Trees in hard landscapes: the Trees and Design Action Group guidance described
Trees in Hard Landscapes: A Guide for Delivery is a free 2014 guide from the Trees and Design Action Group on trees in streets, civic spaces and surface car parks. It covers process, design, below-ground options and species selection.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The guide and who stands behind it
The Trees and Design Action Group (TDAG) published Trees in Hard Landscapes: A Guide for Delivery in September 2014. The group describes it as exploring the practical challenges and solutions for integrating trees in streets, civic spaces and surface car parks, with process, design and technical options. It names highway engineers, professionals who work on public space and tree specialists as the readers of most interest. The guide won the 2016 Landscape Institute Award for Policy and Research. A French version followed in May 2016.
Four bodies sat on the steering group: the Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers, the Chartered Institution of Highways and Transportation (CIHT), the Institution of Civil Engineers and the Institute of Chartered Foresters. Their notices on the launch, and one from the Construction Industry Council, put the free PDF on the TDAG website and credit over 100 built environment professionals and organisations with interviews, case studies and feedback. CIHT's spokesperson called the guide of interest and value to its members.
Four parts
The guide itself opens with a foreword from the Minister of State for Transport, dated September 14, 2014. It lists competing demands for space under streets, changing street use, heavier rainfall and the choice of tree for place. Its overview then gives four building blocks.
- Collaborative process: when, how and with whom joined-up working happens from project start to maintenance and monitoring.
- Designing with trees: strategies for trees to contribute to a project's design objectives.
- Technical design solutions: the below-ground options for lasting success.
- Species selection criteria: the frame of reference for choosing trees.
Roots, oxygen and rooting volume
The technical part treats soil aeration and rooting volume as the two basic preconditions. It reports that when soil oxygen falls below 10 percent, tree roots stop growing. Hard landscapes can compromise aeration through sealed surfaces, poor drainage and compaction. The guide names two likely results: early decline of the tree, or roots growing in the air gap between compacted soil and the surfacing, which raises the risk to infrastructure.
It lists strategies for rooting volume, among them estimating volume early, extending the rooting space beneath paving with substrates that carry the load, planting in a continuous trench and connecting to adjoining soil areas through root paths. Published volume estimates vary widely with soils, climate and tree size, and the final decision is context and species specific.
Rooting space under paving
The guide sorts the load-carrying options into three categories. Each has a section on how it works, benefits, limitations, locations and cost, and the guide states that there is neither the research nor the criteria by which the options can be compared with each other.
| Category | What the guide records |
|---|---|
| Structural growing media | Sand-based substrates, medium-size aggregate substrates and large-stone skeleton substrates. The components are mixed before installation and laid in compacted layers, with total depth limited to 800 mm because aeration is too poor below that. The guide counts over 40 years of use for sand-based substrates. |
| Crate systems | Modular plastic or concrete cells that bridge over loose soil. The guide says the structure takes about 10 percent of the below-ground volume. It lists the cost as expensive and records about ten years of use for plastic crates. |
| Raft systems | A base layer that floats over the rooting environment. Honeycomb mattress systems have been used longer but carry less load. Tile systems have about ten years of use. Cutting out a portion compromises strength. |
The guide adds that these techniques are not mutually exclusive, and that proprietary products carry their own performance specifications and warranties, which it does not detail.
Utilities and water
For underground utilities the guide points to National Joint Utilities Group volume 4, on apparatus close to trees. It reports Swedish and British tests finding tree roots with a penetration force of 15 to 20 bar per square centimetre against about 6 bar for common rubber pipe joints. Intrusion, where it happens, tends on average to follow about two decades after installation. The guide also covers sustainable drainage with trees. Its 25th case study records a planning request for 20 cubic metres of soil per tree under a car park in New Milton, Hampshire. Roof runoff is piped to the rooting system.
Related pages cover soil cells and suspended pavement, structural soil and tree pit soil volume.
Sources
- Trees and Design Action Group, Trees in Hard Landscapes: A Guide for Delivery, guide page, read October 19, 2026
- Trees and Design Action Group, Trees in Hard Landscapes: A Guide for Delivery, full guide (PDF), September 2014, read October 19, 2026
- Institute of Chartered Foresters, Trees in Hard Landscapes: A Guide for Delivery, notice of September 15, 2014, read October 19, 2026
- Chartered Institution of Highways and Transportation, New guidance published, notice of September 15, 2014, read October 19, 2026
- Construction Industry Council, Trees in Hard Landscapes: A Guide for Delivery, notice of September 5, 2014, read October 19, 2026