ArbNation Join free

A tree crew damaged my property: what insurance offices and extension services record about claims

Insurance offices in Tennessee and the District of Columbia describe claims for damage by contractors, and extension services in New Jersey and Georgia cover tree-care insurance, contracts and payment. None of the four is a tree crew claims guide.

This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance guide is about blasting debris, and the District of Columbia Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking guide is about repair contractors after an insured loss. Neither names tree crews. Rutgers Cooperative Extension and University of Georgia Extension write about tree care services directly.

Insurance the crew carries

University of Georgia Extension Circular 1098 lists certificates of insurance among the things to ask a tree service for, including proof of liability for personal and property damage and workers' compensation. It adds that the owner contacts the insurance company to see whether the policy is current. In some circumstances, the circular says, an owner can be held financially responsible if an uninsured worker is hurt on the property or damages a neighbour's property.

The Rutgers fact sheet FS019 lists proof of coverage for personal liability, property liability and workmen's compensation. It also has the owner call the insurer to confirm the policy is current and the cover adequate, at least US$1 million per occurrence. The District of Columbia guide asks for a certificate of insurance showing liability and workers' compensation cover. For the certificate itself, see the guide to certificates of insurance and additional insured status.

Reporting the damage to the home insurer

The Tennessee guide was compiled by the State Fire Marshal's Office and the Insurance Division for homeowners hit by fly-rock from blasting.

  • A homeowner whose property is damaged contacts the insurance company or agent to explore reporting a claim.
  • The contractor may not automatically pay. Contractors must be bonded, yet neither the Fire Marshal's Office nor the Insurance Division can force a contractor to pay a homeowner.
  • The contractor may have made arrangements to compensate for damaged property, and the guide lists contacting the contractor.
  • If the contractor does not respond, the guide says the insurer or a private attorney may be able to help recover the loss.

The guide also covers the claim itself. Permanent repairs wait for the insurer's adjuster, a visual record of the damage is made before repairs begin, and receipts for necessary temporary repairs are saved. It warns that skipping temporary repairs needed to protect damaged property may leave later damage outside the homeowner's policy. It points to the policy section headed What You Must Do After a Loss, and says the claim and repair process may take more than a few days.

Where an insurer has refused to let a policyholder file or has improperly denied a claim, the Consumer Insurance Services Section of the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance takes complaints and can help mediate.

What the insurer does and does not do

The District of Columbia guide separates the roles. The insurance company's legal obligation is to pay the insured homeowner the amount needed to restore the home to its condition before the loss. It does not make the repairs. The homeowner selects the contractor, signs the contract and manages the work.

After a claim is filed, the insurer sends an adjuster, who prepares an itemized scope of loss estimating materials and labour. The guide says homeowners often assume the insurer answers for the contractor. Once the claim is paid, it states, the insurer has no legal responsibility for the quality or progress of the work, delays, damage the contractor causes or violations by the contractor. Old damage is not covered.

Contracts, estimates and payment

Both extension sources deal with the paperwork that comes before any damage. Rutgers says a professional arborist provides a written statement of need, an estimate, a contract and proof of certification and insurance on demand. It lists what the contract specifies: start and end dates, the trees to be worked on, the pruning standards, clean-up, firewood, stumps and total cost, with an hourly rate for unexpected work.

Georgia says the contract names the cost, the tasks and the responsibility for clean-up and disposal. It adds that terms for residential tree work are usually due on delivery, and that an owner need not feel obligated to pay in full until the work is done. Rutgers lists advance payment, other than for plant and landscape materials, among the things to beware of, with door-to-door solicitation and special deals for fast decisions.

Sources compared

What each office covers
SourceContextRelevant content
Tennessee Department of Commerce and InsuranceBlasting debrisReport to insurer, contractor bonded but not forced to pay, adjuster, records, complaints
DC Department of Insurance, Securities and BankingRepair contractors after an insured lossInsurer pays, owner contracts, no insurer liability for contractor work, certificate of insurance
Rutgers Cooperative Extension FS019Hiring tree careInsurance proof, at least US$1 million per occurrence, written contract, advance payment
University of Georgia Extension C1098Hiring tree careCertificates of insurance, owner responsibility if uninsured, written contract, payment on completion

Crew liability from the worker's side is set out in the page on property damage claims. Claims for a fallen tree sit under who pays when a tree falls.

Who to call

Sources