Landscape myth series: what Washington State University and Arizona Extension publish
Washington State University's Linda Chalker-Scott lists 78 PDF links in her Horticultural Myths index, on gardening and tree care claims. A University of Arizona Extension sheet reaches the same finding on vitamin B-1.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Linda Chalker-Scott is an extension horticulturist at Washington State University's Puyallup Research and Extension Center. Her Horticultural Myths index also points to a blog, The Garden Professors, which carries science-based information from four horticultural professors.
The WSU index
The index holds 78 PDF links, one of them a US EPA statement on compost tea. Some entries carry a separate references file. The index groups titles under eight headings: Fertilizers, How Plants Work, Maintaining Trees and Shrubs, Mulches, Pesticides, Planting Techniques, Scientific Literacy and Soil Amendments. Six of them are shown here with some of the titles under each.
| Index heading | Titles listed |
|---|---|
| Fertilizers | The Myth of Beneficial Bone Meal; The Myth of Vitamin Shots; The Myth of Foliar Feeding; The Myth of Phosphate Fertilizer |
| Maintaining Trees and Shrubs | The Myth of Cloroxed Clippers; The Myth of Winter Watering; The Myth of Top-Pruning Transplanted Material; The Myth of Tree Topping; The Myth of Wound Dressings |
| Planting Techniques | The Myth of Root Snorkels; The Myth of Fragile Roots; The Myth of Collapsing Root Balls; The Myth of Staking; The Myth of Vitamin Stimulants; The Myth of Mighty Roots |
| Mulches | The Myth of Pretty Mulch; The Myth of Landscape Fabric; The Myth of Alleopathic Wood Chips; The Myth of Pathogenic Wood Chips |
| Soil Amendments | The Myth of Gypsum Magic; The Myth of Soil Amendments, Parts I to IV; The Myth of Polyacrylamide Hydrogels |
| Pesticides | The Myth of Compost Tea, Parts I to III; The Myth of Baking Soda; Myths, Miracles or Marketing? Horticultural Oils; Myths, Miracles or Marketing? Bt Biopesticides |
How one entry reads
Each entry opened has the same three parts: the myth, the reality and a closing summary. Two examples show the form.
Vitamin B-1 and transplant shock
The myth is that vitamin B-1 reduces transplant shock by stimulating new root growth. The entry finds that applying thiamine to the roots of whole plants does not stimulate root growth, a claim it says the scientific literature has refuted repeatedly. It traces the belief to preparations that mixed auxins with vitamin B-1, where the auxins drove the response, and cites research from 1949. Its closing summary lists nitrogen fertilizer as adequate for transplanting, and adequate soil moisture for new root growth.
Fertilizer injection
The myth here is that injecting fertilizer is the most effective way to correct tree nutrient deficiencies. The entry reports that trunk injection can change leaf color at once, but that studies carried through several seasons report injected trees no different from controls. It names injection sites as entry points for pathogens and pests, and quotes a 2002 review concluding that surface applications were as effective as soil injection or drilling. Its closing summary calls for a complete soil analysis before any fertilizer program.
University of Arizona
Backyard Gardener #252, Root Stimulators, by Jeff Schalau of University of Arizona Cooperative Extension in Yavapai County, is dated July 24, 2024. It is adapted from original Backyard Gardener publications and lists the WSU vitamin stimulants entry among its additional resources. It reaches the same finding on vitamin B-1 and adds that the auxins IBA and NAA found in rooting compounds are used to propagate cuttings. It names proper irrigation as the most important factor in root establishment in an arid climate.
Sources
- Washington State University, Linda Chalker-Scott, Landscape Myths index, Puyallup Research and Extension Center, read October 16, 2026
- Washington State University, Chalker-Scott, The Myth of Vitamin Stimulants (PDF), read October 16, 2026
- Washington State University, Chalker-Scott, The Myth of Vitamin Shots (PDF), read October 16, 2026
- University of Arizona Cooperative Extension, Backyard Gardener #252 Root Stimulators, Jeff Schalau, July 24, 2024, read October 16, 2026