ArbNation Join free

Tree roots and sidewalks: what Seattle, Los Angeles and published studies report

Seattle's Trees and Sidewalks Operations Plan, Los Angeles' municipal code section 62.104.1 and a 1983 field study of 763 street trees each describe how cities handle root and sidewalk conflict.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. Seattle and Los Angeles each run a sidewalk repair programme with its own tree rules, and the research below is a field study of what damaged sidewalks beside street trees.

Seattle: who owns the problem

The Seattle Department of Transportation (SDOT) Sidewalk Repair Program page states that the Seattle Municipal Code requires adjacent property owners to keep sidewalks in good repair and safe for public travel. Repairs need a permit first. If a City-owned tree or sewer line causes the damage, the City takes responsibility for the repair. A damaged sidewalk is considered for City repair only if it is next to City-owned property or City-owned trees are causing the damage.

Seattle also sets a root rule. Before pruning tree roots greater than 2 inches in diameter, a property owner or contractor must arrange for an SDOT Arborist to evaluate how the pruning will affect the tree's health and public safety. The Operations Plan repeats the figure for street trees. SDOT Urban Forestry must approve removing or pruning roots greater than 2 inches in diameter within the dripline. Any root pruning inside the critical root zone must be supervised or directed by an SDOT Urban Forestry representative.

Seattle reports more than 2,100 miles of sidewalks and pathways, covering about 75 percent of the City's blocks. SDOT's Transportation Infrastructure Inventory, quoted in the plan, puts the sidewalks at over 2,000 miles worth US$2.8 billion and the City's trees at about 4.35 million worth US$4.9 billion.

Seattle: the Operations Plan

SDOT issued the Trees and Sidewalks Operations Plan in February 2015. It is written mainly for SDOT staff, and it states four goals: accessibility and health, environment, equity and efficiency. Its objectives include retaining healthy, mature and appropriately sited trees whenever possible while keeping sidewalks usable, repairing sidewalks damaged by street trees with sustainable solutions, and removing a tree only when no other practicable alternative exists.

Figures printed in the 2015 plan
ItemFigure as printed
Tree cover goal30 percent by 2037; about 23 percent in 2007 data (Urban Forest Stewardship Plan)
Walkable zoneA clear pedestrian zone at least 6 feet wide and 8 feet tall wherever possible (Pedestrian Master Plan)
Clear sidewalk widthMinimum 4 feet along the path of travel (US Access Board PROWAG R302.3 and R302.4)
Standards used in the initial checkRoom for a 6 foot sidewalk and a 5 foot planting strip
Replacement ratioTwo trees planted for each tree removed from City property or the right-of-way

The plan's initial assessment form sorts each tree into one of three outcomes. A tree that is unhealthy or hazardous is removed and the sidewalk replaced. A tree that can keep a standard-width sidewalk and tree pit is kept. If standard widths cannot be met, SDOT says it will evaluate other approaches, such as sidewalk width reduction, alternative materials, tree pit adjustment or root pruning. The repair options are listed in fixing sidewalks around trees.

Los Angeles: section 62.104.1

Los Angeles Ordinance No. 187106 added Section 62.104.1 to the Los Angeles Municipal Code. It codifies a Sidewalk Repair Program built to speed up repairs that earn credit under the Willits settlement. The ordinance recites that the settlement has the City spending approximately US$1.3 billion on sidewalk repairs over a 30-year compliance period. The City Clerk's record gives the ordinance effective date as August 2, 2021.

The section sets three approval routes, and the tree count decides which applies.

  • A Qualifying Sidewalk Repair Project can be approved by the City Engineer, and that approval is ministerial under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
  • A project that does not qualify but removes no more than two trees can be approved by the City Engineer, and the approval is discretionary under CEQA.
  • A project that removes three or more trees can be approved by the Board of Public Works, also as a discretionary approval.

A project qualifies only if it meets four tests. Construction takes fewer than 31 non-consecutive days. Excavation does not exceed 30 feet in depth. No known historic, tribal cultural, archaeological or paleontological resource suffers a substantial adverse change. No more than two trees are removed. Every approved project must comply with the Sidewalk Repair Program Street Tree Policy and the Mandatory Project Features Policy. The Board adopts both policies, and the City Council must approve them and any amendment.

What the research found

J. Alan Wagar and Philip A. Barker published their study in the Journal of Arboriculture in July 1983. In 1980 they rated 763 street trees of 10 species in cities on the eastern shore of San Francisco Bay. Damage was scored from 0 for none to 3 for concrete displaced more than 2 inches, and sidewalks replaced because of apparent root damage also scored 3.

Their regression explained 38 percent of the variation in sidewalk damage. Tree diameter accounted for 22 percent, species 10 percent, planting strip width 4 percent and soil texture 2 percent. Damage rose with trunk diameter and was greatest in the narrowest strips.

The authors ranked the species from most to least damaging after adjusting for size, strip width and soil: sweetgum, fruitless mulberry, Shamel ash, Modesto ash, evergreen elm, southern magnolia, planetree, glossy privet, myoporum and flowering plum. They call the ranking approximate. The average gap between the most and least damaging species was 0.85 on the 3-point sidewalk scale. They found that the most damaging species were also among the most often planted.

The authors concluded that planting less damaging, often smaller and slower-growing species and giving trees more space looked more effective in the short term than matching species to soil. They also report that damage varied widely between trees of the same species, size and site.

A later Arboriculture and Urban Forestry paper by E. Thomas Smiley, covered in root barriers, cites a cost above US$100 million a year for this type of damage in the United States.

UK guidance on trees in hard surfaces

The Trees and Design Action Group (TDAG) published Trees in Hard Landscapes: A Guide for Delivery in September 2014. It covers streets, civic spaces and surface car parks, with design and technical options, and is aimed at highway engineers, public realm professionals and tree specialists. The steering group included the Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers, the Chartered Institution of Highways and Transportation, the Institution of Civil Engineers and the Institute of Chartered Foresters. The guide won the 2016 Landscape Institute Award for Policy and Research.

Sources