Pre-event debris contracts: how local governments prequalify tree contractors
FEMA's policy guide asks local governments to keep a prequalified contractor list, but a listed firm gets no standby contract. After Hurricane Irma, 22 of 50 Florida municipalities reported their primary pre-disaster contract was not honored.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here.
When federal debris money applies
44 CFR 206.224 lets the FEMA Regional Administrator fund debris removal from public and private land and water when removal is in the public interest. The regulation lists four tests.
- It removes immediate threats to life, public health and safety.
- It removes immediate threats of significant damage to improved public or private property.
- It secures economic recovery of the affected community for the community at large.
- It removes substantially damaged structures so that land bought under a hazard mitigation program can become open space, recreation or wetland.
The work must finish within two years of the declaration date unless the Assistant Administrator for the Disaster Assistance Directorate extends the period. The regulation allows private-property debris removal by an eligible applicant in urban, suburban and rural areas, but not in areas used for crops and livestock or in unused areas. It provides no assistance directly to an individual or private organization for clearing debris from their own property. Private nonprofits that run eligible facilities are the exception.
The prequalified list
The FEMA policy guide says local governments and private nonprofits should create a prequalified list of responsible contractors. A prequalified contractor is one the applicant evaluated and found qualified on capability, technical and management skills, prior experience, past performance and availability. Although a list is not a contract, many entities use theirs as contract research.
A prequalified contractor is not entitled to a standby contract. The applicant must still run full and open competition. It cannot exclude potential bidders from qualifying during the solicitation period, even if they were not on the prequalified list. The DHS Inspector General report adds that federal law lets FEMA offer an incentive to local governments that submit a debris management plan with one or more prequalified contractors. Establishing prequalified debris removal contractors is a requirement for entities in the Public Assistance Alternative Procedures pilot.
Pre-disaster and post-disaster contracts
The Inspector General report defines a pre-disaster contract as one a local government procures before the incident period, in anticipation of a disaster, for goods or services that support recovery. A post-disaster contract is procured after the incident. Federal procurement standards apply to both.
Under 2 CFR 200.320 there are three families of procurement method, and the recipient must keep documented procedures for each.
| Method | What the regulation says |
|---|---|
| Informal: micro-purchases and simplified acquisitions | For purchases at or below the simplified acquisition threshold. Simplified acquisitions need price quotations from an adequate number of qualified sources |
| Formal: sealed bids | Public invitation, a firm fixed-price contract, award to the lowest responsive bid from a responsible bidder. Local governments must advertise the invitation publicly and open bids publicly. The regulation prefers sealed bids for construction services |
| Formal: proposals | Public notice with all evaluation factors and their relative importance. Award to the offeror whose proposal is most advantageous considering price and other factors |
| Noncompetitive | Only for a micro-purchase, a single source, a public exigency or emergency that will not permit the delay of public notice, written approval from the federal agency or pass-through entity, or inadequate competition after soliciting several sources |
The regulation requires formal methods once a transaction exceeds the simplified acquisition threshold. Formal methods are competitive and need public notice.
The FEMA policy guide limits time-and-materials contracts. It allows one only if no other contract type was suitable, the contract has a ceiling price that the contractor exceeds at its own risk, and the applicant keeps a high degree of oversight. FEMA usually limits their use to a reasonable timeframe in which the applicant could not define a clear scope of work. The guide adds that a time-and-materials contract with no ceiling price, or a cost-plus-percentage-of-cost contract, carries a high risk of failing the cost-reasonableness requirement even where a state allows it.
What happened to pre-disaster contracts after Hurricane Irma
Hurricane Irma struck Florida in September 2017. By May 2019, 661 municipalities had reported US$1.39 billion in estimated debris removal costs. The Inspector General found at least 50 Florida municipalities with one or more performance issues on their pre-disaster debris contracts. The report lists a shortage of subcontractors and poor contracting practices among the factors behind the costly delays, and it says some locations paid more for debris removal as a result.
| Issue | Municipalities |
|---|---|
| Performance deficiencies, such as delays and contractors short of equipment or operators | 43 |
| Primary pre-disaster contract not honored | 22 |
| Pre-disaster contractor asked to change the negotiated rate | 19 |
| No pre-disaster contract honored | 10 |
The 50 municipalities set up pre-disaster contracts to secure lower rates and ready contractors. In some instances, competing new contracts at higher post-disaster market rates drove up the cost for subcontractors. Contractors reported they could not retain subcontractors at the pre-disaster negotiated rates. The Inspector General recorded these local responses, with some municipalities taking more than one.
- 23 used their own government workers for debris removal.
- 24 had pre-disaster contractors who went on to honor the negotiated rates. Many of those contractors fully performed only after finishing work in other municipalities that paid higher post-disaster rates.
- 18 negotiated new contracts, six of them at higher rates. One municipality's three replacement contracts added about US$13.44 per cubic yard.
- 12 used a pre-disaster contractor other than the primary one. One secondary contractor charged US$1.85 more per cubic yard.
- 5 modified pre-disaster contracts, with increases of as much as US$8.00 per cubic yard.
The report also states that FEMA usually does not review or approve pre-disaster contracts. Its Procurement Disaster Assistance Team, nine attorneys sent to disaster areas for training and guidance, does not approve debris removal rates for local governments, and it provided no sample contracts after Irma. On the money side, FEMA pays 75 percent of eligible debris removal costs. For one 30-day period after Irma, the President authorized a 90 percent federal share.
Sources
- DHS Office of Inspector General, Pre-Disaster Debris Removal Contracts in Florida, OIG-20-44, August 11, 2020, read October 21, 2026
- eCFR, 2 CFR 200.320, Procurement methods, current text, read October 21, 2026
- eCFR, 44 CFR 206.224, Debris removal, current text, read October 21, 2026
- FEMA, Public Assistance Program and Policy Guide, Version 5.0, effective January 6, 2025, read October 21, 2026, state-hosted copy from Montana Disaster and Emergency Services