ArbNation Join free

IACA Significance of a Tree Assessment Rating System (STARS): what it scores

STARS rates a tree's significance in the landscape as high, medium or low from a checklist of conditions. Retention value then follows from that rating, with life expectancy as the second factor in some reports.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

STARS is the Significance of a Tree, Assessment Rating System published by the Institute of Australian Consulting Arboriculturists (IACA) in 2010. Three arborist reports filed with NSW councils and the NSW planning portal reproduce its text: a 2023 report for a Carlingford site, a 2020 report for a Double Bay site and a 2017 report for Chatswood Golf Course.

Why the system exists

The reports quote IACA on the problem. The landscape significance of a tree is an essential criterion to establish the importance a tree may have on a site. Rating it becomes subjective and hard to repeat because of assessor bias. IACA therefore set out structured, qualitative criteria. The reports credit the original concept to the Footprint Green Tree Significance and Retention Value Matrix of June 2001. Definitions come from the IACA Dictionary for Managing Trees in Urban Environments (2009).

The system supports planning where trees are kept on or next to a development site. It uses a three-step scale of high, medium and low significance in the landscape. Once an individual tree has a significance, its retention value can be set.

The three bands

Conditions listed for each significance band
BandConditions in the criteria
HighGood condition and form typical of the species. Remnant or locally indigenous, rare, of botanical interest or of substantial age. Listed as a heritage item, threatened species or on a council significant tree register. Visually prominent and a positive contribution to local amenity. Social, cultural or commemorative value. Room to reach full size
MediumFair to good condition, with typical or atypical form. A common or planted indigenous species. Visible from neighbouring properties but not prominent. A fair contribution to the look of the area. Moderately restricted by the built environment
LowFair to poor condition. Not visible or only partly visible from neighbours. A minor or negative contribution to amenity. Severely restricted growing space. Exempt under a local tree preservation order. A wound or defect that could become structurally unsound

A tree needs at least three criteria in a category to be placed in it. The criteria are for individual trees, and the reports note they can be applied to a single-species stand such as a hedge.

Where the report texts differ

The Carlingford and Chatswood reports describe a high-significance tree as in good condition and good vigour. The Double Bay report words it as good condition or normal vigour. Double Bay says grand age where the others say substantial age. It adds a high-band criterion for a tree influenced by historic figures or events. It words the low-band condition rating as fair to poor with normal or low vigour and either form.

The Carlingford report lists a young tree that can easily be replaced among its low-band conditions. After the low band it adds two more categories: an environmental pest or noxious weed species, and hazardous or irreversible decline. The second covers a tree that is dead, structurally unsound, or likely to fail in whole or part in the immediate to short term.

From significance to retention value

The Chatswood report says STARS compares life expectancy with landscape significance and gives a retention value of high, moderate or low. It classes remaining life expectancy as long, over 40 years, medium, 15 to 40 years, short, 1 to 15 years, or imminent hazard or dead. The Carlingford report records retention value as H for high, M for medium, L for low and R for removal.

Sources