ArbNation Join free

Misclassification penalties in US federal law, California, Massachusetts and the UK

Federal law recomputes an employer's tax at 1.5 percent of wages plus 20 percent of the employee's Social Security share. California sets a civil penalty of US$5,000 to US$15,000 per willful violation. HMRC publishes a status tool and no penalty figure.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The sources are the IRS page on independent contractors, 26 U.S. Code 3509, California Labor Code 226.8, Massachusetts General Laws chapter 149 section 148B and the HMRC page on its employment status tool. None of them names tree work. The tests themselves are covered in the guide to state employee and contractor tests.

Penalties side by side

What each source prints on misclassification
PlaceConsequence as printed
US federalEmployer liability of 1.5 percent of wages plus 20 percent of the employee Social Security tax. 3 and 40 percent if returns were not filed
CaliforniaUS$5,000 to US$15,000 per willful violation. US$10,000 to US$25,000 for a pattern or practice
MassachusettsCriminal and civil remedies, including debarment
United KingdomNo penalty figure on the HMRC status tool page

US federal

The IRS tells business owners that a worker who is misclassified, with no reasonable basis for the treatment, can leave the business liable for employment taxes. It names section 3509. That section sets the employer's liability as if the amount withheld were 1.5 percent of wages, with employee Social Security tax at 20 percent of the usual amount. Where the employer fails to meet reporting requirements under sections 6041(a), 6041A or 6051 without reasonable cause, the figures become 3 percent and 40 percent. Section 3509 does not apply where the employer intentionally disregarded the withholding requirement.

The IRS also describes relief for a business with a reasonable basis, which needs consistent information returns and no earlier employee treatment of similar workers after 1977. The Voluntary Classification Settlement Program lets a business reclassify workers as employees for later periods with partial relief from federal employment taxes. A worker who thinks the classification is wrong can attach Form 8919 to a return. Form SS-8 asks the IRS for a determination, which can take at least six months.

California

Labor Code 226.8 makes willful misclassification unlawful. It also bars charging a willfully misclassified person fees or making deductions that would have been unlawful for an employee. A determination by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency or a court carries the civil penalties in the table. For a licensed contractor, a certified copy of the order goes to the Contractors State License Board, whose registrar starts disciplinary action within 30 days of receipt. The employer must also post a notice about the finding for one year, signed by an officer.

Massachusetts

Section 148B treats a person performing a service as an employee unless three conditions hold. The person is free from control and direction. The service falls outside the usual course of the employer's business. The person is customarily in an independent trade or business of the same nature. Failure to withhold taxes or pay insurance does not count in the test. The section extends liability to the president, the treasurer and any officer or agent managing the entity.

United Kingdom

HMRC's tool gives its view of a worker's status. A status result decides who works out and pays tax and National Insurance contributions. HMRC says it will stand by all results as long as the information given stays accurate. A contract, written, verbal or implied, must exist or be expected before the tool is used. Further detail sits in HMRC's Employment Status Manual.

Sources