Root washing and bare-rooting container trees: what MSU and Cornell trials found
In Michigan State University trials, washing the soil off container tree roots cut circling roots but raised leaf scorch, die-back and early losses in sensitive species. Shaving the root ball cut circling without that cost.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Root washing and bare-rooting are described below as Michigan State University and Cornell University publish their trials. It is not training and does not teach the work. The trials cover container-grown trees and nursery-grown bare-root trees. No opened source reports washing the soil off a balled-and-burlapped tree.
The root treatments compared
Bert Cregg and Riley Johnson of Michigan State University present the trials in a 2026 slide set for the University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Landscape and Grounds Maintenance Short Course. They list five commonly recommended treatments for circling roots on container trees: teasing, butterflying, vertical slicing, shaving and root washing. Their summary of the earlier literature:
- Vertical slicing can disrupt circling roots and improve root egress in some studies, while another (Weicherding and others, 2007) found no difference from the control.
- Teasing is common with small plants and time-consuming. Weicherding and others also found no root-growth difference.
- Shaving the root ball at planting increases new root growth and reduces circling in studies cited as Gilman and Wiese (2012) and Cregg and Ellison (2018).
- Bare-rooting is cited, to Appleton and Flott (2009) and Chalker-Scott and Stout (2009), as the only means of revealing and remediating root defects.
Shaving and teasing, London planetree
In the Cregg and Ellison (2018) trial, four years after planting, root treatments cut the share of circling roots. Two experiments are shown in the slides.
| Treatment | Experiment 1 | Experiment 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Control | 87.5 | 76.3 |
| Teased | 12.5 | 2.5 |
| Shaved | 0 | 0 |
Root manipulation had no effect on tree growth after three years. Twelve years after planting, shaving and teasing still showed less circling and better root quality than the control.
Bare-rooting by washing or air tool, 2018 trial
Rouse and Cregg (2021) planted 100 litre container trees of red maple, columnar tulip tree and London planetree in May 2018 (96 trees) and July 2018 (27 trees). The treatments were control, shaving, bare-root by washing and bare-root by air tool. The slides say the root treatments needed extra time at planting.
- Bare-rooting produced more trees with extreme leaf scorch after transplant. Species varied in response, and some trees recovered while others kept declining.
- Mortality varied by species. Tulip trees in the air tool treatment were dropped from measurement after July 2018 because of mortality.
- Bare-rooting raised moisture stress straight after planting. The slides add that trees can recover from the first stress.
- Six years after planting, shaving reduced circling in all three species and improved the root quality rating for tulip poplar and planetree.
The 2021 four-species trial
This trial used London planetree, tulip tree, American hornbeam and hophornbeam, from 1.5 to 2 inch liners grown two years in 25 gallon containers, planted in May 2021. Treatments were control, shaving, vertical slice and bare-root by washing. Bare-rooting cut first-year survival. Crown die-back was rated from 0 for none to 4 for dead.
| Species | Control | Shaved | Bare-root |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hornbeam | 1.1 | 1.5 | 3.0 |
| Tulip tree | 0.0 | 0.0 | 3.9 |
| Hophornbeam | 0.4 | 0.3 | 2.1 |
| London planetree | 0.7 | 0.6 | 0.4 |
Three years in, the treatments reduced circling in every species except hornbeam. They were less effective on other root defects. Vertical slicing reduced circling in two of the four species without improving the root quality rating.
The authors' summary: shaving, teasing and bare-rooting were effective against circling roots, bare-rooting raised water stress and cut survival and added die-back in sensitive species, and the results show shaving to be the most effective approach for container-grown trees.
Cornell's bare-root method for nursery trees
Cornell's Urban Horticulture Institute, with the City of Ithaca, wrote a booklet on planting nursery-grown bare-root trees (2009 edition). It is a different case: trees grown and dug bare, not washed container stock. The Institute's outreach page says that for many species bare root planting is equally as successful as balled-and-burlapped planting.
- Bare-root trees cost one third to one half less than balled-and-burlapped trees.
- In a simple Cornell comparison, bare-root trees of the same size and species had 200 percent more roots than a balled tree. The booklet says about 90 percent of tree roots are routinely left in the nursery at harvest.
- The booklet names root drying between digging and planting as the main drawback. Cornell dips the roots in a fine-grade hydrogel slurry and bags them, for planting within a week.
- Girdling roots can be seen before planting.
The booklet's appendix sorts species by bare-root difficulty from the Institute's and Ithaca's experience. London plane tree is in the easy list. Tulip tree, hornbeam and American hophornbeam are in the difficult list, the same species where the Michigan trial saw the worst die-back after washing.
Sources
- Bert Cregg and Riley Johnson, Michigan State University, Getting to the root of the problem with container-grown trees, slides for the UW-Madison Division of Extension Landscape and Grounds Maintenance Short Course, 2026, read October 16, 2026
- Cornell University Urban Horticulture Institute, Outreach: Transplanting, read October 16, 2026
- Michelle Buckstrup and Nina Bassuk, Cornell Urban Horticulture Institute, Creating the Urban Forest: The Bare Root Method, 2009, read October 16, 2026