ArbNation Join free

Hazard tree guidelines for Forest Service work: the 2022 Angwin report that replaced 2012

The Forest Service Pacific Southwest Region revised its hazard tree report in March 2022, replacing the Angwin 2012 version. It rates a tree by adding a target score to a defect score.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named Forest Service reports are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. It does not rate any tree and says nothing about what should be done with one.

The 2012 report and its 2022 replacement

The Forest Service Pacific Southwest Region (Region 5) published "Hazard Tree Guidelines for Forest Service Facilities and Roads in the Pacific Southwest Region" in April 2012 as report RO-12-01. Its authors were Peter Angwin, Daniel Cluck, Paul Zambino, Brent Oblinger and William Woodruff. The report covered Forest Service roads and facilities such as campgrounds, boat ramps, trailhead parking, summer home tracts and information centres in California.

A revision followed in March 2022 as Forest Health Protection report RO-22-01, "Hazard Tree Identification and Mitigation". The cover states that it replaces all previous versions, including the April 2012 report. The authors are Angwin, Cluck, Rosen, Woodruff, Hawkins, Barnes, Cannon and Hazelhurst.

Definitions in the 2022 report

The 2022 report defines hazard trees as trees with a risk of falling, in whole or in part, and injuring people or damaging property. It uses "hazard tree" and "danger tree" as the same thing. Responsibility on National Forest System lands sits with the agency or with parties it delegates by written agreement, such as concessionaires.

The criteria apply to trailheads, campgrounds and other recreation sites, and to National Forest System lands next to state or private infrastructure. The report admits that all tree failures cannot be predicted. Judgment and the report together can reduce the risk of injury or damage, but not eliminate it.

The report sets out a few terms. A defect is a flaw that reduces a tree's structural strength. A failure is the mechanical breakage of a tree or tree part, and it becomes a loss only if someone is injured or something is damaged. Targets are people or built infrastructure near the tree, either stationary, such as buildings and parked vehicles, or mobile, such as moving vehicles.

The 7-point rating in the 2022 report

The 2022 report presents a modified version of the "7-Point System" of Mills and Russell (1980). Two values are decided separately, then added: hazard rating equals failure impact plus failure potential.

Point values in the 2022 Region 5 report
ValuePointsWhat the points describe
Failure impact (target)1, 2 or 3Low, medium or high. The report weighs the chance of a hit, the damage if it happens, and the value of the target. Campsites and residences are its examples of 3 points. Day-use areas are examples of 2 points. A little-used road is an example of 1 point.
Failure potential (defect)0 to 30 for no defects found, then 1 for minor, 2 for moderate and 3 for serious defects. One point is added where defects interact, up to a maximum of 4. A dead tree scores 4.

When a tree has several defects, the highest single defect value counts as the failure potential. The report's example of an interacting pair is a leaning tree with root damage or trunk decay. Lean and branch decay do not earn the extra point, because lean does not raise the chance that dead branches fail.

The 2012 report used the same two scales. It also divided recreation areas into high, medium and low risk zones, and noted that two-thirds of reported failures occur in trees over 8 inches in diameter at breast height.

Defect classes in the 2022 report

The report lists nine classes of defect, lettered A to I, and gives indicators of failure potential for each.

Defect classes, 2022 Region 5 report
ClassExample the report gives
A. CracksA crack going completely through a stem or branch is a high indicator. So is a branch of 4 inches or more with any crack. A single frost or lightning crack with no internal decay is a low indicator.
B. Branch unions and forked topsA weak V-shaped union with included bark that is also cracked, cankered, decayed or streaming pitch is a high indicator. The same union with no other defect is medium.
C. Decay in stem or branchesLess than one-third of the radius sound is high. The report calls this the One-Third Rule.
D. Fungal fruiting bodiesConks may or may not point to high failure potential, depending on species, size and number. One quinine conk on Douglas-fir, pines, spruce or hemlock is a high indicator.
E. CankersDepending on the species, a canker taking in more than one-third or one-half of the circumference is often highly prone to failure.
F. Dead tree, top or branchesAll dead trees are a high indicator, whatever the species, size or time since death.
G. Trees attacked by bark and wood-boring beetlesGreen trees showing certain beetle-associated signs are considered dead and indicate high failure potential.
H. Root damage and root diseaseThe report lists separate root conditions that indicate high and medium failure potential.
I. Leans and poor tree architectureAn uncorrected lean with other defects is high. An uncorrected lean without other defects is medium.

On the One-Third Rule, the report gives a worked case: an 18-inch diameter tree has a 9-inch radius, so 3 inches of sound wood around the circumference passes. The report calls the rule only a general guide with many exceptions. Leaning trees, off-centre decay and open cavities call for more sound wood.

Failure zone and inspection timing

The 2022 report puts the potential failure zone on level ground at one to one-and-a-half times the tree height. For a failed branch or top, it is one to one-and-a-half times the length of the part. On a slope the zone may need extending.

Region 5 Forest Health Protection specialists recommend inspecting a site once a year, with extra inspections after storms or fires. Campgrounds are usually inspected before opening. Along major roads, trailheads and parking lots, the report says inspections could come every two years.

The report lists these mitigation options: removing targets, felling or removing trees, topping, pruning, site closure, warning signs, monitoring, and specialised actions such as cabling or bracing a high-value tree. For catastrophic events such as wildfire or beetle outbreaks it adds a faster identification process. It notes that about 1 to 2 percent of trees die each year under normal forest conditions.

The Northern and Intermountain Regions guide

The Forest Service Northern and Intermountain Regions published a separate guide, report R1-17-31 of October 2017, for developed recreation sites. Five of its figures come from the Angwin 2012 report, used with permission. It states that it creates no rights enforceable at law.

The R1-17-31 rating differs from the Region 5 one. It adds three values: failure potential on a scale of FP1 to FP4, damage potential from 1 to 3, and target value from 1 to 3. The total therefore runs from 3 to 10. FP4 covers dead trees, live trees with major defects, and decayed or burned trees with too little sound wood. FP1 covers live trees with no visible defects.

The guide also gives a height to diameter ratio as an indicator. A ratio above 100 counts as FP4, and a ratio under 60 as FP1.

Sources