Structural soil and engineered tree soils: the Cornell mix and what its research reports
Cornell's CU-Structural Soil is crushed stone with clay loam in the gaps, compacted under pavement so roots can grow. Cornell's guide and a 1998 paper give the mix, depth, volume and field results.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Cornell University's Urban Horticulture Institute developed CU-Structural Soil, also known as CU-Soil, to carry pavement loads after compaction and still let roots grow. It is patented (US Patent 5,849,069) and trademarked. Licensed producers mix it. The Institute's booklet Using CU-Structural Soil in the Urban Environment (Bassuk, Grabosky and Trowbridge, 2005) and the 1998 ASLA conference paper by Bassuk, Grabosky, Trowbridge and Urban are the sources for the figures below.
The problem it addresses
Pavement needs compacted ground. Compaction crushes the large pores between soil aggregates, so air and water move poorly and roots struggle to enter. The Cornell booklet says roots in dense soil change direction, stop, or stay near the surface. Shallow roots leave a tree more exposed to drought and can heave pavement. The 1998 paper estimates that a tree with most of its roots under pavement lives an average of 7 to 10 years, where 50 or more would be expected in better soil.
What the mix is
The mix has two parts. Angular crushed stone forms a rigid lattice that carries the load and leaves connected voids. Clay loam sits in those voids and feeds the roots. A small amount of hydrogel works as a tackifier so the stone and soil do not separate while mixing and placing.
| Component | Figure |
|---|---|
| Crushed stone | Uniformly graded (booklet) or narrowly graded (1998 paper), 3/4 to 1 1/2 inch, angular; no fines in the 1998 paper |
| Clay loam | At least 20% clay in the booklet; 1998 paper gives clay 25 to 40%, silt 20 to 40%, sand 25 to 30%, gravel under 5% |
| Organic matter | 2 to 5% |
| Hydrogel | Potassium propenoate-propenamide copolymer, 0.03 parts |
| Proportions by weight | Stone 100, clay loam 20, hydrogel 0.03; moisture 10% at mixing |
| Placement | Compacted in 6 inch lifts to not less than 95% Proctor density (AASHTO T-99) |
The two Cornell documents give different bearing figures. The 1998 paper reports a California Bearing Ratio greater than 40. The booklet reports a CBR of 50 or greater when the mix is compacted to 95 to 100% Proctor or Modified Proctor density. The booklet says the stone should meet the regional or state transportation standard for pavement base courses.
Depth, volume and width
- Depth: at least 24 inches, with 36 inches preferred, in both documents.
- Volume: the booklet gives two cubic feet of soil per square foot of crown projection, the area under the drip line at expected maturity. It names the desert southwest as the exception.
- Width: the booklet says there is no established minimum and that the mix was built to run under the whole pavement area, ideally building face to curb. Where that is impossible it describes a trench 5 to 8 feet wide beside the curb. The 1998 paper calls a trench 8 feet wide and 3 feet deep minimally adequate.
- Base course: the booklet says no gravel base is needed on top of the mix.
Where Cornell shows it used
The booklet lists sidewalks, parking lot islands, plazas, medians and low-use access roads. It also shows a break-out zone: two sidewalk flags removed, the ground dug 24 to 36 inches, and the mix backfilled so roots can pass under the pavement into an adjoining lawn. Where a planter wall has a deep footing, it shows a 6 to 8 inch PVC sleeve filled with uncompacted soil to let roots through. With non-mortared pavers, it shows a coarse sand setting bed over a geotextile above the mix. It says the mix is for places where compaction is required. Where it is not, it calls for a good, well-draining soil.
Research results
- Roots in the mix grow deep into the base material, away from the temperature swings at the pavement surface, and are less likely to heave pavement than under conventional paving.
- An excavation of a seven-year-old installation showed no aggregate migration.
- Roots have been seen moving around stones and surrounding some of them in older installations.
- Cornell says frost heave has not been rigorously tested. It reports no frost heave damage in its Ithaca, New York installations.
- The booklet reports no nutrient deficiencies so far, probably because of the large soil volume.
- The two oldest installations date to 1994: a honeylocust planting on the Staten Island Esplanade in New York City and a London plane planting on Ho Plaza at Cornell.
- Cornell says research on whether hydrogel breaks down is continuing. It expects roots and soil organisms to take over its role over time.
The 1998 paper counts the extra drainage and deeper excavation as added project cost and suggests new construction or infrastructure repair as the best fit. The booklet says new trees still need supplemental water in the first growing season.
Other engineered soils
Everything above concerns the Cornell stone and clay loam mix. Cornell's outreach page links to its guides on stormwater and on porous asphalt over the mix, but gives no data on sand-based or other stone-soil blends. Soil cells and suspended pavement are in structural soil, soil cells and suspended pavement.
Sources
- Cornell University Urban Horticulture Institute, CU-Structural Soil outreach page, read October 15, 2026
- Bassuk, Grabosky and Trowbridge, Using CU-Structural Soil in the Urban Environment, Cornell University, 2005 (hosted by Virginia Tech), read October 15, 2026
- Bassuk, Grabosky, Trowbridge and Urban, Structural Soil: An Innovative Medium Under Pavement That Improves Street Tree Vigor, ASLA Annual Meeting Proceedings 1998, read October 15, 2026