ArbNation Join free

Root barrier types and what research reports on roots that go under or around them

Root barriers are plastic panels, fabrics or bottomless containers set in the soil to turn roots downward. Four research papers report fewer surface roots at first, then roots that grow under and return to the surface past the barrier.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Four published papers report on root barriers. Three come from Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, the journal of the International Society of Arboriculture. The fourth is a 1993 US Forest Service buyer's guide. It is not training and does not teach the work.

Barrier types in the papers

Barrier types tested or compared
TypeDescription in the paper
Ribbed panelsPanels of polyethylene, polypropylene or polystyrene with internal vertical ribs, joined into a ring for a planting hole or laid in a line along a sidewalk. The ribs are meant to turn roots downward and stop circling
Continuous rollsBarrier material rolled up for shipping, pre-cut to a length or not, used in a line or as a cylinder
Extension casingBottomless polyethylene tube, 26 cm (10 in) deep, attached to a nursery container and left in place at planting
Nursery container, bottom cut outA #5 or #15 container planted whole, tested as a low-cost circular barrier
Coated or treated fabricHeavy or medium weight nonwoven geotextile, some with a copper hydroxide coating and one with herbicide nodules, tested as vertical barriers 45 cm (18 in) deep

Six years of circular barriers

Pittenger and Hodel (2009) tested four circular barriers on American sweetgum and Indian laurel fig in southern California. After six years the barriers had cut the number of roots in the top 15 cm (6 in) of soil. They nearly eliminated surface roots 5 cm (2 in) or thicker within 120 cm (48 in) of the trunk.

Low-cost barriers matched commercial ones at stopping large surface roots. Roots still grew below the barriers and came back to the surface where soil texture, density and moisture suited them. Many roots between 1.25 and 2.5 cm thick grew in the top 15 cm just past the barriers, 18 to 60 cm from the trunk. No barrier reduced small roots beyond 60 cm.

The authors conclude that barrier diameter mattered more than depth or rib design: the smallest container failed because it was too small, and they give 36 cm (14 in) as a minimum diameter. They also write that keeping pavement at least 120 cm from trees might be as effective as a barrier. A #15 container barrier reduced caliper growth in both species.

Vertical barriers beside a row of oaks

Smiley (2005) planted two rows of willow oak in Charlotte, North Carolina, with 45 cm barriers 60 cm from the trunks. After two growing seasons no roots had gone through any barrier. All five barriers changed root growth. Some roots passed beneath and turned upward, but control trees had more roots from the surface down to 30 cm, a difference reported at P = 0.05.

Smiley reports that the polypropylene panel was best at sending roots below the barrier, while the chemically treated fabrics were better at suppressing root growth. No root was thicker than 1 cm, so he calls it too early to say where the roots end up.

Chinese hackberry in California

Peper and Mori (1999) tested three 30 cm barriers on Chinese hackberry for three years. The extension casing cut root weight in the top 33 cm by 50 percent against the controls. The two ribbed commercial barriers matched the controls in root weight and diameter. Roots on barrier trees escaped past the walls and rose to about the same depth as the controls, 37 cm. Casings appeared to encourage circling roots. Ribs diminished circling. Top growth was similar across all treatments.

The 1993 buyer's guide

Peper and Barker, of the US Forest Service, compared ribbed panel and continuous barriers after installing panel types in northern California in May 1993. They noted that plastics differ: high-density polyethylene is recognized as most resilient, polypropylene is slightly harder and may chip or crack more easily, and polystyrene crystallizes in sunlight, which compromises its durability. They saw chipped ribs above grade where mowers hit them, panels that settled, and connectors that cracked or separated.

Their summary is that there was still no clear evidence that barriers on street trees avoid harm to the tree and reduce sidewalk damage. Pittenger and Hodel cite other work that barriers only delay surface-root problems and that fewer roots do not always mean less damage.

City requirements and other trials

None of the four papers reports what any council or city requires. Municipal planting specifications are compared in the guide to planting specs by city. Barriers beside new sidewalks were tested in three other controlled studies.

Sources