Two-rope working in the UK: the HSE decision, the AA background and the TG1 update
In 2019 HSE told the Arboricultural Association it would not change its definitions of work positioning and rope access, so stationary rope technique counts as rope access. The Association's magazine said two independently anchored lines would be the principle in most situations.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work. HSE text is adapted from HSE pages published under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
HSE's tree climbing page
HSE states that the Work at Height Regulations 2005 do not ban climbing work. Employers must plan the work and choose equipment that makes it as safe as possible. HSE names two main climbing techniques: work positioning, such as changeover climbing with a harness, friction knot and climbing line, and rope access and positioning, such as footlocking or single rope technique (SRT).
For work positioning, HSE puts the system on two anchor points that carry load, where possible. It adds that work positioning is used only with a suitable backup for preventing or arresting a fall. Where a backup is not reasonably practicable, HSE lists the ways to keep the system from failing: training, properly chosen equipment, reliable anchor points, industry and HSE guidance, and the correct use of tools.
Rope access and positioning is used only with at least two separately anchored lines, one the working line and the other a safety line. The user is connected to both through a suitable harness. The working line carries a safe means of ascent and descent with a self-locking design, and the safety line carries a mobile fall protection system that travels with the user.
A single rope is allowed in rope access and positioning if a risk assessment has shown that a second line would bring higher risk and appropriate safety measures are in place. HSE says it worked with the industry to clarify what is reasonably practicable on two climbing lines and anchors. It points readers to the Arboricultural Association's ICoP and Technical Guide 1.
How the Association tells the history
The Arboricultural Association (AA) published a background page on 15 August 2019. It traces the question to 2003, when the EU work at height directive circulated, and to the 2005 Regulations. The first edition of the Guide to Good Climbing Practice in 1998 had recommended supplementary anchor points and two separate lines wherever possible.
In 2004 the training standards network held 12 practical demonstration events involving about 250 professional climbing arborists. HSE then met the industry at Myerscough College from 3 to 5 November 2004 and commissioned a report, Determination of rope access and work positioning techniques in arboriculture. The 2005 edition of the guide followed that report.
The AA says the first edition of the ICoP, in 2015, set out the principle that all rope and harness climbing can be described as work positioning. That removed the higher level of compliance that Schedule 5, Part 3 of the Regulations attaches to rope access. The AA writes that HSE broadly accepted this in 2015 but has since told the AA it cannot support it.
2019: the HSE decision
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Early 2019 | HSE comments on the draft of Technical Guide 1. It is broadly supportive but objects to how the draft defines climbing systems. |
| 11 March 2019 | AA and HSE meet. HSE does not endorse the ICoP's work positioning approach for all climbing systems. A redrafted Section 8 of the guide, written after the meeting, is also rejected. |
| 10 June 2019 | The AA demonstrates doubled and moving rope systems and single and stationary rope systems to HSE in small trees, trees with limited main anchors and large open-grown and dense-canopy trees. |
| 2 July 2019 | HSE confirms it will not alter its definitions. SRT, used for direct access or as a work positioning technique, is classed as rope access. |
| 15 August 2019 | The AA publishes its background page. |
The AA records that HSE does not read the decision as a large change for work positioning. The test of what is reasonably practicable still applies, but HSE inspectors would expect two points of attachment to be the norm for most of the time. For rope access the Regulations allow a single rope only where a second line would bring higher risk and appropriate safety measures are in place.
The AA also reports HSE's view that the arboricultural sector has the highest accident rate per capita of all UK industries. The AA notes scepticism, since there are no reliable statistics for the sector. HSE's keyword search of RIDDOR reports for April 2017 to March 2018, heavily caveated as an incomplete record, found 117 reportable incidents, 23 of them falls from height, one fatal.
ARB Magazine, autumn 2019
Issue 186 of the AA's magazine carried an update from its senior technical officer, with a statement from Stuart Parry, HM Inspector of Health and Safety. Parry called single-rope climbing and working a custom of the industry for too long and a factor in many falls from height, and said HSE strongly supports the AA promoting two-rope systems.
The AA's article describes a shift it calls subtle but distinct. In its reading, the law sets two lines as the norm, while the mitigating circumstances in Schedule 5 stay available where a second line is not possible or adds risk. Risk assessments would have to justify any single-line exception. The AA expects the change to add time and cost, and to affect trainers and assessors.
The article says some utility sector clients already require two ropes from their contractors. The AA planned to revise the draft Technical Guide 1 and to identify parts of the ICoP to revise, and the issue reports Technical Guides 2 to 5 at stages from design to peer review.
The ICoP second edition and Technical Guide 1
The AA released the second edition of the ICoP in May 2020 after receiving an HSE endorsement. HSE's wording was that it was involved in producing the guidance and that the guidance follows a sensible and proportionate approach to managing health and safety. The AA said the consultation for Technical Guide 1 would open in June 2020.
The AA's shop lists Technical Guide 1: Tree Climbing and Aerial Rescue as a 116-page A5 guide by Chris Cooper-Abbs and Matt Brooker. The shop page calls it part of a series of technical guides meant to be read in sequence, with the ICoP setting the principles for planning and management.
Sources
- HSE, Tree climbing, read October 15, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Background to the HSE decision on two rope working, August 15, 2019, read October 15, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, ARB Magazine issue 186, Autumn 2019, Two ropes in work at height, read October 15, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Updated Industry Code of Practice for Arboriculture released, read October 15, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Technical Guide 1: Tree Climbing and Aerial Rescue, shop listing, read October 15, 2026