ArbNation Join free

After stump grinding: roots left in the ground, regrowth and replanting

A ground stump leaves wood and roots below the surface. Purdue, Iowa State and Ask Extension describe slow decay, settling soil, root sprouts and a replanting site that stays difficult.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Three extension pages cover what is left after a stump is ground: Purdue University Forestry and Natural Resources, Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, and Ask Extension. None of the three gives a grinding depth figure. Grinding is also described in three other extension descriptions of stump removal.

What stays below ground

Purdue says a stump location has limited soil and rooting depth for nutrient uptake and structural stability, because of the below-ground mass that remains. Decay can take several years to finish unless the stump was ground very deeply or removed with an excavation machine. As the wood rots and loses its fibre, the ground settles, and Purdue's answer is to add soil back to replace the roots and stump below.

Iowa State makes the same point from the other side. If any of the old tree's roots are still in the ground, a newly planted young tree may not have enough room to grow.

Grindings in the soil

Purdue says the woody debris from grinding has a high carbon to nitrogen ratio, which lowers the nitrogen available to a new tree or to grass. Iowa State puts it that the sawdust left by grinding and stump removal usually changes the structure and nutrient balance of the soil drastically, which makes it hard for a new tree to grow. It adds that the old tree used many of the nutrients a young tree would rely on.

Sprouts from the roots

Purdue says sprouts may come up because the roots act as energy storage for the tree. Purdue's answer for them is a typical lawn herbicide, used as needed at the label rate. Species differ in how hard they sprout, and that is covered in the guide to stump sprouting by species.

Grass over a ground stump

Purdue usually does not want new trees or turf planted immediately over the top of a stump. For grass, its answer is to add soil to the stump area with a little extra mounded to allow for decay. Sod is preferred, though seed can work. Slow-release turf fertilizer offsets the nitrogen the grindings tie up, and yellowing is the sign of low nitrogen.

A new tree in the same spot

Iowa State says planting a new tree in the exact spot of a removed one is possible but not advised, and calls a new site best. It also names a possible disease or pest in the soil when that was why the old tree came out. A spot at least three feet from the old tree avoids most of the problems with soil, nutrients and old roots, and six to eight feet is better.

For a new tree that has to go in the same place, Iowa State says establishment will be difficult. For that case it lists four points:

  • Waiting a few years lets the old roots decompose. A year or two is the minimum before it makes a difference.
  • Site preparation means removing the stump and all the sawdust, chopping out as many roots as possible, and filling with compost and topsoil.
  • If disease or insects killed the old tree, the new one should be a species they do not affect.
  • A new tree does not succeed in the decomposing stump itself, because of the soil, rooting space and moisture.

An Ask Extension answer for a parking strip in Multnomah County, Oregon, covers planting after grinding. The expert gives a hole at least twice as wide as the root ball and only as deep as the root ball, with the top of the root ball level with the surface. The answer calls loosened original soil mixed with 10 to 20 percent compost the best backfill. Later it says research shows organic amendments are not necessary and that one plant is best backfilled with the soil that came out of the hole. The question asked about the grinding chips, and the answer does not mention them. It ends with a soil saucer 2 to 3 inches high and a 3-inch layer of mulch.

Sources