Root pruning and root loss: what trenching and anchorage research reports on stability
Pull tests on trenched trees show stability falling with root loss, and a 2025 trial put the loss in bending stress at about 2 percent for each percent of root volume cut. A 2007 model finds that which roots matter depends on the soil.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The studies and the brochure below are described as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. None of them gives a root loss at which a tree's stability stays unchanged.
Pull tests after cutting roots
The 2025 Arboriculture & Urban Forestry paper by Jason Miesbauer, Andrew Koeser and Brian Kane reviews the earlier pull-test work. Static pull tests measure the force needed to tilt a tree to a small set angle, 1 degree in the Smiley and 2025 work and 0.2 degrees in the Fini work.
- Smiley (2008) trenched young willow oaks at steps from 5 times trunk diameter down to 1 times. The force to reach 1 degree fell when trenching came within 2 diameters of the trunk.
- In the same study roots were removed from 50 percent of the root flare circumference. The share of roots cut and the loss in pulling force had a linear relationship (r squared 0.80). Smiley and co-authors (2014) repeated this on red maple and found 0.74.
- Fini and co-authors (2020) trenched horse chestnut and linden 40 cm from the trunk, about 4.5 times diameter, on one side or on two. Linden showed an effect of one-sided trenching more than 4 years later. Two-sided trenching cut uprooting resistance in both species for the full 51 months.
The 2025 trial on root volume
Miesbauer and colleagues trenched 30 red maples in Florida at 1, 3 or 5 times trunk diameter. They then dug each root system, reattached the cut roots and measured volume by photogrammetry. Trenching at 1 times diameter removed 13.3 percent of root volume on average, against 4.1 percent at 3 times and 2.5 percent at 5 times. Bending stress fell by 45.2, 35.2 and 22.3 percent.
The authors put the relationship at about a 2 percent drop in bending stress for each percent of root volume lost (r squared 0.5466). They conclude that even a small volume of root loss can meaningfully reduce stability. They add that pulling in the elastic range may not match the load that causes uprooting, and they call for tests to failure.
Where the studies differ
Smiley (2008) saw a 23 percent fall in pulling force when roots were cut at 1 times diameter. The 2025 trial saw 50 percent at the same distance. The authors point to method, since Smiley trenched in steps and they assigned one distance per tree. They also point to species and soil, and to the deep uncut roots Smiley suspected in willow oak.
Other studies measured growth and water stress rather than stability. Miller and Neely (1993) followed 98 trenched trees and found the harm to growth lessened with distance from the trunk. The American Society of Consulting Arborists proposed a buffer of 0.3 m per 2.5 cm of trunk diameter in 1989. Benson and co-authors (2019) found long-term water stress avoided when linear trenching stayed at 6 times diameter or more.
Anchorage in a computer model
Thierry Fourcaud and colleagues ran two-dimensional finite element simulations of uprooting in the Annals of Botany in 2007. They removed single roots from schematic root systems in two soils, a saturated soft clay and a loamy sand.
In clay the longest roots set the size of the root and soil plate that lifts, so roots inside the plate had no influence on anchorage strength. In sand, removing individual roots changed the plate's shape and size and moved the rotation axis. The tap root and deeper roots mattered more in sand than in clay. The paper calls the work a simple model that shows how root form and soil properties shape anchorage.
The ISA construction brochure
The ISA brochure Avoiding Tree Damage During Construction lists grading, trenching, paving and soil changes within the critical root zone as sources of root damage. If too many roots are damaged, the tree is affected. It says an arborist can prune roots out of the way before excavation, or cut them cleanly, and can arrange temporary irrigation after significant root loss.
Related pages are root cutting limits in tree protection rules and the root plate and root zone.
Sources
- AUF, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, Miesbauer, Koeser and Kane, Impact of Trenching on Root Loss and Tree Stability, 51(1), January 2025, pp. 94-102, read October 19, 2026
- International Society of Arboriculture, TreesAreGood brochure, Avoiding Tree Damage During Construction, 2021 edition, read October 19, 2026
- Annals of Botany, Fourcaud, Ji, Zhang and Stokes, Understanding the Impact of Root Morphology on Overturning Mechanisms: A Modelling Approach, 101(8), October 17, 2007, read October 19, 2026