Bare root and balled-and-burlapped trees: what two establishment studies report
A study in Ithaca, New York and a Yale study of 1,159 Philadelphia street trees compared bare root with balled-and-burlapped stock. Survival was high for both; early growth differed by species.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Two studies set bare root trees beside balled-and-burlapped (B&B) trees in city sites. One is a paired planting trial in Ithaca, New York. The other is a survey of trees planted by community groups in Philadelphia. Neither report covers container-grown stock.
The Ithaca paired planting
Michelle Buckstrup and Nina Bassuk published the trial in the Journal of Arboriculture, volume 26, issue 6, in November 2000. They paired 40 mm (1.5 in) caliper B&B and bare root trees of three species on sites around Ithaca. Half were planted in fall and half in spring. The bare root trees got a hydrogel root dip at the nursery to slow root drying after digging.
Survival was excellent in every treatment but one. Spring-planted bare root American hophornbeam had 50% mortality. Growth was measured in August of the first and second growing seasons.
| Species | Season planted | Better first-year growth |
|---|---|---|
| Hackberry | Fall | Bare root |
| Hackberry | Spring | Balled-and-burlapped |
| American hophornbeam | Fall | Equal |
| American hophornbeam | Spring | Balled-and-burlapped |
| Swamp white oak | Both seasons | Balled-and-burlapped, somewhat |
By the end of the second season, very few growth differences between the two stock types remained. Swamp white oak planted in fall grew somewhat better than spring-planted oak, in both stock types.
A separate trial on swamp white oak withheld irrigation from spring-planted pairs. Bare root and B&B trees performed equally after two drought-affected growing seasons.
The Philadelphia street tree survey
Emily Jack-Scott of the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies sampled 1,159 trees of ten species. Philadelphia community groups planted them between 2006 and 2009, guided by the Pennsylvania Horticultural Society. The paper appeared in Cities and the Environment, volume 4, issue 1.
The study starts from cost. Urban tree-planting groups name limited funding as their main obstacle, and many along the eastern United States plant bare root trees as the cheaper option. Bare root trees are also much lighter, which makes them easier for volunteers to handle.
- Survival across all trees was 95%, with no significant difference between B&B and bare root trees.
- Chokecherry, London plane and Amur maple had the highest survival.
- Heavily trafficked streets showed lower survival, canopy cover and live crown.
- B&B trees had larger growth measures, which the author links to their being planted larger than bare root stock.
- Rosaceae species (Amelanchier, Malus and Prunus virginiana) had lower canopy cover.
- Wounds and sidewalk pit cut size were not major factors in trees aged one to five years.
The author concludes that bare root trees are a viable alternative to B&B trees in community-based plantings, and that the findings support larger trees along commercial corridors. The author says campaigns with climate conditions similar to Philadelphia's can use the study to choose stock and species.
Where the two studies line up
Both report high survival for both stock types, and both find growth differences that shrink or trace back to planting size. They differ in design. Ithaca is a paired trial with measured growth over two seasons. Philadelphia is a survey of one to five year old plantings.
Sources
- Buckstrup and Bassuk, Transplanting success of balled-and-burlapped versus bare-root trees in the urban landscape, Journal of Arboriculture 26(6), November 2000, abstract record at Urban Forestry South, read October 16, 2026
- Urban Forestry South, second library record for Buckstrup and Bassuk 2000 (keywords, sub-topics), read October 16, 2026
- Jack-Scott, Survival and Growth Factors Affecting Community-Planted Urban Street Trees, Cities and the Environment 4(1), Loyola Marymount University Digital Commons, read October 16, 2026