ArbNation Join free

Healthy-looking limb drops on a calm day: what a city and an ISA journal paper record

Menlo Park, California and a 1983 Arboriculture and Urban Forestry paper describe sound-looking limbs breaking from mature trees on calm summer days. The two sources differ on mechanism, and neither gives a way to spot the limb.

This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named city pages and journal paper are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. This page cannot say whether any limb will fail.

Names and first descriptions

The City of Menlo Park calls it sudden limb drop, also known as summer branch drop. A healthy-looking branch breaks without warning, mostly on mature trees, during hot, dry weather. The city's July 6, 2026 article and its August 7, 2023 article both call the events hard to predict.

Richard W. Harris, in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry in April 1983 (volume 9, issue 4, pages 111 to 113), describes seemingly healthy limbs up to a metre in diameter breaking out of mature trees. It happens during or after hot, calm summer afternoons in Australia, South Africa and the United States. England has reports of it in calm weather after a heavy rain that ends a spell of increasing soil dryness.

Where the break happens

Harris says breakage is most common 1 to 4 metres from the branch attachment, on long limbs that reach to or past the canopy edge. Sometimes a branch fails at its attachment, and less often the main leader or whole top goes. He reports no outward appearance tied to an impending failure. The wood at many breaks looks sound, while at others it is brash or decayed. Brash or decayed wood may predispose a branch to failure, he writes, but does not explain failure under these conditions.

Menlo Park points to end-heavy limbs: long, horizontal branches carrying significant weight at the tips, extending beyond the tree's dripline.

Species and age

Harris counts species from at least 19 genera. He cites Kellogg's 1882 report of Quercus lobata in the coastal mountain ranges of central California and a warning sign at Kew Gardens that older trees, particularly beech and elm, can shed large branches without warning. Young, vigorous trees seem less prone, and overmature trees may shed branches repeatedly, he reports from Rushforth's 1979 note. Menlo Park names no species.

Explanations on record

The two sources do not agree on mechanism.

  • Menlo Park gives three causes. Heat and dryness can dry internal wood and cause tiny cracks. Long limbs carry weight at their tips. On calm, hot days a tree can take up water faster than its leaves release it, which adds weight and builds internal moisture.
  • Harris notes that limbs are normally lighter in the afternoon, when transpiration is high, so failure then puzzles him. He suggests high xylem pressure, weakening of the cell wall bonding in the xylem, and extra limb weight together may be responsible.
  • He offers two sources of pressure. Wetwood bacteria have created gas pressures up to 60 psi in elm trunks. Or, under calm conditions, high humidity in the canopy cuts transpiration, and root pressure then raises the branch's water content and weight.
  • A third theory he gives ties reduced flow in calm weather to warmer branches, more ethylene, and faster brashness.

Harris calls all of these possibilities. No definitive cause is given by either source.

City programme and 1983 precautions

Menlo Park's tree crew and its contractor inspect and prune city street and park trees on a five-year cycle. The pruning it names is reduction pruning, which shortens long horizontal branches, and balancing the crown to spread weight and water flow evenly. The city also recommends deep watering of mature trees in heat waves, proper mulching and regular inspection by a certified arborist. Residents report a fallen branch or an end-heavy city tree through the ACT Menlo Park service.

Harris lists precautions that include warning people or roping off areas near hazardous trees from late spring to early fall, and not planting susceptible species where people gather. He also lists shortening and lightening long horizontal branches and opening the tree so humidity is less likely to build up. Susceptible trees, he writes, can be inspected for external defects, with low-vigor limbs that have decay or cavities removed.

Related pages

For the UK research note, see the guide to summer branch drop. For risk, see the guide to whether a tree is safe and the page on wind-damaged trees.

Who to call

Sources