ArbNation Join free

Growing trees from seed: stratification, scarification and seed sources

Arizona Extension says almost all tree seeds need a treatment to break dormancy, most often cold moist stratification for 1 to 6 months. The USDA Woody Plant Seed Manual and the Forestry Commission's Bulletin 83 give the species detail.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Three public references describe seed dormancy and the treatments that end it: the USDA Woody Plant Seed Manual, University of Arizona Cooperative Extension, and the Forestry Commission's Seed Manual for Forest Trees. This is a description of what they publish. It is not training and does not teach the work.

Terms

Arizona Extension's Backyard Gardener sheet 123, adapted by agent Jeff Schalau, says some seeds need cold moist conditions, physical abrasion or the acid of an animal's gut before they germinate. It explains the adaptation this way: without it a seed may germinate in the wrong season and be killed by frost, heat, drought, predators or pathogens.

It names two common treatments. Stratification is a period of moist, cold conditions, 33 to 41 degrees F for a set time of 1 to 6 months, that brings gradual internal changes toward germination. The sheet describes home stratification as moist seed in a closed bag in a refrigerator. Scarification is a nick in a hard seed coat made with a file or sandpaper, or heat for fire-adapted species. Commercial producers often use sulfuric acid.

The Forestry Commission's Bulletin 83, edited by A. G. Gordon in 1992, defines dormant seed as mature seed of most temperate woody species that does not germinate promptly under normal conditions. Dormancy helps wild populations by preventing out-of-season emergence and spreading germination over weeks or years, but it is a problem for a nursery wanting uniform crops. The bulletin finds no single accepted classification of dormancy.

Dormancy by group in Bulletin 83

Dormancy types named in Forestry Commission Bulletin 83, chapter 12
GroupDormancy the bulletin records
Most temperate conifersWeak physiological dormancy; moist prechilling improves uniformity and rate of germination
Conifers with hard seed coatsDeep dormancy from the seed coat, called mechanical dormancy
Pinus peuceEmbryo dormancy
Betula pendulaWeak physiological dormancy; responds to moist chilling
Red oak groupDeep radicle dormancy, readily overcome by winter cold when sown in autumn
White oak groupGerminates very readily, so acorns are hard to keep from sprouting during collection and processing; Quercus petraea is more prone to it than Quercus robur
Quercus robur and Quercus petraeaEpicotyl dormancy at times, a dormancy of the shoot after the root has emerged, overcome by cold in the winter that follows
BeechThe only commercially important broadleaf with real germination problems; chilling needed averages 12 weeks and runs from 4 to 16

Bulletin 83 names Picea sitchensis, Larix leptolepis, Abies grandis, Tsuga heterophylla and Pinus contorta as the conifers that show dormancy most often, in that order. Thuja plicata and Chamaecyparis lawsoniana often show no reaction in germination percentage to prechilling in the laboratory, yet the yield of seedlings in the nursery may be dramatically improved by a cold moist treatment. The bulletin reports that moist prechilling is more efficiently carried out in transplant cold stores or even domestic refrigerators than in nursery stratification pits, where temperature cannot be accurately controlled. Its procedure places the seed in refrigeration at 1 to 5 degrees C. For the nine conifers tested, pretreatment without sand was almost always better and never worse than pretreatment in sand.

Species figures in the Arizona sheet

Treatments printed in Backyard Gardener 123, October 9, 2023
SpeciesTreatment printed
Arizona ashStratify 90 days
Arizona cypressStratify 21 days after drying two-year-old cones until the scales separate
Arizona sycamoreStratify 60 to 90 days
Desert willowNo stratification; storage in wet sand for several days speeds germination
Netleaf hackberryRemove the flesh by wet maceration, then stratify 60 to 90 days
Velvet mesquiteScarify by nicking; bruchid beetles likely kill many seeds
Western soapberryStratify 90 days; scarification may also enhance germination

The sheet adds that oaks, walnuts and other large-seeded trees often do best sown in native soil or in elongated containers, so they can send a deep root down at once.

Seed sources

Bulletin 83 treats the source of the seed as a choice with a measurable return. Its Table 2.1 sets unselected seed taken from the species' whole natural range as the datum with no gain. Seed from proven best origins within the native population gives considerable gain over that datum. Selected superior trees in superior stands of proven origin give a slight gain over the proven origins.

Seed orchards are plantations of selected, vegetatively propagated clones or seedlings of known identity, isolated to cut pollination from inferior outside sources. The bulletin calls orchards of untested known-parent material not-tested orchards, shown as NT in British identity numbers, and tested orchards those with proven genetic quality. Bulletin 83 states that to market orchard seed of species covered by the Forest Reproductive Material Regulations, all clones had to come from parents growing in the same region of provenance in Britain. It adds that this would change if the EEC Directives were amended in the current revision, 1991, which it called likely. For collection guidance by seed centre, see the guide to national tree seed centres. Terms are defined in the propagation and seed glossary.

The USDA manual

The Woody Plant Seed Manual is Agriculture Handbook 727, the update of Seed of Woody Plants in the United States first published in 1974. It runs to 1,233 pages. Part One has seven chapters on seed biology, genetic improvement, harvesting and conditioning, storage, testing, certification and nursery practices. Part Two covers 236 genera of native and introduced woody plants.

Each genus entry gives growth habit, occurrence and use, flowering and fruiting, collection, extraction and storage of seed, pregermination treatments, the germination test and nursery practices. The per-genus pregermination data sit in Part Two.

Sources