Root barriers: what controlled studies found (Smiley, Gilman, Pittenger and Hodel)
Three peer-reviewed field trials tested linear and circular root barriers beside pavement. Results differed by soil, barrier depth and tree species, and roots often returned to the surface past the barrier.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Each trial below ran at one or two sites with one or two tree species, and the authors state their own limits.
The trials side by side
| Trial | Site, trees and timing | Barriers tested |
|---|---|---|
| Smiley 2008 | Charlotte, North Carolina; 30 London plane trees planted 50 cm (20 in) from new sidewalk, clay loam. Planted 1996, pavement removed 2006. | Vertical panel 45 cm (18 in) deep; vertical polyethylene sheet; gravel, foam and structural soil under the pavement; untreated control |
| Gilman 2006 | Gainesville, Florida; 48 sycamores planted 0.75 m (30 in) from walks on a well-drained and a poorly drained fine sand. Planted 1996, roots opened November 2003. | Three vertical barriers 30 cm (12 in) deep; gravel layer 15 cm (6 in) deep under the walk; control |
| Pittenger and Hodel 2009 | Riverside, California; sweetgum and Indian laurel fig, 100 trees. Six years after planting. | Four circular barriers: a commercial one 0.8 m (2.5 ft) across and 0.6 m (2 ft) deep, two nursery containers with the bottom cut out, a polyethylene sleeve |
Linear barriers beside pavement
In Smiley's trial, the vertical barriers led to fewer, smaller and deeper roots under the pavement than the other treatments. Cracking at the joint beside the tree showed up in four of five controls and in three of five polyethylene sheet and structural soil plots. The panel barrier had no cracking and no roots over its top. In the polyethylene plots, cracks came from large roots that grew over the top edge, which had dropped below the mulch or soil level in places. Some panels also settled below grade after installation.
Gilman's trial gave a different picture. On the well-drained site, the vertical barriers did not make roots deeper than the control. Only the gravel layer did: roots under the walk averaged 19 cm (7.6 in) deep, against 11 cm (4.4 in) for the other treatments, and no roots grew in the gravel. On the poorly drained site, the gravel layer, the polyethylene sheet and one barrier did about equally well, and only one barrier gave measurably deeper roots. That difference was 16 mm (0.6 in), which Gilman says may be too small to separate from a walk with no barrier. The panel barrier was the least effective vertical type there.
Smiley attributes the gap between the two trials most likely to barrier depth, 45 cm against 30 cm, and to soil, a clay loam against a fine sand. Gilman also saw that roots deflected downward by the vertical barriers returned toward the surface by the time they reached the far side of the walk. He cites earlier trials where roots grew under a barrier and came back up.
Under-pavement treatments
Smiley found minimal lifting or cracking with gravel, foam and the panel barrier. Roots crushed the foam as they thickened, which spread the upward force. Gravel did well for pavement protection but was only marginally effective at cutting root numbers, root diameter or raising root depth. A 10 cm (4 in) structural soil layer produced the largest roots, a large number of cracks and the greatest lifting. The paper adds that structural soils are normally installed in layers of at least 60 cm (24 in), and a 10 cm layer has never been recommended.
Gilman reports that gravel under the walk held roots well below the slab in well-drained soil. He credits the air space between clean gravel pieces, which dries and gives roots nothing to grow in. In poorly drained soil he reports the gravel was less effective, and he suggests low oxygen at depth as the reason.
Circular barriers
Pittenger and Hodel excavated the top 15 cm (6 in) of soil to 180 cm (72 in) from each trunk. Six years on, the barriers had reduced the number of roots in the surface soil and nearly eliminated large roots, 5 cm (2 in) or more across, within 120 cm (48 in) of the trunk. Many small roots between 1.25 cm and 2.5 cm across were found just beyond the barriers, 18 to 60 cm (7 to 24 in) from the trunk. No barrier reduced small roots beyond 60 cm.
The cheap options held up unevenly. A container with the bottom removed, 35.6 cm (14 in) across, did about the same as the commercial barrier. The smaller 25.4 cm (10 in) container and the polyethylene sleeve failed on sweetgum: trunks filled and split the small container, and the taped seams of the sleeve failed. The authors judge barrier diameter more important than depth or interior ribbing.
The same paper reports that roots grew below barriers and returned to the surface where soil texture, density and moisture suited root growth. It adds that keeping pavement at least 120 cm (48 in) away from trees would be as effective as a barrier in reducing the possibility of damage from large surface roots. The large container reduced trunk caliper increase on both species, and it and the commercial barrier reduced height increase of sweetgum. In Smiley's trial, treatments had no effect on trunk diameter.
What the authors leave open
A 2000 symposium at the University of California, Davis, sponsored by UC Cooperative Extension, the USDA Forest Service and the Western Chapter of the International Society of Arboriculture, drew researchers and practitioners together on this problem. Its report in the Slosson series says California spends US$70 million a year on street tree damage to sidewalks, curbs and gutters, and that infrastructure damage is the second most common reason California city tree managers name for tree removal. The participants called for more information on the long-term effects of root guidance methods, including barriers, trenching and chemical control.
Gilman records that one control sidewalk lifted 3 cm (1.2 in) and cracked at a 32 mm root, and he could not tell whether the crack or the root came first. He cites other work finding that sidewalks on clay soils cracked just as often with or without trees nearby, and calls for more research. For the rules cities set around sidewalk work, see tree roots and sidewalks.
Sources
- E. Thomas Smiley, Comparison of Methods to Reduce Sidewalk Damage from Tree Roots, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 34(3), May 2008, read October 15, 2026
- Dennis Pittenger and Donald Hodel, Six-Year Evaluation of Circular Root Barriers on Two Tree Species, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 35(1), January 2009, read October 15, 2026
- Edward F. Gilman, Deflecting Roots Near Sidewalks, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 32(1), January 2006, read October 15, 2026
- L. R. Costello and others, Strategies to Reduce Infrastructure Damage by Tree Roots: A Symposium for Researchers and Practitioners, Slosson Report 2000-2001, USDA Forest Service Pacific Southwest Research Station, read October 15, 2026