Which trees fail in hurricanes: UF/IFAS wind-resistance ratings and the surveys behind them
University of Florida researchers rated tree species for wind resistance from surveys of 18,200 trees after hurricanes. The four ratings run from highest to lowest, and a 2025 paper extends them to 281 more species.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The ratings come from University of Florida Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences (UF/IFAS) work led by Mary Duryea. A team studied hurricanes between 1992 and 2005 and measured urban trees within three to six days of landfall. They looked at over eighty species. All figures here are for wind.
The four ratings
UF/IFAS publication FR174 sorts southeastern coastal plain species into Highest, Medium-High, Medium-Low and Lowest wind resistance. It uses hurricane measurements, a survey of arborists and the scientific literature. The publication adds that no species and no trees are completely windproof, and that soil, tree age and health matter too.
| Rating | Examples listed |
|---|---|
| Highest | Live oak, sand live oak, southern magnolia, American holly, yaupon holly, crape myrtle, flowering dogwood, baldcypress, pondcypress |
| Medium-High | River birch, pignut hickory, sweetgum, sweetbay magnolia, water tupelo, Shumard oak, post oak, winged elm |
| Medium-Low | Red maple, silver maple, sugarberry, sycamore, black cherry, white oak, American elm, slash pine, longleaf pine, loblolly pine |
| Lowest | Pecan, tulip poplar, Bradford pear, laurel oak, water oak, southern red cedar, sand pine, spruce pine, Leyland cypress, Washington fan palm |
The UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions page prints the top two tiers as a planting list for Florida, and says the data came from damage observations, expert opinion and species characteristics.
What the surveys measured
FR174 reports 100 neighbourhoods and 18,200 front-yard trees along street transects. Each tree was recorded as standing, leaning or fallen, and fallen trees as broken or uprooted. The team also sent 240 surveys to arborists, urban foresters and scientists. Eighty-five came back, a 35 percent return.
Circular FR010, from the 1995 Pensacola and Fort Walton Beach surveys, counted 4,911 trees in 25 neighbourhoods. Hurricane Erin brought sustained winds of 85 mph and Opal 125 mph. Eleven percent of trees fell in Erin and 13 percent in Opal.
Survival in Hurricane Ivan
Ivan struck at 209 km/h (130 mph) in 2004. FR174 Table 1 gives the share of trees still standing.
| Species | Standing |
|---|---|
| Sand live oak | 99% |
| American holly | 95% |
| Southern magnolia | 92% |
| Live oak | 91% |
| Flowering dogwood | 81% |
| Laurel oak | 77% |
| Slash pine | 72% |
| Southern red cedar | 61% |
| Sand pine | 48% |
| Tulip poplar | 24% |
FR174 then counted standing trees with half or more of their branches lost as dead. Live oak dropped from 91 to 81 percent, sycamore from 73 to 52 and southern red cedar from 61 to 46. Large trees (100 to 200 cm diameter) lost 30 percent of branches on average, against 12 percent for trees under 20 cm. Live oak fell to 78 percent in Hurricanes Charley and Andrew, at 233 and 265 km/h.
Where the sources differ
FR174 puts pecan in the lowest tier. FR174 Table 1 gives 97 and 93 percent of pecans standing after Erin and Opal. FR010 lists pecan among the best survivors in Erin and Opal and notes that pecan was reported as the least wind-resistant species after Hurricane Camille in 1969. FR010 also names slash and longleaf pines among the best surviving conifers, while FR174 rates both Medium-Low.
The 2025 extension
A paper in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry (2025, volume 51, issue 2) built a machine-learning model on the same four ratings. It trained on 73 species from 39 studies and tested on 52 species from 32 studies, with 91 percent accuracy. It assigned ratings to 281 new species. The authors write that the model did best for Medium-High and High species and worse for Low and Medium-Low. For wind in general, see wind-damaged trees and wind scales and tree damage.
Sources
- UF/IFAS Extension, Duryea and others, Selecting Coastal Plain Species for Wind Resistance (FOR119/FR174), read October 16, 2026
- UF/IFAS Extension, Duryea, Wind and Trees: Surveys of Tree Damage in the Florida Panhandle after Hurricanes Erin and Opal (CIR1183/FR010), read October 16, 2026
- Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, Salisbury and others, Expanding a Hurricane Wind Resistance Rating System for Tree Species Using Machine Learning, March 2025, read October 16, 2026
- UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions, Trees that can withstand hurricanes, read October 16, 2026