ArbNation Join free

Root pruning in standards and extension: what A300 Part 8 scope and extension say

ANSI A300 Part 8 covers trenching near a tree, root pruning for tripping hazards and infrastructure damage, and girdling roots. New Mexico State extension, Smiley and Koeser report distances and regrowth for root cuts.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The named standard, extension note and journal studies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.

ANSI A300 Part 8 scope

The Tree Care Industry Association publishes ANSI A300 Part 8, Root Management. Its page says the part seeks to improve the quality, life expectancy and safety of trees by promoting and facilitating the care of roots. It calls the part a guide to writing good specifications on work.

TCIA lists three subjects: trenching near a tree, root pruning to mitigate tripping hazards and infrastructure damage, and managing stem-girdling and stem-circling roots. TCIA adds that Part 8 takes precedence in the USA over previous tree care management standards and guidelines. The site also has a page on ANSI A300 Part 8, Root Management.

New Mexico State University: the critical root radius

Marisa Thompson, extension horticulture specialist at New Mexico State University, answered a reader's question on cutting roots for a house addition in July 2003. She prefers to talk about how close to the tree roots are cut, and teaches the Critical Root Radius, CRR, which recommends not cutting roots inside it.

The CRR in feet is the trunk diameter in inches, measured at 4.5 feet above ground, multiplied by 1.5. A tree with a 5 inch trunk has a CRR of 7.5 feet. She calls it a general guideline: on some trees roots can be cut closer, on others farther away.

Her reasoning is that inside the CRR roots branch little and absorb little water and minerals. They act as pipes carrying what smaller roots farther out collect. Cutting a large root removes all the branch and absorbing roots tied to it. Large roots have lost the ability to regenerate, so the lost absorption is permanent. Smaller roots outside the CRR regenerate more readily.

She adds that roots give the tree a wide base, so removing part of it reduces stability in wind and under snow and ice loads. Cutting absorbing roots may cause dieback in the top of the tree, and she says severe dieback can make removal the safest choice.

Smiley: pull tests on young willow oak

E. Thomas Smiley published Root Pruning and Stability of Young Willow Oak in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in March 2008. He simulated two kinds of root damage and pulled trunks to 1 degree from vertical with measured force. A third of the trees were pulled to failure to relate the two forces, with a regression r2 of 0.76.

Linear cuts across the root zone, which simulated utility trenching, produced measurable drops in force when made within three times the trunk diameter from the trunk. A tangential cut at the trunk cut the force by 35 percent. Severing one root cut it by 12 percent on average, and severing half the exposed buttress roots cut it by 30 percent.

Smiley concludes that arborists should avoid cutting roots near the trunk, and that linear trenching should be no closer than three times the trunk diameter. How much root loss starts a failure risk is covered with the risk guides, including root cutting limits in tree protection rules.

Koeser and others: regrowth after trenching live oak

Koeser, Grabosky, Benson and Morgenroth reported in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in January 2025. In 2017 they simulated trenching on mature live oaks at 3, 6 and 12 times the stem diameter from the base. Five years later they revisited the trees and measured regrowth on the cut roots.

Regrowth appeared on all but 38 of 557 cut roots, or 6.7 percent. The regrowth had on average 22.2 percent of the cross-sectional area of the original root. The treatment distance and the distance between trunk and cut end predicted the level of regrowth, with P values of 0.024 and 0.002. The authors conclude that root systems need many years to recover from trenching and that more distance may have a minor effect on regrowth.

The paper also reports what the International Society of Arboriculture's Best Management Practices, Managing Trees During Construction, third edition, say about distance. The BMP sets a protection zone of 6 to 18 tree diameters from the base, by species tolerance and age. It says long-term water stress can result if trenching is closer than 6 times the diameter. Many trees see a decline in structural integrity when root loss occurs at 3 times, and most face an immediate loss in stability as it approaches 1.5 times.

Sources