Tree valuation by country: methods named in court, council and industry documents
Courts and councils name different yardsticks for a tree's value: CAVAT in an English planning case, diminution in property value as the general rule in two US appeals, the Burnley Method in an Australian council motion.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here.
Methods named, by country
| Country | Document | Method or measure named |
|---|---|---|
| England | R (Plant) v London Borough of Lambeth [2022] EWHC 3079 (Admin), High Court | CAVAT, as the tool the London Plan and the Lambeth Local Plan name for the value of trees removed. Claim dismissed |
| United States, federal appeal | Humphreys v. Fuselier, No. 99-5232, 10th Circuit, order and judgment of December 19, 2000 | Diminution in the value of the property, under Oklahoma law. Replacement value rejected |
| United States, Ohio | Arnett v. Chappo, 2025-Ohio-4783, Ninth District Court of Appeals, October 20, 2025 | Diminution of value as the general rule. Replacement cost allowed for a shade tree |
| Australia, New South Wales | Canterbury-Bankstown Council media release, August 28, 2024 | The Burnley Method, named in a Notice of Motion on fines for tree vandalism |
| Australia and New Zealand | MIS506 Tree Valuation, Arboriculture Australia and NZ Arb | Burnley, City of Melbourne, Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers, i-Tree Eco, STEM and Thyer |
| New Zealand | No statute, council policy or tribunal decision was opened | The industry standard above is the only New Zealand document in this table |
England: CAVAT in a planning judgment
The claim in Plant against Lambeth challenged planning permission for a block of 20 homes at the Cressingham Gardens Estate. The scheme meant losing four mature trees. Officers used CAVAT to value them and secured a financial obligation of £182,564 for replacement planting nearby, which the report said could fund an estimated 200 trees.
London Plan Policy G7 calls for replacement based on the existing value of the benefits of the trees removed, determined by "for example, i-tree or CAVAT or another appropriate valuation system". Lambeth Local Plan Policy Q10 uses the words "cost/benefit tools such as i-tree or CAVAT". The judge read Q10 in the council's favour and dismissed the claim at paragraph 72. The method itself is set out in the guide to CAVAT.
United States: diminution of value and its exception
In Humphreys, a bulldozer cleared 5,320 square feet of a neighbour's lot in Tulsa County, Oklahoma. The court of appeals agreed that the general rule for injury to real property is diminution in value. It called replacement value a theory "not applied in any Oklahoma cases". The court-appointed appraiser had put the lot at US$127,500 with no loss from the tree destruction. One defendant had settled for US$30,000. The order is marked as not binding precedent.
In Arnett, an Ohio court affirmed an award of US$2,406 for one removed silver maple. The court restated the general measure, diminution of value from removal, and added that the rule is "applied with some flexibility". It noted that replacement cost may be awarded for shade and ornamental trees. The award covered stump grinding, levelling and regrassing the spot, and a young replacement tree.
Australia: the Burnley Method in a council motion
Canterbury-Bankstown Council reported poisoning and removal of more than 12 large eucalypts, and at least 13 trees cut down, at a Picnic Point property. A Notice of Motion adopted at the council meeting called for higher fines using the Burnley Method. The councillor described it as a well-established tree valuation method and wants the state to adopt it in legislation. Council also resolved to write to the Minister for Planning and Public Spaces. The motion changes no penalty by itself. Method detail is in the Burnley guide.
Australia and New Zealand: the industry standard
MIS506 is one of the Minimum Industry Standards written by Arboriculture Australia and the New Zealand Arboricultural Association. Its contents list "selected current methods": Burnley, City of Melbourne, Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers, i-Tree Eco, STEM and Thyer. A further entry covers Standards Australia and New Zealand as historical. Section 6 of the contents names a compliant method, MIS506/22. Section 3 lists the uses of a valuation, among them regulation, contracts, bonds, damages and insurance. See the STEM guide and the comparison of valuation methods.
Sources
- NZ Arb Association, MIS506 Tree Valuation product page and contents, read October 16, 2026
- National Archives, Find Case Law, Plant v London Borough of Lambeth [2022] EWHC 3079 (Admin), read October 16, 2026
- US Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, Humphreys v. Fuselier, No. 99-5232, December 19, 2000, read October 16, 2026
- Ohio Court of Appeals, Ninth District, Arnett v. Chappo, 2025-Ohio-4783, October 20, 2025, read October 16, 2026
- City of Canterbury-Bankstown, Council roots out tree vandals, August 28, 2024, read October 16, 2026