Kane 2011: ascenders on arborist climbing ropes, one paper explained
Brian Kane's 2011 drop tests put toothed ascenders on four arborist climbing ropes. In 67 tests the arrest distance met the 2 m limit of EN 12841 only 10 times.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. The paper is Brian Kane, "Compatibility of Toothed Ascenders with Arborist Climbing Ropes", Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 37(4), July 2011, pages 180 to 185, published by the International Society of Arboriculture.
The question
Kane opens with a change in practice. Climbers were using ascenders in place of Prusik loops when footlocking a doubled rope, and with single rope technique. He writes that makers set explicit limits on ascenders, and many of those limits are broken in tree climbing. Product literature cited in the paper warns that an ascender on a working line goes with a safety line carrying a Type A rope grab, and that climbers avoid falls that produce a large impact load. The paper adds that ascenders are usually classed as Type B rope grabs under EN 12841-2006.
The aim was to find out whether arborist climbing ropes are compatible with commonly used toothed ascenders. The author found little hard data on how they perform in tree work.
How the tests ran
- The tests ran in March and April 2010, in a red oak, from a branch about 12 m above the ground and 265 mm across at the eye bolt.
- The method was the EN 12841-2006 test for Type B rope grabs, with changes. An 86 kg drop mass was held on the ascender for 60 seconds, then released by cutting a throwline.
- The ascender sat 1000 mm below the dynamometer, a fall factor of 1.04. The runs were repeated at 2000 mm, a fall factor of 0.52.
- Every rope was new. Each combination was tested at least five and at most ten times.
- Limited extra runs used 4000 mm of rope, a 110 kg mass, a friction hitch above the ascender and a Prusik knot in place of the ascender.
- Impact load and arrest distance were measured. EN 12841 allows an arrest distance of 2 m at most for a Type B grab.
What the paper found
| Measure | Result |
|---|---|
| Tests meeting the 2 m arrest distance | 10 of 67: 3 of 33 at 1000 mm and 7 of 34 at 2000 mm |
| Mean impact load | More than 5 kN (5.1 kN in the text) |
| Impact load with a friction hitch added | More than 6 kN |
| Static rescue rope | Arrest distance did not exceed 2 m in any test |
| 110 kg runs | Both tests on one arborist rope severed it completely |
| Prusik knot in place of an ascender | The greatest impact loads, up to 8.5 kN |
On the arborist ropes the ascenders stripped the outer sheath and slid it along the core, which bunched and slowed the descent. In some tests only a few inner strands, about 5 mm across, remained. The ascender frames also showed fatigue after several tests, and Kane retired them.
Kane reports that adding a friction hitch did not meaningfully change arrest distance and appeared to raise impact load. The hitch was only mildly tightened, to mimic a hitch pushed up the rope during a footlock, and it gripped in three of ten tests. He notes it may still guard against other accidents, such as a branch knocking the ascender off the rope.
The author's conclusions and limits
Kane calls the drop test a worst case, but one that a Type B rope grab has to pass under EN 12841. He concludes that climbers need to be made aware of the proper use of ascenders and to use only compatible ropes. The one rope that never went past the limit was a stiff, all-nylon static rescue rope. He suggests the ANSI Z133 safety standard should address ascender use in tree climbing.
He lists limits of his own. The dynamometer sampled at 60 Hz where the standard asks for 1000 Hz, so true peaks may be higher. A carabiner was sometimes cross-loaded, and branch deflection, which he estimated as small, stored some energy. Only one ascender model and four arborist ropes were tested.
The standards named
BSI Knowledge lists BS EN 12841:2024, rope adjustment devices, published March 31, 2024, and BS EN 1891:1998, low stretch kernmantel ropes, published September 15, 1998. Both show the status "Current, Under Review". Kane tested to the 2006 edition of EN 12841. The Arboricultural Association's code of 2020 defines an ascender as a device that slides when advanced up a rope and grips when loaded the other way, and lists both standards. Related pages are the other rope and ascender papers in the journal and how the codes define an ascender.
Sources
- Kane, Compatibility of Toothed Ascenders with Arborist Climbing Ropes, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 37(4), July 2011, pages 180 to 185, read October 21, 2026
- BSI Knowledge, BS EN 12841:2024 Personal fall protection equipment. Rope access systems. Rope adjustment devices, published March 31, 2024, read October 21, 2026
- BSI Knowledge, BS EN 1891:1998 Low stretch kernmantel ropes, published September 15, 1998, read October 21, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Industry Code of Practice for Arboriculture: Tree Work at Height, second edition, May 2020, glossary and standards list, read October 21, 2026