ArbNation Join free

Tree shelters, spiral guards and mesh: what forestry agencies and extension publish

Forest Research gives guard heights from 200 mm for voles to 1.8 m for red deer. GOV.UK puts plastic shelters at 5 to 10 years before breakdown, and Purdue says 5 to 7.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Forest Research, the Forestry Commission, GOV.UK, Forest Advisory Scotland and Purdue University publish the guard and shelter details below. It is not training and does not teach the work.

The types

GOV.UK technical guidance on mammal damage calls shelters, spirals, guards and tubes protective structures around young trees against browsing, gnawing and bark stripping. Tall and medium ones, up to 2 metres, are meant for deer and livestock. Shorter ones deter voles, rabbits and hares. Shelters and tubes are usually translucent polypropylene on wooden stakes. Spirals and guards are usually metal or plastic mesh wrapped on the stem. Against beavers, welded-mesh guards are required.

Forest Research Note 12, by Trout and Brunt, adds that shelters give a favourable microclimate and fast early growth. Most larger shelters and guards need stakes, while spiral guards are held by the tree and some small shelters are pushed into the ground.

Heights by animal

AnimalIndividual protection in Forest Research Note 12
Voles200 mm split plastic tubes, buried at least 5 mm
Rabbit0.6 m shelters, split tubes, mesh or spiral guards
Hare0.75 m shelters or plastic mesh guards
Roe and muntjac deer1.2 m shelters or plastic mesh guards
Red, sika and fallow deer1.8 m with a heavy stake
Cattle1.8 m steel netting on 2 or 3 stout stakes, viable only for specimen trees

GOV.UK puts the top of the structure just above the maximum browse height of the target animal. Purdue's extension note on hardwood plantations sets shelters at least 4 feet high against deer. It gives shorter shelters for rodents and herbicide drift, and wire cages at least 4 feet high. Its tree guards run 6 to 24 inches and do not stop deer.

Voles and burial depth

The sources print different burial depths for voles. Forest Research gives at least 5 mm for split tubes and shelters, and GOV.UK about 5 mm for spirals. Forest Advisory Scotland, in technical note TN690, gives at least 3 cm for 60 or 120 cm shelters. Purdue says several inches. Forest Advisory Scotland reports that voles nest inside poorly secured shelters. It describes purpose-made vole guards, about 3 cm across and 20 cm tall, and a 1 m weed-free circle round each tree. The Forestry Commission guide also names the 1 m vegetation-free area.

Forest Research reports that plastic guards with aeration holes are ineffective against voles. Purdue says drilled airflow holes are time-consuming and limit spray protection, and that raised tubes or open seams let rodents in.

Spirals and mesh

GOV.UK calls spiral guards effective against voles and small rodents but difficult to remove, prone to fragment, and not recommended. Purdue says the slit spiral type will not girdle a tree, while a solid tube will and must come off first. The Forestry Commission decision tree names spiral or vole guards where voles are present and mesh guards for species that do not gain from shelters. Forest Research notes that lateral growth may still be browsed with spirals and meshes.

Removal timing and materials

GOV.UK gives 5 to 10 years of support and protection before the material breaks down. Purdue gives 5 to 7 years before plastic turns brittle and says shelters stay until the tree reaches about a 2-inch caliper at ground line. It reports that shelters left too long can injure and even kill trees. Forest Research says it may be appropriate to remove treeguards after several years. The Forestry Commission puts the establishment period at a few years, and beyond five on challenging sites.

GOV.UK warns that shelters may raise wind snap risk on exposed sites, and that early growth in the warm, humid microclimate suits some species and not others. Purdue reports late-fall growth inside shelters and winter dieback, a particular problem for black walnut. Removed plastic is subject to waste rules, the Forestry Commission says. GOV.UK says the effectiveness of paper, cardboard, starch and wool alternatives is not yet known, and the Commission does not recommend fragmenting plastics.

Sources