Tree valuation methods compared: inputs, outputs and who publishes each
CTLA's trunk formula, CAVAT, Helliwell and i-Tree Eco each value trees from different inputs and give different outputs.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on five published sources. No tree is valued here and no method is recommended.
The methods in one table
| Method and publisher | Inputs | Output |
|---|---|---|
| CTLA Guide for Plant Appraisal, ISA publisher (United States) | The trunk formula method starts from the cost of a replacement tree, using trunk area. The Forest Research review calls it a widely accepted approach in the USA. | A replacement cost as the starting point of the valuation. |
| CAVAT, London Tree Officers Association (United Kingdom) | Trunk area, a unit value factor from nursery and planting cost, a Community Tree Index for population density, accessibility, and the surveyor's judgement of function, amenity and safe life expectancy. | A money value for a tree over its remaining expected lifetime. |
| Helliwell, Rodney Helliwell, endorsed by the Arboricultural Association (United Kingdom) | Scores for six visual factors, mostly on a scale of 0 to 4, set by expert judgement. Field data needs are very low. | A money value from points times a value per point. |
| i-Tree Eco, USDA Forest Service (United States) | A sample or complete inventory with species and diameter at breast height, plus local weather and air pollution data. | Structure, pollution removal, carbon, energy effects, avoided runoff, and the compensatory value of the forest with the economic value of ecosystem services. |
Other methods have their own pages, including the trunk formula method, the Burnley method and STEM.
The Forest Research review
Forest Research reviewed three systems, CAVAT, Helliwell and i-Tree, in a project completed in 2008 and a research note dated April 2011. The note finds that they differ greatly in methodology, data requirements and outputs. At one end, Helliwell is entirely expert judgement, looks only at visual amenity and needs very little field data. At the other, i-Tree needs a sample or a complete inventory plus community figures such as programme management costs, city population and the price of residential electricity. CAVAT falls in between.
The note says CAVAT and Helliwell value a tree over its remaining expected lifetime, while i-Tree values the current annual benefits. Helliwell appears to produce the most variable outcomes of the three. None of the three can comprehensively quantify biodiversity or social and cultural benefits.
CAVAT
The London Tree Officers Association says CAVAT was developed by Chris Neilan and the Association in 2008. The Forest Research table dates it to 2007. It is for managing trees as public assets rather than liabilities. The association says over half of UK local authorities use it regularly. The Full Method was updated on March 27, 2023, to address the under-valuing of trees that are extensively managed, such as urban pollards. The new steps judge the completeness and quality of the tree and its crown.
The unit value factor is a published figure that changes each year. The association lists £23.56 for 2025-2026, £24.82 for 2024-2025, £22.26 for 2023-2024 and £16.26 for 2020-2021. The Forest Research note, written earlier, gave a unit value factor of about £13 in 2009. Under the note's description, five steps run from a basic value through location, function and amenity adjustments to safe life expectancy. A safe life of over 80 years keeps 100% of the adjusted value, and under 5 years loses 90%.
Helliwell
Forest Research dates Helliwell to 1967, making it the oldest of the three. Its six factors are tree size (maximum 8 points), useful life expectancy, importance of position in the landscape, presence of other trees, relation to setting (each up to 4 points) and form (up to 2 points). The scores are multiplied. The note reports a recommended £25 per point in the 2008 version, which caps a single tree at £102,400.
CTLA and the Guide for Plant Appraisal
ISA's publications page says the Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers is a collaboration of seven organizations, with ISA as publisher of the Guide for Plant Appraisal. A public comment period on the tenth edition ran until February 28, 2025, ahead of an eleventh edition. The Guide is sold in digital and print through the ISA store. Forest Research's note calls CAVAT's unit value step similar to the CTLA trunk formula method.
i-Tree Eco
The i-Tree site describes Eco as a model that uses tree measurements and other data to estimate ecosystem services and structural characteristics of the urban or rural forest. Missing measurements are estimated by regression equations, and results are then less accurate. Eco reports pollution removal for ozone, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide and fine particulate matter. The site carries a notice that a change in USDA Forest Service policy has indefinitely halted traditional funding for i-Tree.
Sources
- London Tree Officers Association, CAVAT (Capital Asset Value for Amenity Trees) page, read October 15, 2026
- Forest Research, Review: street tree valuation systems (project completed 2008), read October 15, 2026
- Forest Research, Street tree valuation systems, Research Note FCRN008, April 2011, Crown copyright, read October 15, 2026
- International Society of Arboriculture, CTLA 10th Edition Comment Period, read October 15, 2026
- i-Tree, i-Tree Eco application overview, USDA Forest Service, read October 15, 2026