ArbNation Join free

Root plate and root zone: how roots anchor trees, per Forest Research and two papers

Forest Research, a 2008 Annals of Botany model and a 2025 field study of 21 trees describe how the root plate holds a tree against wind. All three tie anchorage to soil.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Three sources cover how roots and soil hold a tree against overturning. Forest Research gives the wind-damage frame for British forests. A finite element study models which roots carry the load. A field study pulled and uprooted trees.

Forest Research on tree stability

Forest Research names three groups of processes behind windthrow: the interaction of trees and wind, of roots and soil, and of wind and topography. It reports that storms damaged volumes of timber above 1 million cubic metres at least five times in the last 50 years. Its research aims include the link between root development and soil properties, and anchorage related to tree size, species, soil group and rooting depth. The page is about forest stands and the ForestGALES wind-risk model for conifer plantations.

A model of which roots carry the load

Fourcaud, Ji, Zhang and Stokes built a two-dimensional finite element model of uprooting in Annals of Botany 101(8), 2008. They tested two herringbone root patterns in a soft saturated clay and a loamy sand, then removed roots one at a time.

  • Clay: the longest roots set the size of the root-soil plate, and roots inside it added nothing to anchorage. The authors put the plate circumference at 3.2 m for most patterns and 3.0 m for two.
  • Sand: removing roots changed the shape of the plate and the rotation axis. The tap root counted for 22.2 percent of strength in the horizontal-lateral pattern and 0.6 percent in the 45 degree pattern.
  • Roots lost: removing the shallow lateral roots cut strength by 26.1 and 23.7 percent on average. Removing the deeper short laterals cut it by 1.9 and 1.6 percent.
  • Stress: stresses ran highest in the most superficial roots and in leeward roots in sand.

A field test of 21 trees

Andreozzi and co-authors tested 21 trees of eight species at the University of Dundee Botanic Gardens and reported the results in Forests 16, 1780, published November 27, 2025. Fifteen trees were uprooted. The maximum overturning moment came between 1.59 and 2.93 degrees of inclination, irrespective of species.

They tried two plate models on the data. A model with resistance in proportion to the square of the root-plate diameter did not fit. A circular foundation model with stiffness in proportion to the cube of the diameter gave a reasonable fit. They suggest structural roots beyond the conventional plate may add resistance that simple geometric models miss.

The authors found no correlation between maximum overturning moment and trees of the same species with similar size. They conclude that stability depends much more on the site-specific conditions of each tree, and say soil strength and water content were at least as important as species. They also list earlier winching work, including 368 pulling tests on Sitka spruce with failure moments of 16 to 53 kNm.

Where the sources differ

The two journal papers weigh the plate differently. The model treats a plate defined by the longest roots in clay and a shifting axis in sand. The field study reports that a model with resistance proportional to the square of the plate diameter did not yield satisfactory results on mature trees at one botanic garden. Both are single studies on specific soils. Windthrown plates on the ground are described in the guide to windthrown root plates.

Sources