ArbNation Join free

Reading a soil test report: pH, organic matter and nutrients in four extension guides

Iowa State, Maryland, Ohio State and Newfoundland and Labrador each explain the lines of a soil test report. Their pH, organic matter and nutrient ranges differ, and all four are written for gardens, lawns or farm crops.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Four public guides walk through a soil test report line by line. The ranges differ from guide to guide. They come from the Iowa State University Extension yard and garden service, the University of Maryland Extension, Ohio State University Extension and the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador. The Ohio State fact sheet says report formats vary from laboratory to laboratory.

Soil pH and buffer pH

Soil pH measures acidity or alkalinity on a scale where 7 is neutral. Iowa State and Maryland both say it affects nutrient availability. Ohio State measures it in a 1:1 mixture of soil and water.

Soil pH ranges named by each guide
GuidepH range
Iowa State6.0 to 7.5 for most horticultural crops
Maryland5.5 to 7.0 for vegetables, grasses and most natives and ornamentals; 4.5 to 5.5 for conifers and ericaceous plants
Ohio State6.3 to 7.0 for most Ohio crops
Newfoundland and Labrador6.0 to 7.0 for most crops; the lab aims for 6.5

Newfoundland and Labrador adds that its soils are naturally acidic, at pH 4.5 to 6. In Iowa, pH usually runs 5.5 to 7.5, Iowa State reports.

Buffer pH is a second line. Iowa State calls it the soil's resistance to pH change, used only to work out how much lime to apply. Maryland describes it as a measure of stored acidity, and says a lower buffer pH, closer to the soil pH, means more lime is needed. Ohio State lists a desirable buffer pH of 6.8 to 7.0.

Iowa State ties tree trouble to pH: iron deficiency symptoms on pin oak often come from improper pH, not a lack of iron, because the soil test shows adequate iron.

Organic matter and cation exchange capacity

Cation exchange capacity, CEC, measures how well soil holds and releases nutrient ions. Soils with more clay or organic matter have higher CEC, according to Maryland and Ohio State.

Organic matter and CEC figures in each guide
GuideOrganic matterCEC
Iowa StateUnamended soils 2 to 4 percent; 3 to 6 percent idealIdeal 15 to 20 meq/100 g; below 6 needs close monitoring
MarylandHealthy soils 2 percent or moreUnder 10 is where the guide suggests more organic matter
Ohio StateOhio mineral soils 1 to 6 percentSand 1 to 5, silt 6 to 20, clay over 21 meq/100 g
Newfoundland and LabradorOver 3.5 percent is good4 for very sandy soil to 200 for very clay soil, in cmol/kg

Maryland explains how the organic matter number is made. A sample is weighed, ignited to burn off carbon compounds and reweighed. Because the result is by weight, not volume, gardeners who add much organic matter may find it under 5 percent.

Phosphorus, potassium and the secondary nutrients

Iowa State reports two phosphorus tests. The Bray-P1 test is used below pH 7.4 and the Olsen-P test above it, and each extracts phosphorus differently. Its levels in parts per million:

Iowa State phosphorus levels by test
LevelBray-P1Olsen-P
Low0 to 50 to 3
Medium6 to 104 to 7
High11 to 258 to 18
Very highOver 25Over 18

Iowa State puts potassium above 125 ppm as sufficient and below 50 ppm as a likely deficiency. It sets calcium at 300 ppm or more, magnesium at 35 ppm or more and sulfur at 15 ppm or more.

Ohio State prints desirable ranges on the Mehlich 3 test: phosphorus 20 to 50 ppm and potassium 100 to 170 ppm. It lists calcium at 200 to 8,000 ppm, with less than 200 a concern, and magnesium at 50 to 1,000 ppm, with less than 20 a concern. The soil test value is the plant-available part, and the total in the soil is several times higher. It also prints conversion factors between tests, including 1.35 to turn Bray P1 phosphorus into Mehlich 3.

Maryland and Newfoundland and Labrador describe the words on the report. Maryland says an optimal, excessive or very high level means a nutrient is more than adequate, and that excessive amounts do not harm plants except where very low pH and high aluminum or manganese make those two toxic. Newfoundland and Labrador rates nutrient levels on ten steps from L- to E. L-, L and L+ are low, M-, M and M+ are sufficient, H-, H and H+ are high, and E is excessive.

Nitrogen, salts and heavy metals

Iowa State says soil tests do not measure nitrogen, because nitrate moves too easily for a test to be reliable. Recommendations rest on organic matter and the plant grown. It puts about 0.7 pounds of nitrogen per 1,000 square feet per growing season from each 1 percent of organic matter, and says shrubs and trees may need no supplemental nitrogen where organic matter is adequate.

Iowa State sets soluble salts at 2 mmhos/cm or less as needing no action. Sensitive plants show damage above 2, moderately tolerant plants above 4 and tolerant plants above 8. Standard soil tests do not usually include lead or other heavy metals. Iowa State lists the Iowa Department of Natural Resources soil standard for lead as 400 ppm.

Report layout in Newfoundland and Labrador

The Newfoundland and Labrador guide says its report has four sections: client and sample identification, test results, interpretation ratings, and recommendations. Nutrient values are reported in mg/L. The limestone recommendation is given in tonnes per hectare. For labs and what they test, see soil testing for trees: which lab reports and soil pH and tree nutrient availability.

Sources