Branch collar and branch bark ridge: what Shigo, Colorado State and the ISA BMP describe
Alex Shigo's 1982 primer and Colorado State University Extension both place the final pruning cut just outside the branch collar, guided by the branch bark ridge. They tie flush cuts to decay and cracking.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This summary describes what the named publications print about where a pruning cut goes. It is not training and does not teach the work. It quotes no clause of ANSI A300 or BS 3998. The A300 history is in ANSI A300 in one volume.
The two features
Colorado State University Extension defines both. The branch collar is the area where the annual growth rings of the trunk overlap the rings of the side branch, "in a manner similar to shuffling a deck of cards". On some species the collar is noticeable, and on others it is less obvious. The branch bark ridge is where bark from the trunk meets bark from the side branch and rises into a ridge that mirrors the angle of attachment.
Inside the collar sits a narrow cone of cells that Colorado State calls the branch defense zone. It inhibits the spread of decay organisms into the trunk. If the collar is cut or nicked, the zone may fail, and the wound is predisposed to decay.
Alex Shigo, then chief scientist at the US Forest Service Northeast Forest Experiment Station and a tree pathologist, described the same features in Forest Notes in spring 1982. He calls the ridge a hard woody tissue, seen in the bark as a slightly raised ridge, that separates the branch from the main stem. He calls the collar a protective layer the tree forms in the wood at the base of a branch as the branch begins to wane.
Where each source puts the cut
| Case | Publication and description |
|---|---|
| Live branch removed to the trunk | Shigo places the shears or saw in front of the ridge, cutting downward and slightly outward. Colorado State puts the final cut just beyond the collar, at an angle that mirrors the ridge. |
| Species with no clear collar | Colorado State points to the branch bark ridge as the guide. |
| Side branch more than half the trunk diameter | Colorado State says there is no branch collar, and it tilts the final cut out a little more to shrink the wound. With no collar there is also no defense zone. |
| Dead branch | Colorado State puts the cut just outside the collar of live bark. If live wood has grown out along the dead branch, only the dead stub is removed. Shigo says not to injure the collar on living, dying or dead branches. |
| Stubs | Shigo's captions say not to leave a stub. |
What flush cuts do
Shigo writes that a cut behind the ridge injures the main stem and removes the internal chemical protective layer. With a flush cut, microorganisms in the tree gain easy access to the wood above and below the branch. Internal cracks may also result and can split outward later in the life of the tree.
His photographs show the outcomes. Three small trees, two birch and a red maple, show trunk infections linked to flush cuts a few months after pruning. A cherry a year after a flush cut shows cracks starting above and below the wound and discoloured sapwood. A dead red maple branch shows that beneficial fungi decaying the branch stayed inside the protective zone of the collar, which cutting the collar away removes.
The captions say flush cuts covered with wound dressing have been the recommendation for over a century, and that there are no scientific data to support benefits of such treatments. Colorado State likewise says wound dressings do not benefit a tree in most cases.
Other cut types in the Colorado State fact sheet
Colorado State separates three cuts. Removal cuts, also called thinning or collar cuts, take a side branch back to the trunk or parent branch and preserve the defense zone where there is a collar. Reduction cuts remove a larger branch back to a smaller side branch, and carry a high risk of decay above 2 inches in diameter because the removed branch has no defense zone. Heading cuts, made at a bud, are described as cuts to avoid in most landscape situations.
The fact sheet says all pruning cuts would ideally be on branches 2 inches or less in diameter. Heartwood becomes significant at 2 to 4 inches, and cuts above 4 inches raise the risk of decay organisms colonising the wood.
The ISA pruning BMP
The International Society of Arboriculture's Best Management Practices: Pruning, third edition (2019), by Sharon J. Lilly, Edward F. Gilman and E. Thomas Smiley, runs to 63 pages. ISA describes it as interpreting tree care standards and as a companion to the ANSI A300 Tree Care Standards. Its listed topics include pruning systems, pruning objectives, pruning cuts, pruning practices, poor pruning practices, specifications and a glossary. It replaces the second edition of 2008.
The Tree Care Industry Association, secretariat of A300, describes the standards as practices and specification-writing guidelines.
Sources
- Alex L. Shigo, A Pictorial Primer for Proper Pruning, Forest Notes, Spring 1982, read October 15, 2026
- Colorado State University Extension, Pruning Cuts, read October 15, 2026
- Tree Care Industry Association, ANSI A300 Tree Care Standards page, read October 15, 2026
- International Society of Arboriculture, Best Management Practices: Pruning, Third Edition (2019), store listing, read October 15, 2026