 bulletin and the Texas guide. The 2009 bulletin reports that a single injection gave more than 99 per cent fewer larvae: untreated trees held 68 to 132 larvae per square metre of bark, treated trees 0.2. It was then the only product tested to control EAB for more than one year from one application. Texas A&M rates it excellent for 1 to 3 years. Wisconsin notes the label covers two years and some research suggests three or more at the highest labeled rate.
Azadirachtin gets a different review. Texas A&M reports it is less acutely toxic to adults than emamectin benzoate or dinotefuran but reduces the viability of eggs laid by mature females. It rates protection at 1 to 2 years, with yearly application where beetle numbers are high.
Imidacloprid injections gave 60 to 96 per cent fewer larvae in one Michigan State trial, per the 2009 bulletin. In a discouraging Michigan trial, trees injected two years running still declined under severe pressure, though less than untreated trees.
Lower trunk spray
Texas A&M reports that dinotefuran sprayed on the lower trunk reaches the leaves as fast as emamectin benzoate and faster than soil-applied imidacloprid, in trees of any size. A five-year Ohio State study found the highest labeled rate gave better control than the lower rate in ash up to 22 inches. The 2009 bulletin reports larval density cut by about 30 to 60 per cent in a Michigan State trial, for one year, with better results in small trees.
Cover sprays
Both bulletins report that cover sprays act on adults feeding on leaves and on larvae newly hatched, and have no effect on larvae already under the bark. The 2009 bulletin reports good control from well-timed sprays of bifenthrin, cyfluthrin and carbaryl, and says spraying large trees is likely to cause considerable drift. Texas A&M rates cover sprays moderate, protecting for one year, and calls foliar application alone inadequate. Both name spray drift and non-target organisms as concerns. Texas A&M calls the systemic products safer for non-target organisms than cover sprays.
Removal and the economics
Texas A&M reports that treating healthy or lightly infested trees, under 30 per cent canopy reduction, is more cost-effective than removing them. It also reports that once EAB is established in an area it has never been eradicated, so valuable trees need treatment for their lifetimes. The Wisconsin article reports that insecticide is not appropriate for woodlots or large numbers of ash, and that per-acre label limits can cap the number of trees treated. Cities often have their own treatment or removal plans, it adds. Chicago's Bureau of Forestry injects ash trees to slow the beetle and, every three years, assesses each tree to decide whether to retreat or remove it, per the City of Chicago page. Regulations on moving wood are in emerald ash borer regulation by country, and the broader record on trunk injection is in trunk injection and ash treatment.
Sources
- Herms and others, Insecticide options for protecting ash trees from emerald ash borer, North Central IPM Center bulletin E3075, June 2009, read October 16, 2026
- Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Service, Emerald ash borer control: a guide for professionals (ENTO-PU-228, October 2024), read October 16, 2026
- University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Professional guide to emerald ash borer insecticide treatments (XHT1185, revised April 7, 2022), read October 16, 2026
- University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Is my ash tree worth treating for emerald ash borer? (XHT1215, revised January 29, 2026), read October 16, 2026
- City of Chicago, Streets and Sanitation, Emerald Ash Borer page, read October 19, 2026