Learning from video versus assessed training: what HSE and OSHA say
Britain's HSE and America's OSHA put the training duty on the employer. HSE ties chainsaw work in trees to a certificate of competence and qualified instructors, and none of the pages mention video lessons.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. It sets out the training wording in the Health and Safety Executive's (HSE) tree-work and chainsaw guidance, and in the Occupational Safety and Health Administration's (OSHA) training page.
HSE on tree surgeons and chainsaw operators
HSE's page for forestry and arboriculture workers says 24 tree surgeons and arborists were killed during tree work in the last 10 years, and nearly 1,400 were injured. The key causes are chainsaws, falls from height and being struck by falling timber or trees. For tree surgeons, the employer must have the worker trained and competent to do the work.
On chainsaws, HSE's page has anyone who uses one at work receiving adequate training and being competent for the type of work. By law, operators must have received adequate training relevant to the work they undertake. HSE's investigations found most fatal and major injuries involve operators taking shortcuts and not following good practice guidance, usually to save time.
HSE's page also lists questions a client can put to a contractor. One is whether the contractor's employees hold relevant certificates of competence, such as chainsaw use, tree climbing and aerial rescue, chippers and mobile work platforms (MEWPs). Others cover trade body membership, safety record and the codes the contractor works to.
The HSE chainsaw leaflet
HSE's leaflet INDG317, Chainsaws at work, is aimed at employers, the self-employed and those who control work equipment. It says anyone who uses a chainsaw at work must receive adequate training and be competent for that type of work. Employers must give clear instructions, information and adequate training on the risks, the control measures and the emergency procedures.
For tree work, the leaflet quotes the Approved Code of Practice that supports regulation 9 of the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations 1998 (PUWER). Before using a chainsaw on or in a tree, a worker should have received appropriate training and obtained a relevant certificate of competence or national competence award, unless undergoing such training and adequately supervised. The leaflet lists an agricultural exception for hedging, clearing fallen branches and pruning for machine clearance, done by the occupier or employees who used a chainsaw before 5 December 1998.
- Training is to be carried out by suitably qualified instructors, such as independent training providers, instructors and colleges.
- Where a trainee consolidates training through workplace experience, a supervisor competent in the work and holding the relevant certificate or award supervises. Suitable training records are kept for trainees deemed safe and competent who await external assessment.
- The suggested ratio of trainees to instructors is 1:4 on an organised course and 1:2 for supervised consolidation at work. During the initial practical operation it is 1:1.
- Refresher training is suggested every two to three years for occasional users and every five years for full-time users.
- Chainsaws should not be used off the ground unless the operator is adequately trained in safe working techniques. Use from a rope and harness requires special skills and should be done only by people with the relevant training and competence for arboricultural work.
OSHA on employer training
OSHA's training page says OSHA requires employers to provide training to workers who face hazards on the job. Before engaging in any potentially hazardous activities, workers must receive appropriate safety training from their employer, as defined in OSHA standards. Outreach training, the 10-hour and 30-hour cards, is described as basic hazard awareness delivered by OSHA-authorized trainers. OSHA does not require it, though some localities and employers do.
Video and online learning
None of the four pages mentions video lessons or online learning. They name who must be trained and who must be competent, and HSE names certificates of competence and qualified instructors. None of the four pages says whether learning from video counts toward a certificate or award.
Sources
- Health and Safety Executive, Forestry and arboriculture workers (tree-work Are you a...? page), read October 21, 2026
- Health and Safety Executive, Chainsaws at work, INDG317(rev2), publication page, read October 21, 2026
- Health and Safety Executive, Chainsaws at work, INDG317(rev2), leaflet text, read October 21, 2026
- Occupational Safety and Health Administration, Training, read October 21, 2026