ArbNation Join free

Pruning for storms: what UF/IFAS says about lion-tailing and over-thinning

All three UF/IFAS county extension pages in Florida warn against lion-tailing, and the Lake County page says there is no such thing as hurricane pruning. Duval County also lists over-thinning as improper and calls the palm hurricane cut a myth.

This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The facts on this page come from three UF/IFAS county extension offices. It is not training and does not teach the work.

All three offices are part of UF/IFAS Extension at the University of Florida. Their pages use different words for the same few cuts, so the terms come first.

The terms

  • Lion-tailing is removing small branches and leaving foliage only at the ends. The Lake County office pairs it with "pineapple pruning" and says both are often called hurricane pruning.
  • Over-lifting is removing all the lower branches, which leaves too much weight at the top of the canopy.
  • Over-thinning is removing interior branches. The Duval County office lists it with topping, lion-tailing and over-lifting as improper pruning.
  • Topping, also called hat-racking, is against the Miami-Dade County Tree Code, according to the Miami-Dade office.

Lake County: no hurricane pruning

The UF/IFAS Lake County page holds that there is no such thing as "hurricane pruning" for trees or palms. Pruning correctly over time is the best defense. Lion-tailing and pineapple pruning both increase the chance of storm damage.

On the Lake County page, causes of limb failure include dead limbs, poor branch attachment and pest or disease infection. A U-shaped attachment is stronger than a V, and V shapes are more likely to break. Branch removal cuts go outside the branch bark collar, never flush with the trunk, and wounds are not sealed. It puts inspection of large trees by a professional arborist at every two years.

Miami-Dade County: thinning and its limits

The UF/IFAS Miami-Dade page puts thinning for trees with a thick canopy at no more than 30 percent of the foliage in a year. Most trees need pruning every two to three years. Its photographs show a dense, unpruned crown as more susceptible to hurricane damage than the same tree after thinning, with a more open canopy that lets air through.

Multi-trunked trees become hazardous as they grow larger, and a single trunk from top to bottom is better. Weed eaters, construction debris and soil compaction should not damage the roots and trunk flare. Palms do not need hurricane pruning because they are adapted to windstorms.

Duval County: lessons from storm surveys

The UF/IFAS Duval County page lists lessons from University of Florida researchers who surveyed storm-damaged urban canopy. Properly pruned trees had less damage than unpruned or improperly pruned ones. Proper pruning means forming a single leader in young trees, eliminating co-dominant stems, leaving interior branches and using reduction cuts.

Over-thinning, topping, lion-tailing and over-lifting are the examples it gives of improper pruning. Trees growing in groups blew down less often than lone trees, because group trees share the wind load. Trees with confined roots were more likely to uproot.

Anchoring takes rooting space, assuming soil at least three feet deep. A small maturing tree needs at least 100 square feet, a medium one 400 and a large one 900.

On palms, the Duval page calls the "hurricane cut" a myth. Improperly pruned palms were damaged more often than palms never pruned at all. Removing only dead fronds is the best method, and more pruning stops at the 9 o'clock and 3 o'clock positions, meaning only fronds pointing downward.

Where the pages differ

The Miami-Dade page recommends thinning a thick canopy by up to 30 percent a year. The Duval page treats over-thinning as improper pruning. Neither page gives a figure for the point where thinning becomes over-thinning. The Lake page does not mention over-thinning. The Duval page adds that no way exists to remove the risk of a tree falling in a storm entirely.

Who to call

Sources