Trees in the roadside clear zone: FHWA, Iowa DOT and Wisconsin DOT
FHWA calls a tree with a trunk over 4 inches a fixed object, and Iowa and Wisconsin set 4 inches as the size that triggers treatment or removal in the clear zone. Each measures the trunk a different way.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The Federal Highway Administration, the Iowa Department of Transportation and the Wisconsin Department of Transportation each publish text on trees beside the road. Wisconsin's manual calls its roadside maintenance clear zone a barrier-free area that enhances the sight of drivers, maintains roadside aesthetics and opens the roadway to sunlight in the winter.
FHWA on trees as fixed objects
FHWA's Context Sensitive Solutions page on trees draws from the 1997 guide Flexibility in Highway Design, pages 91 and 92. It reports that single-vehicle collisions with trees account for nearly 25 percent of fixed-object fatal accidents each year and about 3,000 deaths.
A tree with a trunk diameter greater than 100 mm (4 in), measured 100 mm (4 in) above the ground line, is considered a fixed object along the roadway. FHWA lists the factors in placing trees: design speed, traffic volume, roadway cross section and guardrail placement.
FHWA says trees should not be placed in the clear zone for new construction or major reconstruction, and should not be thought safe just outside it. It wants the placement made with a highway designer who knows safety.
Where a community values existing trees, FHWA lists alternatives to removal: traffic barriers, a lower design speed, or a redesign of the facility around the trees. Where sight distance matters, it points to taller trees with trimmed lower branches, or plants shorter than 1 m (3 ft).
Iowa DOT Design Manual, section 8A-4
Section 8A-4 of the Iowa DOT Design Manual, Chapter 8 Roadside Safety, was issued December 13, 2010 and revised March 4, 2021. It covers objects in the clear zone, and objects at or beyond it may be judged case by case.
For trees and shrubs, Iowa DOT measures trunk diameter 6 inches above the ground surface. A tree with several trunks at that height has its trunk diameters added together. For a shrub with several trunks, the largest trunk is the effective diameter. Trees and shrubs with an effective diameter of 4 inches or more should be treated.
Removal is the preferred treatment. The manual lists cases where keeping a tree may be desirable. One is a park, recreation site or residential area where the tree's function or looks would be lost. Another is a tree unique in size, species or historic value. A third is a place where removal would harm endangered species, wetlands or water quality, or cause significant erosion. Where removal is not possible or feasible, trees should be shielded with a barrier.
The same section treats utility poles in the clear zone. Burying the lines is the most preferable fix. If that is not possible, the poles should be relocated to the right-of-way line.
Wisconsin DOT Highway Maintenance Manual, chapter 7
Section 7-10-00 (May 2022) cites Wisconsin Statutes sections 84.07(1) and 66.1037. Its clear zone values come from the Facilities Development Manual, 11-15 Attachment 1.9, with the zone starting at the edge of the traveled way.
The manual states that woody plants over four inches in diameter at maturity shall not be planted or permitted to grow in the highway clear zone. Counties cutting under their maintenance agreements remove all trees over four inches in diameter at maturity inside the clear zone and the vision triangles. Stumps four inches or larger are ground to at least four inches above the ground.
The manual also sets limits on that cutting.
- Mature trees over eight inches in diameter, trees in dooryards, memorial trees, trees with sentimental value and specimen trees are not cut without approval of the maintenance office.
- Trees are not limbed up, except to remove dead or broken branches.
- Dead trees outside the clear zone are not cut unless they could fall onto the roadway.
- Trees are never harvested just to clear the right of way.
The manual lists exceptions. In sensitive areas such as Door County, the whole clear zone need not be cleared. Cutting can run up to 15 feet beyond the clear zone on the south or west side of a roadway when more light is needed for winter maintenance. In areas the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service maps for the rusty patched bumble bee, large woody vegetation beyond the first 15 feet comes out only between October 10 and March 15.
Three ways to size a tree
| Source | Measure | What follows |
|---|---|---|
| FHWA | Trunk over 100 mm (4 in), measured 4 in above the ground line | Counts as a fixed object |
| Iowa DOT, 8A-4 | Effective trunk diameter of 4 in or more, measured 6 in above the ground, multiple trunks added | Should be treated, with removal preferred |
| Wisconsin DOT, HMM 7-10-00 | Diameter over four inches at maturity | Not planted or permitted to grow in the clear zone; removed within it |
FHWA and Iowa DOT use different measuring heights, and Wisconsin's test is the size the tree reaches at maturity, with no measuring height given. Their 4 inch figures are not the same measurement.
Sources
- Federal Highway Administration, Cross-Section Elements: Trees, from Flexibility in Highway Design (1997), page updated June 20, 2017, read October 16, 2026
- Iowa DOT Design Manual, Chapter 8 Roadside Safety, Section 8A-4 Warrants for Specific Objects, revised March 4, 2021, read October 16, 2026
- Wisconsin DOT, Highway Maintenance Manual, Chapter 07 Section 10 Woody Vegetation Management (HMM 7-10-00), May 2022, read October 16, 2026