Forces in rigging: static load, peak force and anchor force in published studies
HSE rigging research, as an Arboricultural Association article relays it, found peak forces averaging 8 to 12 times a lowered section's weight. A Kane study put force at the block slightly above double the rope tension.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on two Arboriculture and Urban Forestry papers, an Arboricultural Association article on the HSE rigging research, a Tree Care Industry magazine article and an Association outline for a rigging guide. It is not training and does not teach the work.
Static load and dynamic load
Brian Kane, Sergio Brena and Wesley Autio, in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in March 2009, describe rigging as involving dynamic forces. Pieces swing or fall some distance before the rope decelerates and stops them, and the tree responds by oscillating. They write that the greatest stresses arise when the rigging point is below the piece being removed, a setup commonly called butt-hitching.
In their account, a piece that free falls is moving faster when the rope stops it. The stopping force then runs well above the piece's weight. Decelerating the piece gradually, known as letting a piece run, can reduce that force. An abrupt stop makes the force needed to decelerate the piece, in theory, much greater.
The Tree Care Industry magazine article of July 2022 makes the same point for negative rigging, where the load falls into the rope from above the anchor point. It says the dynamic forces on the tree and equipment far exceed the static load of the mass of the cut log.
Rope tension and force at the block in the Kane papers
The 2009 study removed the tops and four further pieces from 13 red pines, each tree averaging 30.6 cm in diameter and 21.6 m tall, and recorded peak loads with dynamometers at the block and the friction device. Mass was the best predictor of force at the block and of tension in the rope. Notch angle, notch depth and fall distance were less important and showed counter-intuitive relationships.
The paper explains that tension in the rope must be doubled to estimate the force in the block and sling, and that friction in the block makes the real figure somewhat lower. It cites work on a 227 kg (500 lb) mass in which rope tension fell between the block and the friction device by 4 to 30 percent, depending on the block. In the 13-tree data, force at the block was slightly more than double the tension in the rope. For two tops the force was great enough to strip bark as the sling and block slid about 0.5 m down the trunk.
Kane, in the January 2012 paper on hitches and ropes, tested four common hitches and seven ropes in a static pull. Breaking load was similar between the hitches and varied widely among the ropes. The paper lists as an important limitation that a static load does not reflect the dynamic loads often generated in rigging.
Peak force in the HSE rigging research
An Arboricultural Association article by Andreas Detter, from ARB Magazine issue 182, reviews peak forces from the HSE rigging research. Drops were simulated with the friction device blocked. Peak forces did not act parallel to the trunk. On average they acted at 30 to 40 degrees to the trunk axis, which creates a lateral bending moment that may cause a stem used as an anchor point to fail.
The forces at the rigging point exceeded the weight of the lowered section by an average of 8 to 12 times, and the factor decreases with increasing mass (HSE Rigging Report 2008). Newer drop tests used logs up to 750 kg, three times the mass of the biggest sections in earlier tests.
The article derives a rule of thumb for double braid and kernmantle ropes of 12 mm and 14 mm. Across 22 drops with a locked friction device it underestimated peak force by less than 10 percent and, at most, ran about a quarter too high. The author states that the rule should not be readily applied to other rigging scenarios or ropes, and that an experienced and competent person must adapt it to the actual situation. He adds that for crown sections still in leaf, peak forces with a locked device did not exceed those from slow deceleration of trunk sections of similar mass.
The two sources differ on test method. The article says setups with a force meter between the pulley and the anchor sling, which include the 2009 Kane study, extend the real fall distance and record much greater forces than real tree care operations. Kane's paper also notes that placing the dynamometer between sling and block increased the fall distance compared with a work situation.
Force at the anchor and on the rope
A Tree Care Industry magazine article by Matt Follett and colleagues tested anchors under a running rope. A sheave block, it writes, magnifies the falling load to approximately 2 times at the anchor point. The tests used a 425 lb (93 kg) piece rigged 7.5 m up an 18-inch green ash, with three drops per anchor.
With three stationary anchors (rings and thimbles), the load at the friction device was about half that with the block, and peak stem strain fell by approximately one third. The authors call this a running-rope best case. The load in the lead rope to the falling piece did not drop the same way, and they point out that the potential energy to dissipate is unchanged. In their words only a longer time to slow the piece reduces that peak.
A second test with an 11¾-inch ash found that leaving limbs below the upper anchor lowered peak stem strain. One small limb under one-third of the stem diameter cut it by approximately 20 percent, and two limbs by about 35 percent in that case.
The Association's outline of forces
The Arboricultural Association's August 2017 scoping document for a rigging and dismantling technical guide sets out section 4, "Understanding the Forces Generated". It plans parts on estimating section mass and potential peak load, correction factors and potential peak loading, starting from the worst-case scenario.
The parameters it lists for peak load are the mass of the section and the distance of fall. Rope length and rope modulus come next. Then come the elasticity, height and slenderness of the trunk, aerodynamics and damping, friction and rope angles at the rigging point, and lever arm length.
Sources
- Kane, Brena and Autio, Forces and Stresses Generated During Rigging Operations, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 35(2), March 2009, read October 16, 2026
- Kane, Breaking Load of Hitches and Ropes Used in Rigging, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 38(1), January 2012, read October 16, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, A simple rule of thumb for rigging forces from full-size tests (Detter, ARB Magazine issue 182), read October 16, 2026
- Tree Care Industry magazine, Testing Equipment and Techniques to Reduce Loads on the Stem, July 1, 2022, read October 16, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Draft Technical Guide scoping document: Rigging and dismantling, August 2017, read October 16, 2026