ArbNation Join free

Wind loading on trees: what pruning studies report on drag and crown reduction

Two Arboriculture and Urban Forestry studies measured wind load on shade trees before and after pruning. Both found the drop in load followed the mass of foliage and twigs removed. Forest Research covers wind risk to whole stands.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Two papers from Arboriculture and Urban Forestry record wind load on shade trees before and after pruning: Smiley and Kane in 2006 and Pavlis, Kane, Harris and Seiler in 2008. A Forest Research page on windthrow gives the stand-level picture for UK woodland.

Drag, centre of pressure and bending moment

The 2008 paper sets out the physics the studies use. Drag depends on air density, the crown's frontal area, a drag coefficient and wind speed. Bending moment in the trunk is the product of drag and the height of the crown's centre of pressure. Lowering the centre of pressure or lessening drag therefore lowers the bending moment, and the paper treats bending moment as the better measure because it governs mechanical stress in the trunk.

It reports that wind speed rises logarithmically with height above the ground, and that larger trees have stiffer branches, which reconfigure less than those of small trees. On larger trees, drag may follow the square of wind speed instead of the nearly linear relation reported for smaller ones.

Smiley and Kane, 2006

The 2006 study measured wind load, bending moment, height and weight of 81 red maples before and after pruning. The trees were thinned, reduced, lion tailed or stripped of foliage, and tested at 11, 16 and 20 metres per second (25, 35 and 45 miles per hour). Mean trunk diameter was 7.54 cm and mean weight 16.1 kg.

Foliage and twigs removed per tree, Smiley and Kane 2006
Pruning typeAverage removed
Lion tailing3.32 kg, 19 percent
Reduction2.43 kg, 13 percent
Thinning1.93 kg, 11 percent

All three treatments cut wind load by a statistically significant amount against unpruned trees at every speed, and the cut grew with speed. The difference between reduction and thinning was not significant at any speed. The load fell in a straight line with the weight removed, though that link was significant only at 20 metres per second. For the unpruned trees, load rose with wind speed raised to the power 1.4. That is less than the square expected for a rigid body and more than the first power found for some conifers.

Centre of pressure height dropped on thinned and reduced trees and did not change on lion-tailed trees. The authors flag a trade-off. Severe reduction pruning raises the probability of branch decay, and decay raises the risk of branch failure. They call for further work on whether reduction cuts the risk of failure more than thinning.

Pavlis and co-authors, 2008

The 2008 team drove trees on a pickup truck from 0 to 24.5 metres per second (55 miles per hour) to simulate wind. Freeman maple, swamp white oak and shingle oak were measured before and after raising, reduction pruning or thinning, the types in the ANSI A300 standard of the time.

  • The cut in drag-induced bending moment differed by pruning type, largely in line with the mass of foliage and twigs removed.
  • The effect depended on species, because crown shape decided how much mass each type removed.
  • Per unit of mass removed, reduction pruning cut the bending moment more than thinning or raising.
  • Reduction pruning lowered the centre of pressure height and, presumably, made the crown more porous.
  • Crown area removed did not predict the drop in bending moment reliably. Tree mass was the best predictor of bending moment after pruning.

The paper lists limits. The trees were comparatively small. The force was static, while real wind is gusty, and static force overestimates the wind speed at which failures have been documented. No trunk or branch failed in testing, so the study could not tell whether that came from small-tree flexibility or from the absence of decay and weak attachments. It adds that pruning recommendations cannot rest on mechanics alone: physiology, decay and regrowth also count.

The introduction records an older view. Topping was once expected to reduce windthrow and lion tailing to let wind pass through the crown, and the paper says neither presumed benefit was ever rigorously quantified. The paper names a European prescription based on theoretical drag reduction as untested at that time.

Wind risk to stands in Forest Research

Forest Research describes windthrow in woodland, where the unit is the stand. It lists what influences the risk: site exposure, species and rooting form, soil and drainage, stand spacing, thinning regime and tree height. Turning momentum increases with height. It also reports that regular thinning of low to moderate risk stands can reduce risk, yet stands are at highest risk after thinning.

The page links wind risk to climate projections of more frequent storms, higher wind speeds and wetter winters. Waterlogged soils reduce rooting depth and root anchorage. For how storms damage trees in practice, see the guide to why trees fail in storms.

Sources