Tree-cutting verdicts and penalties: cases with a court record or agency release
Three entries with a court record or council release: a AU$36,000 fine in New South Wales, treble damages against a Minnesota township, and US$108,000 in statutory damages for 98 trees cut on Vermont park land.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. Each entry below rests on one court opinion or one agency release, and the figure is printed as that record prints it.
Register of entries
| Place and year | Record | Amount as written |
|---|---|---|
| New South Wales, 2025 | Council media release; Bankstown Local Court | AU$36,000 fine, AU$18,000 of it to the council |
| Minnesota, 2010 | Court of Appeals, file A09-1742 | US$5,213 tree value, trebled against the township |
| Vermont, 2006 | Supreme Court, No. 04-371 | US$108,000 statutory damages |
New South Wales: Padstow Heights, 2025
The City of Canterbury Bankstown released the outcome. A developer was convicted in Bankstown Local Court after admitting that trees came out of a Padstow Heights construction site between March and April 2024. The release lists a native weeping lilly pilly, two evergreens and a magnolia removed without consent. A eucalyptus was also pruned without consent.
Council inspectors found the removals after reports from community members. Six penalty infringement notices went out first. The developer took the matter to court instead of paying them. In court the developer said an architect had told him permission was granted, and accepted full responsibility.
The magistrate called the breaches of the NSW Environmental Planning and Assessment Act not insignificant. The fine was AU$36,000, with half ordered to the council. The council said it would see the trees replaced.
Minnesota: township road easement, 2010
The Minnesota Court of Appeals opinion is unpublished. Its own header says it may not be cited except as Minn. Stat. 480A.08, subd. 3 provides. The facts date to 2003. A township hired contractors to clear brush along a road that runs on an easement over private land. They removed about 135 trees within 25 feet of the road centreline. The township gave no notice, which Minn. Stat. 160.22 requires of a road authority.
An earlier appeal held that the township cut the trees without lawful authority. The trespass-to-trees statute, Minn. Stat. 561.04, sets treble damages unless the trespass was casual or involuntary. On remand the district court found a tree value of US$5,213. One township witness had put it at US$1,430. The district court allowed single damages only.
The Court of Appeals upheld the US$5,213 value. It also upheld the finding that the contractors acted in good faith, so they owed single damages. It held that the township was liable for treble damages as a matter of law, because it never argued the cutting was casual or involuntary. The case went back for judgment on that basis.
Vermont: state park land, 2006
The Vermont Supreme Court decided No. 04-371 on June 30, 2006. The defendant cut 98 trees on a swath of state park land between his property and the reservoir in Hyde Park. The State sued under the timber trespass statute, 13 V.S.A. 3606, which allows multiple damages.
The jury put the value of the trees lost at US$54,000 and the value of the replacement trees at US$54,000. It also filled in US$62,500 as punitive damages. The Supreme Court held that punitive damages are unavailable together with multiple damages under section 3606. It held the State entitled to statutory damages of US$108,000 and sent the case back for judgment in that amount.
To correct or remove an entry, write to the address at the foot of this page.
Sources
- City of Canterbury Bankstown, Hefty fine for illegally removing protected trees, media release of October 29, 2025, read October 19, 2026
- Minnesota Court of Appeals, file A09-1742, unpublished opinion filed April 27, 2010, read October 19, 2026
- Vermont Supreme Court, No. 04-371, decided June 30, 2006, as published by FindLaw, read October 19, 2026