ArbNation Join free

Thyer and the Australian valuation methods: Thyer, Burnley and the IACA rating

Australia never finalised a standard for valuing amenity trees. Drafts were withdrawn in 1975 and 2004 never approved in 1992 and not widely accepted in 1999, and a 2006 draft carried the Thyer and Burnley formulas.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Dr G M Moore of the University of Melbourne's Burnley campus wrote the 2006 account of Australia's tree valuation drafts for the 7th National Street Tree Symposium. The Minimum Industry Standard MIS506, a Canterbury-Bankstown Council release and a Parramatta planning agenda fill in the rest. The guide to the Burnley method covers that formula in full.

A standard that never finished

Moore writes that the first attempts at an Australian Standard for amenity tree evaluation came more than thirty years before his paper. A draft released for comment in 1973 was withdrawn in 1975. A 1992 draft was never approved, though many arborists used it between 1992 and 1999, and the opposition of the powerful insurance and utility sectors "virtually doomed" it. A 1999 draft took a new approach and was widely criticised. A 2004 draft was withdrawn before wide circulation.

Standards Australia convened a committee again in 2005. Its document EV 01800-00-02, Draft Amenity Trees: Guide to Valuation, went to the working committee in 2006. It kept the 1999 framework of repair, replacement and non-replacement valuation, revised the 1992 formula, and included a shortened Burnley method and the 2005 Thyer method. Moore says the Burnley and Thyer methods had performed well in comparative studies by Garner (1999), Watson (2002) and Fitzgerald (2005). His own view was that prospects for finalising the draft were not bright.

The formulas in the 2006 draft

MethodFormula as Moore prints itInputs
Thyer (2005)Tree value = S x A x Q x PS is size factor, A is age factor, P is planting cost in dollars. Q adds eight scores: health, environmental benefit, life expectancy, re-establishment potential and rate of growth (each 0 to 8), and social benefit, form and features, and social significance (each 0 to 16)
Burnley (revised 2005)Value = V x B x E x FV x LV is the volume of a cone, B is a base value per cubic metre, E is useful life expectancy (0.5 to 1.0), FV is form and vigour (0.00 to 1.00), L is a location modifier (0.4 to 1.0)
1992 draft, revisedValue = P(I x L x C + F x Y x S x V)P is a unit value factor. I, L, C, F, Y, S and V are visual impact, site suitability, cultural significance, frequency of occurrence, life expectancy, live crown size and form and vigour, each on a 1,5 to 15 scale
City of MelbourneValue = basic value x species x aesthetics x locality x conditionBasic value is matched to trunk diameter at breast height. Proposed as a replacement for the revised 1992 formula, but not agreed by the committee

The Thyer formula is credited to Peter Thyer, whose 2005 paper is cited as an online publication. Moore adds that stakeholders could use all three non-replacement formulas and present an average in controversial cases.

MIS506 and the methods it lists

MIS506 is a book in the Minimum Industry Standards series, produced by Arboriculture Australia Ltd and the New Zealand Arboricultural Association with the arboriculture community in both countries. Its contents page lists a history of tree valuation for the USA, Europe, and Australia and New Zealand. Chapter 5 covers selected current methods: Burnley, City of Melbourne, the Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers, i-Tree Eco, the Standard Tree Evaluation Method (STEM) and Thyer, followed by the historical Standards Australia/New Zealand drafts. MIS506/22 names its own compliant method with market baseline, land use, social and quality factors.

Burnley in a council fines motion

On August 28, 2024, Canterbury-Bankstown Council announced that a Notice of Motion had been adopted at the previous night's meeting after the poisoning and removal of mature eucalypts at Picnic Point. The motion called on Council to advocate for higher fines using the Burnley Method, which Councillor Linda Downey called a scientific and equitable approach. The release says Council would also write to the Minister for Planning and Public Spaces about tougher penalties for vandalism of trees on public land.

IACA significance rating

The Institute of Australian Consulting Arboriculturists published its Significance of a Tree, Assessment Rating System (STARS) in 2010. A Parramatta City Council planning agenda of December 19, 2023 reproduces it in an appendix to a private arborist's impact report. That text says rating a tree's landscape significance is subjective, so the system uses structured criteria to set a retention value.

  • High, medium and low significance in the landscape are the three classes.
  • High significance criteria include good condition, typical form, rarity or substantial age, listing as a heritage item or on a council significant tree register, and visual prominence.
  • A tree needs at least three criteria in a category to be placed in that group.
  • Retention value comes from a priority matrix. The report's notes mark retention as high, medium, low or removal.

The Parramatta text credits a 2001 Footprint Green matrix as the original concept.

Sources