ArbNation Join free

Insurance cost as a share of revenue: what official figures exist and what do not

The official workers' compensation documents price cover as a class rate per US$100 of payroll, adjusted by an experience mod. None of the three documents opened prints premium as a share of revenue.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. It is not insurance advice and gives no monthly price. The documents behind it are a Texas Department of Insurance filing notice, a North Carolina Rate Bureau circular and the National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) booklet on experience rating.

What the documents price

The NCCI booklet The ABCs of Experience Rating describes the simplest method as manual rating. Employers are grouped by business operation into classifications, the estimated losses of the group are added up, and an average cost is obtained. The booklet says the rate for each classification is approved by the state and applied per US$100 of payroll. Each US$100 of payroll is multiplied by the rate, and the premiums for the classifications are summed to the initial total premium.

The base in these documents is payroll. None of the three documents prints a premium as a percentage of revenue or a monthly figure. For a firm with payroll in more than one class, the booklet's roofing example adds one line per class before the mod is applied.

The experience mod

Experience rating compares an employer's own payroll and loss record with the average employer in the same classification. The result is an experience rating modification, or mod, which may raise, lower or leave unchanged the premium. An employer with better-than-average loss experience receives a credit, and one with worse experience carries a debit.

The experience period is usually based on three years of payroll and loss data. It can contain less than 12 months of data or up to 45 months, depending on short-term policies, policy dates or a new employer. The plan gives more weight to how often accidents happen than to how large each one is. The booklet's own example shows the effect of the mod on a premium of US$100,000 before the mod:

Mod factorModified premium
0.75US$75,000
1.00US$100,000
1.25US$125,000

Premium eligibility amounts, which decide whether an employer is experience-rated, differ by state and are set out in the Premium Eligibility table in the plan. NCCI issues an intrastate mod when an employer has exposure in only one state that participates in the plan and an interstate mod when it has exposure in two or more participating states. An employer that is a new business with no data available for a mod receives a unity factor against the premium.

The manual filings

The Texas Department of Insurance notice of workers' compensation filing records that NCCI filed Item E-1411 on July 24, 2024. It is a new edition of the Experience Rating Plan Manual, with conforming changes to the Basic Manual and the Statistical Plan. NCCI proposed that it take effect for new and renewal policies issued on or after 12:01 a.m. on July 1, 2025.

The North Carolina Rate Bureau circular of December 6, 2024 reports that the North Carolina Commissioner of Insurance approved the revised manual effective July 1, 2025. The filing memorandum attached to it states that the filing makes no substantive changes to any rule that would result in premium impact. It lists 39 jurisdictions where NCCI's plan applies, including Texas, North Carolina, Florida and Georgia.

Published rates by state

Class rates for tree work are published by state and province in the guide to workers' comp rates in the US and the guide to rates in Canada, Australia and New Zealand.

Sources