ArbNation Join free

Street trees and pavement life: the shade-and-asphalt study and what it found

McPherson and Muchnick paired 48 street segments in Modesto, California, and found better pavement condition under more tree shade. Their model projects US$7.13 per square metre saved over 30 years under large hackberries.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

One study measures the effect of street tree shade on asphalt: McPherson and Muchnick, "Effects of Street Tree Shade on Asphalt Concrete Pavement Performance", Journal of Arboriculture 31(6), November 2005, pages 303 to 310. The paper is held in the US Forest Service Treesearch library and on the University of Arizona Water Resources Research Center site. The study area was Modesto, California, a city of 925 street kilometres, about 60 percent of them residential.

Why the authors tested it

The paper opens with the view of street trees as liabilities, through litter, sidewalk root damage and blocked signs and lights. The authors say no earlier work had examined tree shade against pavement performance. Higher surface temperatures harden asphalt binder and make pavement more prone to rutting and fatigue cracking, and street trees lower air and surface temperatures by cutting the sunlight that reaches the ground. Modesto's street superintendent had estimated that repaving could be put off 10 years on a well-shaded street and possibly up to 25 years on heavily shaded streets.

The sample

The team used Modesto's street tree inventory, geographic information system and street services records to find residential streets built in the 1950s and 1960s, with most original trees still in place and similar maintenance histories. Each pair came from identically sized segments of the same roadway, between 93 and 418 square metres. One was low shade and one high shade. The final sample was 24 pairs, or 48 segments, with data collected in summer 2001.

Twenty pairs came from the same street. Four more pairs, drawn from nearby roadways, were matched using asphalt core samples. Matching required air-void content within 3 percent, construction dates within 4 years, and similar layer ratios and aggregate gradation.

Pavement condition was scored with the Metropolitan Transportation Commission's Pavement Condition Index (PCI), from 100 for new pavement to 0 for pavement beyond repair. Shade was scored with a Tree Shade Index (TSI), from 0 for no shade to 100 for complete shade, computed from tree size, crown density and position over the March to October foliation period.

Results

Segments with more shade had higher PCI. The t-test gave t = 4.80 with P below 0.0001, and the regression was significant at P = 0.0001. The regression coefficient was 0.544 with a standard error of 0.117, so each point of added shade index went with about half a point of pavement condition. TSI explained 49 percent of the variation in PCI. A 20-point rise in TSI went with a PCI gain of 10.9, with a 95 percent confidence interval of 6.20 to 15.56.

No single kind of distress was strongly tied to shade. Only alligator cracking showed a significant inverse relation, a mild one, with P = 0.0358. The abstract still credits shade with partly reducing fatigue cracking, rutting, shoving and other distress.

The 30-year projection

The authors built a hypothetical pair of identical 38.1 by 10.7 metre residential streets and used the observed shade and condition relation. Resurfacing was assumed to be a slurry seal whenever PCI fell to 70, with PCI returning to 100 after each seal.

Projected slurry seals over 30 years
StreetShade index at 30 yearsSlurry sealsSaving against unshaded
Unshaded06, about one every 5 yearsNone
12 crape myrtles, 4.4 m crown diameter95, one every 6 yearsUS$829, 17 percent
6 Chinese hackberries, 13.7 m crown diameter412.5, one every 12 yearsUS$2,900, 58 percent, or US$7.13 per square metre (US$0.66 per square foot)

The hackberry street also needed half the tree planting cost, the paper reports, though the figure leaves out a possibly higher care cost for large trees.

Limits the authors give

  • The study covers residential asphalt concrete streets like those in the sample. Environmental conditions, materials, traffic loads and preservation methods all affect pavement, and their combined effects are not well quantified.
  • The sampled streets were 40 to 60 years old and kept up with surface preservation, so the results apply mainly to overlays and resurfacing.
  • The savings should not be carried over to other resurfacing treatments or to other climates, because the deterioration curves came from Modesto streets.
  • Real PCI may not return to 100 after each seal, and below-surface defects could speed decline.
  • The scenario is hypothetical and leaves out variation in tree growth, survival and management.

The authors call for controlled laboratory experiments, with identical pavements exposed to different temperature and shade regimes, and for better pavement models that include climate.

Sources