ArbNation Join free

What bad pruning looks like in words: the cuts the standards name as faults

The European Tree Pruning Standard names flush cuts, topping and lion's tailing as faults or critical errors. The ISA research review ties flush cuts to more decay. No photos, no firms.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The faults below are the ones the named codes and training bodies publish. It is not training and does not teach the work.

The European Tree Pruning Standard (2021) was published by the TeST project (Technical Standards in Tree Work) in cooperation with the European Arboricultural Council. The project was supported by the Erasmus+ programme. ISA's Arborist News article by James R. Clark and Nelda Matheny (February 2010) summarizes the research behind several of the same points. AS 4373-2007, Pruning of amenity trees, is listed by a standards seller with its title, scope and contents only.

Faults the European standard names

Fault wording in the European Tree Pruning Standard (2021)
FaultWording in the standard
Flush cutSection 3.3.2.1: flush cuts, the removal of stem tissues, must be avoided in all cases. Where a branch collar is not clearly visible, the cut must be positioned outside the branch bark ridge without damaging it
ToppingSection 3.4.4.8: topping of semi-mature and mature trees without an intent to establish a fixed artificial form, and without planned repeat pruning, is considered bad tree work and must be avoided at all times. It leads to large pruning wounds and the associated dysfunction and decay. The standard calls topped trees mutilated trees
Lion's tailingListed as a critical error, the clearing of all inner parts of the crown, in the crown maintenance classes for young and semi-mature trees and for mature trees
Excessive hit rateListed as a critical error in several classes, a large volume of leaf area removed. For crown maintenance of young and semi-mature trees the standard says leaf area removed should not exceed 20 percent. It advises keeping it below 20 percent in lateral crown reduction of young trees and below 10 percent in lateral crown reduction of mature trees
Excessive crown raisingListed as a critical error in the crown maintenance classes for young and semi-mature trees and for mature trees
Large woundsListed as a critical error above 10 cm diameter in several classes. Section 3.2.4 advises wound sizes of no more than 5 cm in species with weak compartmentalisation and 10 cm in species with good compartmentalisation, with exceptions for dead branches and safety removals
StubsSection 3.3.4 defines stub cutting as removing a branch and leaving a stub, without a lateral leader of sufficient size (one third of the stem diameter). Pruning to a lateral branch of insufficient diameter is considered stub cutting. A large number of longer stubs is a critical error for pollards
TearingUnder stub cutting the standard says branch tissues must not be torn

The standard also accepts some of these cuts in set cases. Stub cutting is the prevailing method for establishing pollard-style shapes and is listed in rare, justified cases for lateral crown reduction. A rip cut (section 3.3.7), where a branch is broken off after a partial cut on the upper side, is described as a method that mimics natural shedding and supports biodiversity. Dead branches can also be broken off, leaving a stable stub with a natural tear.

The standard separates topping from pollarding. Shaping starts in a young tree, repeats at short intervals (less than 3 years, or 3 to 10 years when maintaining pollards) and uses small cuts, less than 5 cm, or usually less than 10 cm when maintaining pollards. Section 3.4.4.5 notes that a pollarded shape can be confused with topping, because a young tree is topped to start one.

Findings in the research review

Clark and Matheny summarize 201 research citations from 44 journals in 12 countries. They report that before the 1980s branches were commonly cut flush to the trunk and the wound was covered with sealant. Research changed both practices. Alex Shigo's experiments showed flush cuts caused more discoloration and decay than cuts just outside the branch collar, which led to the CODIT model of tree response to wounding. Across a wide range of species in several countries, wound dressings neither speeded closure nor reduced discoloration and decay.

The review also marks the limits of the evidence. It reports that removing stubs located outside the branch collar may improve wound wood development, but no documentation for this was found. It finds no sound scientific basis for crown cleaning, thinning and branch reduction as they relate to tree health or stability, and says that does not mean arborists should drop current methods.

Australian standard

Standards Australia published AS 4373-2007, Pruning of amenity trees, on March 14, 2007. The listing states its scope as methods for pruning trees and guidance on correct and uniform practice for amenity trees, reconfirmed in Australia in 2020 and current in New Zealand. The contents list names natural target pruning, reduction pruning, remedial pruning, selective pruning and formative pruning of young trees. The contents list also has a section 8, Unacceptable practices, with lopping and topping, wound painting and flush cutting. The listing prints no wording under those headings, so none appears here.

See also the guide to what sources say about topping, the guide on wound dressings and the guide to the European Tree Pruning Standard.

Sources