Tree health diagnosis step by step: the keys extension publishes
Kentucky extension lays diagnosis out in five steps and Wisconsin extension in twelve. Both start with the plant and leave the cause for later steps. Alabama extension adds the symptom and sign split.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Five steps in the Kentucky fact sheet
University of Kentucky fact sheet PPFS-GEN-15, Considerations for Diagnosis of Ornamentals in the Landscape, is a checklist of five steps. The authors name abiotic conditions, mechanical damage, insects and wildlife as frequent culprits, and a site visit as the way to gather what a diagnosis needs.
- Begin the evaluation. Record the plants and cultivars affected, their normal appearance, location, height, planting date and depth, soil type, watering, drainage, sun exposure, the dates fertilizer was applied, and the dates and rates of fungicides, insecticides and herbicides. Photos cover close-ups, symptoms, and wide views of the plants and the area around them.
- Examine the site. Is one plant affected or several, of one type or many? Is there a pattern, such as near a neighbor's property, near a foundation, in shade, or along a drainage line? The checklist lists low and high areas, slopes, compaction and hardpan, then history: de-icing salt, grade change, herbicide, irrigation, transplanting, construction and weather extremes.
- Examine the whole plant. The checklist asks whether symptoms came on gradually or fast, whether they recur, and which way they move: top down, bottom up, tips toward the trunk or trunk toward the tips. It also asks where they sit, and notes wire or string in the trunk, volcano mulch, a missing buttress flare and suckers.
- Identify the symptoms and possible causes, by leaf, by branch, stem and trunk, and by root.
- Reach a conclusion. If the field diagnosis is inconclusive, the notes go with a sample to a plant diagnostic laboratory.
Branch and trunk symptoms with the causes listed
| Symptom | Possible causes in the fact sheet |
|---|---|
| Cankers or lesions | Fungal or bacterial disease; mechanical injury such as mower or string trimmer |
| Dieback, slow decline, thinning canopy | Vascular pathogens, root-related problems, environmental stress, transplant shock |
| Mushrooms or bracket fungi | Wood decay, which often follows decline from stress |
| Oozing sap | Disease pathogen such as Phytophthora or bacterial wetwood; physical injury |
| Staining or streaking of inner branch tissue | Vascular diseases such as oak wilt and Verticillium wilt |
| Sawdust or frass | Insects |
Twelve steps in the Wisconsin slides
Vijai Pandian, a horticulture educator with University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, presents 12 schematic steps. They run in this order:
- Identify the plant.
- Learn what is normal for the species and cultivar.
- Check common problems with that kind of plant.
- Look for signs and symptoms.
- Assess the entire plant.
- Note when the symptoms were first seen.
- Note how much of the plant is affected.
- Check the adjacent plants.
- Record site conditions, including soil pH, texture and compaction, roads, drain spouts, buildings, construction and shade.
- Record the maintenance history: planting date, watering, fertilizer, pruning and sprays.
- Record the weather, such as winter swings, spring freezes, drought or excess moisture.
- Ask what the owner thinks the problem is.
The analysis part then sorts the problem into biotic causes, meaning insects and diseases, or abiotic ones such as heat, cold, wet, dry, soil pH and herbicide drift. The slides give reasons for diagnosing properly: the right treatment, saved time and money, and less spread of infection. They list wrong plant identification as a challenge, for example green ash against mountain ash.
Signs, symptoms and the questions asked first
Tony Glover of Alabama Cooperative Extension, in a plant diagnostics presentation, frames the work as detective work: who, what, where, when and why. Questions come before answers, conclusions wait, and the first test is whether a real problem exists at all. The plant is compared with a healthy plant of the same species.
Glover separates symptoms from signs. Symptoms are changes in growth or appearance and dead plant parts. They are not definitive and usually very general. Signs are evidence of the cause: a pathogen, an insect, mechanical damage, chemical residue, plant secretions, a damage pattern or recent weather records.
He reports that many problems start at the root level and often trace to transplanting and aftercare, especially in plants three years old or less. His examples of normal parts mistaken for pests include a catkin read as worms and a juniper's berry-like fruit set against a bagworm's bag. His photo list asks for an object of known size, close-ups, the transition zone between good and bad tissue, several angles, and the base of the plant with mulch pulled back.
Sources
- University of Kentucky Cooperative Extension, PPFS-GEN-15, Considerations for Diagnosis of Ornamentals in the Landscape, Leonberger, Gauthier, Aldenderfer and Leonberger, July 2019, read October 16, 2026
- University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, 12 Schematic Steps in Diagnosing Plant Disorders, Vijai Pandian, slides dated March 23, 2020, read October 16, 2026
- Alabama Cooperative Extension System, CSI Southeast Plant Diagnostics, Tony Glover, read October 16, 2026