Snubbed-off loads and shock loading: how rigging sources describe the risk
Tree Care Industry magazine, a 2009 Arboriculture & Urban Forestry study and a rope maker's technical page all describe the force when a rigged piece is stopped abruptly. The maker says snubbing off can more than double the shock load.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The named studies and technical pages are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.
Which words the sources use
None of the three sources uses the phrase "locked off" for a ground-level lowering device. They describe the same event in different terms. The rope maker calls it "snubbing off" a piece. The 2009 study speaks of a piece that "stops abruptly". Tree Care Industry magazine describes dynamic forces from lowering a load haphazardly or too quickly, and sets friction devices against the limit of what a person can hold.
The rope maker's technical page
The rope maker's page on technical aspects of rigging says excessive shock loading must always be considered. It says the rigging system should be built to withstand the maximum shock-load potential. The maximum shock loads usually occur when the rigged piece is snubbed off and not gradually decelerated.
The page advises avoiding snubbing off wherever possible. Testing and research, it reports, show the block and sling can see more than double the shock-load force in that case.
The 2009 study of rigging forces
Brian Kane, Sergio Brena and Wesley Autio published "Forces and Stresses Generated During Rigging Operations" in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry in March 2009. The authors call rigging one of the most dangerous aspects of arboriculture. They found no "robust studies" of the forces and stresses it creates.
The team removed the top and then further pieces from each of 13 red pines. A block on a sling sat just below the cut, and the lowering rope was secured to the base of the tree by a friction device on a sling. The authors write that securing the rope this way made each top stop abruptly, which produced the large forces they meant to measure. Dynamometers recorded the peak force at the block and at the friction device.
The paper reports these results:
- Mass was the best predictor of force at the block and of tension in the rope, for tops and for pieces.
- Force at the block was more than double the tension in the rope. Friction in the block added about 20 percent on top of twice the rope tension.
- For two tops, the force at the block was great enough to strip bark from the trunk as the sling and block slid about 0.5 metres down it.
The introduction explains why a short fall can matter. A piece that free falls is moving faster when the rope slows it, so the stopping force exceeds the piece's weight by a wide margin. Letting a piece run reduces the stopping force, the authors say, but some jobs leave no room for it. They add that an abrupt deceleration needs much more force than a gradual one.
The authors name four factors with a greater effect on stopping force than notch depth and angle: the mass of the piece, its length, the distance of the block from the cut, and slack in the lowering rope. They add that climbers sometimes add slack on purpose to keep a cut piece from swinging back, and that these points should not override a climber's judgment.
Tree Care Industry magazine
Jeremy McCombs and Jack O'Shea wrote "Exploring the Principles of Rigging" for Tree Care Industry magazine, published July 1, 2021. They rate non-life-support rope at a working load limit of 20 percent of breaking strength. Their example is a double-braid rope of 5/8 inch with a breaking strength of about 10,800 pounds, which comes to a little under 2,000 pounds.
The article gives two figures for dynamic force. Forces can multiply to 10 times the weight of material lowered haphazardly or too quickly. In its negative rigging example, a 50-pound piece falling three feet exerts about three times its weight, plus the weight itself, so about four times.
The authors define positive rigging as a system where the pulley sits above the rigging point and the ground crew pre-loads the system to reduce dynamic force. They call negative rigging, with the block below the piece, the least desirable method for free fall but often key to tree removal.
On friction, the article makes a point about people: the best assistant cannot hold more than their own weight. It then lists working load limits for two lowering devices. A spiked device carries 1,000, 2,000 or 3,000 pounds depending on set-up, figures that include dynamic forces. A wrap-style device is listed at 2,000 pounds, limited by sling size, tree strength and knot choice.
Where the figures differ
The maker's page says block and sling see more than double the shock-load force when a piece is snubbed off. The 2009 study measured force at the block at more than double the rope tension. The two figures measure different things, and neither source ties its figure to the other's.
The magazine's 10 times and four times figures describe two different drops. None of the three sources gives a safe load for a locked-off device.
Sources
- Brian Kane, Sergio Brena and Wesley Autio, Forces and Stresses Generated During Rigging Operations, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 35(2), March 2009, read October 19, 2026
- Jeremy McCombs and Jack O'Shea, Exploring the Principles of Rigging, Tree Care Industry magazine, July 1, 2021, read October 19, 2026
- Samson Rope Technologies, Technical Aspects of Rigging, rope maker technical page, read October 19, 2026