ArbNation Join free

Peak force of a falling piece: the Kane papers, the HSE rigging tests and a TCI study

Published rigging tests put the peak force at the block at about 8 to 12 times the weight of a stopped trunk section. Kane's 2009 field trial found mass was the best predictor of that force.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. The figures below belong to the tests that produced them: one rope type, one rigging layout, one species at a time. Their authors say so.

Kane, Brena and Autio, 2009

Brian Kane, Sergio Brena and Wesley Autio removed 13 red pines in Amherst, Massachusetts, with a block and a Port-A-Wrap. Each tree gave a top and four 1.83 m pieces, except two trees that gave three and five. Dynamometers recorded the peak load at the block and in the rope, sampling at 60 Hz. The paper appeared in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, volume 35, issue 2.

Mass of the piece was the best predictor of both the force at the block and the tension in the rope. Fall distance, rope length and notch angle and depth predicted less, and sometimes in the opposite direction from the expected one. Fall factor, the ratio of fall distance to rope length, was not a significant predictor of force. The authors link that to the rope: the fall factor equation comes from climbing rope, which stretches far more than rigging rope.

The Figure 2 caption prints two fitted lines for force at the block: force = 89.2 x mass + 1644 for pieces, and force = 57.4 x mass + 84 for tops. Force at the block came out slightly more than double the rope tension. Measured rope tension was only 12 percent of the theoretical value for tops and 19 percent for pieces.

The discussion lists four factors it expects to matter more than notch depth and angle: piece mass, piece length, how close the block sits to the cut, and slack in the lowering rope. It adds that a climber sometimes adds slack on purpose, that the findings do not replace the climber's judgment, and that the sample was small.

Kane, 2012, on the field loads

A later Kane paper in the same journal, on the breaking load of hitches and ropes, looked back at those field tests. It reports that the cow hitch holding the block saw impact loads up to about 18 kN. On a few tests the load made the sling slide nearly 0.5 m down the trunk and strip the bark. The paper's own breaking-load tests were static, and it calls the absence of dynamic loading data a limitation.

The HSE rigging research and the Arboricultural Association rule of thumb

Andreas Detter, the main author of the HSE rigging report of 2008 (RR668), summarised the full-size tests in an Arboricultural Association article. In the HSE tests the friction device was blocked and forces were measured in the block at the rigging point.

  • The force at the block exceeded the weight of the lowered section by 8 to 12 times on average, and the factor fell as the mass rose.
  • Peak forces acted on average at 30 to 40 degrees to the trunk axis, which puts a bending load on a stem used as an anchor.
  • The rule of thumb for worst-case peak force on the pulley is 8 times the mass of the trunk section plus 500 kp, where 1 kp is the weight of 1 kg. The load on the short end of the rope is that figure divided by 1.8.

Against 22 drops with a locked friction device, the rule underestimated peak force by less than 10 percent and overestimated it by at most a quarter. It was derived for 12 mm and 14 mm double braid and kernmantle rope. Detter says stiffer or differently braided rope may give greater peaks. Drops of crown sections still in leaf did not exceed the peaks from slow dynamic deceleration of trunk sections of similar mass. Treemagineers later used logs up to 750 kg, three times the largest earlier test mass.

Detter also cautions that a force meter placed between the pulley and the anchor sling lengthens the real fall. He says tests set up that way, naming the 1998 Donzelli poster and the 2009 Kane paper, record much greater forces than real tree work produces. The Kane paper itself notes that its dynamometer added fall distance compared with a work situation.

Tree Care Industry Magazine, 2022

Matt Follett and colleagues, writing in Tree Care Industry Magazine, called the loads in negative rigging far greater than the static load of the cut log. A rotating block roughly doubles the load the anchor point carries. In their running-rope tests on a green ash, fixed rings and thimbles cut the load at the Port-A-Wrap to about half and the stem strain by about a third. The load in the lead rope did not fall.

In a second test, leaving even one small limb below the anchor cut the peak stem strain by about 20 percent, and two limbs by about 35 percent. The authors call both results specific to the trees and set-ups tested.

Figures side by side

Published peak-force figures and the set-up behind each
SourceFigureSet-up
HSE rigging report, via Arboricultural Association8 to 12 times the section weight, on averageLocked friction device, blocked drops of trunk sections
Arboricultural Association rule of thumb8 x mass + 500 kp at the pulley12 mm and 14 mm double braid and kernmantle rope, 22 drops
Kane, Brena and Autio, 2009Force = 89.2 x mass + 1644 (pieces); 57.4 x mass + 84 (tops)13 red pines, block and Port-A-Wrap, dynamometer at the block
Kane, 2012Impact loads up to about 18 kNCow hitch holding the block, red pine field tests
Follett and colleagues, 2022Block about 2 times the load on the anchorGreen ash, running-rope ramp

The Arboricultural Association's August 2017 draft scoping document for its rigging and dismantling technical guide also lists a section on estimating section mass and potential peak load, with worked examples.

Sources